3 ms·
>It’s now wrong, but it’s a classic straw man argument (or a cake or cupcake argument really — “should we make cupcakes illegal then?” (Uh. Yes, if they contain
by gruez 3y ago
>It’s now wrong, but it’s a classic straw man argument (or a cake or cupcake argument really — “should we make cupcakes illegal then?” (Uh. Yes, if they contain large amounts of cadmium or lead we absolutely should — you want me to give lead paint in food to your kids?)).
It's ironic that in the course of calling out a straw man, that you went with an example that's the easiest to defeat. What about tuna? They also contain large amounts of heavy metals, so much so that some authorities recommend you only eat a few cans a week. Should we banning tuna as well?
- throwawaaarrgh 3y agoActually, yes, but more because we're causing the species to disappear and they're an integral part of the worldwide biosphere. Systems of systems are kooky.
- richbell 3y agoI suppose the difference is that we openly acknowledge the risks of eating wild fish and dissuade people from consuming too much.
- happytiger 3y agoThis is the answer.
- byproxy 3y agoThe selenium in certain fish (particularly, it seems, tuna) may be enough to offset the adverse effects of the mercury present (known as the "health benefit value of selenium (HBVSe)": https://edis.ifas.ufl.edu/publication/FS437 https://edis.ifas.ufl.edu/publication/FS437