3 ms·
The article unnecessarily conflates two separate pieces of the bureaucracy. The first is management of inputs - work rules, prescribed teaching methods, etc. T
by yummyfajitas 15y ago
The article unnecessarily conflates two separate pieces of the bureaucracy.
The first is management of inputs - work rules, prescribed teaching methods, etc. The second is management of outputs - measurement of student performance and penalties/rewards for teachers who harm/improve this.
The first can certainly be scrapped at the global level (though of course experimentation should continue at lower levels). The second, not so much.
By analogy to programming, it would be silly to hire a programmer and tell him to use Eclipse and make sure all work is performed between 9AM and 6PM. On the other hand, it would be moronic not to give him a detailed description of what you actually want him to build, and put a clause in the contract tying his pay to his product meeting the specs.
- wisty 15y agoYes, but you wouldn't want to measure lines of code.
- yummyfajitas 15y agoNor would you want to measure student performance by class attendance. What's your point?
- wisty 15y agoThat many of the metrics the school system uses are terrible ones, which lead to pathological behavior.
- yummyfajitas 15y agoOk, so fix the metrics. Something interesting that I've observed is that most of the people complaining about metrics are really complaining about the goals of the system. I.e., many people want the school to increase mean(student scores), and then complain when the school attempts to increase count(student score > CUTOFF). If you want the school to have different goals, say so. Don't blame the goals of the system on the existence of metrics.
- jbooth 15y agoYou fix the metrics. You can't argue that metrics should be the be-all and end-all of everything, and a teachers' intuition should count for nothing, when there are all these problems with the metrics we have. Here's a good story: http://www.washingtonpost.com/local/education/creative--motivating-and-fired/2012/02/04/gIQAwzZpvR_story.html http://www.washingtonpost.com/local/education/creative--moti... This teacher was by all accounts a phenomenal teacher, but she was fired because her batch of kids came from a school that had suspiciously high scores the year before, and is currently under investigation for cheating. She didn't maintain that high level of scores so she was fired. Our police system is dominated by metrics and we got The Wire as a result. In education, you hear about cheating scandals in DC, good teachers being fired due to unfortunate statistical conflagrances.. if you're gonna advocate turning your brain off and delegating all decision-making to your metrics, they have to be good.
- yummyfajitas 15y agoThe next time you hire a freelancer, why don't you use his intuition about his own performance rather than measuring whether he actually built what you wanted him to build? ...good teachers being fired due to unfortunate statistical conflagrances.. How do you know they were good? Because they said so, and one of their cronies agreed? This link is relevant: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Principal-agent_problem https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Principal-agent_problem I'll note that you want to scrap objective metrics because they have some problems, but you don't seem to realize "teachers' intuition" also has problems. One of the biggest is comparability - how I can compare the intuition of teacher A with the intuition of teacher B? With standardized tests, the answer is simple arithmetic.
- jbooth 15y agoThe teacher in question was given high marks on review by all her superiors, not just herself. On a freelancer's results, I'm not applying a standardized test to their results so yeah, I am in fact using my intuition an brain about what they built. Metrics are fine, they just shouldn't be fetishized, and we shouldn't allow them to make us fire good teachers. They also shouldn't dominate what's taught to the extent they do. Nation of multiple choice test-takers? That's what we want out of our school system?
- praxeologist 15y agoWhere, specifically, does the article conflate what you are saying? Yes, it would be stupid to not give a teacher or programmer instructions, but we're talking about each individual school not being able to do this, right? Someone at the state level has already decided they want the federal funds tied to complying with whatever initiative and already passed down the order to each school.
- yummyfajitas 15y agoWhere, specifically, does the article conflate what you are saying? They explicitly list both work rules and the need to satisfy minimum test scores in the 6'th and 7'th paragraph. Yes, it would be stupid to not give a teacher or programmer instructions, but we're talking about each individual school not being able to do this, right? Right. Similarly, you don't hire a contractor, and ask him to write the spec for whatever he wants to build. He'll just cook up some easy to meet standard and report success when it's met.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- praxeologist 15y agoYou aren't answering the question, be specific. The article says there that "Law is everywhere in schools." Then, it lists some ways teacher-student interaction is regulated. Then, it mentions how DOE mandated scoring reorients what the teacher does. This isn't conflating. This is showing two different ways the laws (deemed by unelected bureaucrats) affect the culture of the school. >Right. Similarly, you don't hire a contractor, and ask him to write the spec for whatever he wants to build. He'll just cook up some easy to meet standard and report success when it's met. This is a faulty analogy. We're not suggesting teachers just do whatever they want.
- praxeologist 15y agoTypical, a coward votes me down rather than having a counterargument.