9 ms·
Heat pumps can't take the cold? Nordics debunk the myth
- daoboy 3y agoI did not realize this was a myth, but to the extent it is I'm glad it is being addressed. Everyone I know (mostly US midwest) who has one can't say enough good things about them. The main barrier to more widespread use seems to be upfront costs for a a new installation, not concern for efficacy.
- xxpor 3y agoIn the US, the limiting factor in heat pump adoption isn't technical. It's cost. $18-25K for a minisplit with 2 heads is the norm in Seattle. Likely cheaper in other locations, but not by much.
- SketchySeaBeast 3y agoApparently it only cost Oyvind $2,630 including installation? I'd do that tomorrow if that were the case. I'd love a heat pump with a gas backup when we got our week or two of < -30C.
- xxpor 3y agoSeriously. I'd be screaming from the rooftops for everyone to get one.
- amalcon 3y ago> The state now subsidizes heat pumps, which in 2022 were used in just three percent of homes, and sales are beginning to take off. That's probably not the only reason for the difference, but it is probably one reason.
- NorwegianDude 3y agoThat's not a part of the reason. Air-air heat pumps, exhaust air heat pumps and air-water heat pumps is so common that they are excluded. Only new and emerging tech on the market are subsidized. When adoption increases they remove it as the goal is to decrease cost of newer and less common methods.
- einr 3y agoApparently it only cost Oyvind $2,630 including installation? Beware that the article is not very clear and talks about "heat pumps" as a general concept when the term actually encompasses a bunch of different and very differently priced things. What Øyvind gets for $2,630 including installation is a wall-mounted air-to-air heat pump like this one: https://www.polarpumpen.se/varmepumpar/luftvarmepump/mitsubishi-electric-hero-20-ln25-luftvarmepump/p-1547702 https://www.polarpumpen.se/varmepumpar/luftvarmepump/mitsubi... Something like this will be great for heating a single large room, a small house with an open floor plan, or a secondary space like a garage, but is not a system that will handle an entire normal-sized house. But yes, you can get it for $2,630 including installation and it is very efficient at what it does.
- OldSchool 3y agoThe HVAC industry in the US enjoys massive gross margins on this equipment. Prices are supported primarily by licensing laws. You can't legally break into the business, but DIY on your own house is entirely possible: the equipment is available for 1/4 to 1/3 of the "installed" price and some of the more climate-friendly refrigerants do not require an EPA license to purchase. Yes, the work involves electrical, light plumbing and welding, a specialized tool or two, attention to detail, and definitely physical labor, but for a lot of engineers that's just fun stuff to do on a weekend - really fun stuff when you save over $10K per installed system (at the 3-5 ton unit capacity level.)
- SketchySeaBeast 3y agoNot just electrical, 240 V electrical and a possible 200 Amp service upgrade. The really fun "it'll kill you dead" electrical.
- OldSchool 3y agoThe 240V electrical isn’t as scary as it sounds; individually, the hots are no more “hot” relative to ground than a 120V hot (still demands respect!) Certainly it’s not for everyone or even every engineer but I guess my point was that if you’ve already done most of these things yourself it’s not a huge leap to DIY your own HVAC install compared to the financial incentive, especially if your house has more than one system.
- cogman10 3y ago120V will kill you dead, so will 60V.
- SketchySeaBeast 3y agoTrue.
- sidewndr46 3y agoso will 12 volts if conducted through your heart in the right place
- erikprotagonist 3y agoChecking the prices here in Norway a Mitsubishi Uwano 8700 (Mitsubishi's most high-end model) costs 2700 USD before any government rebates. It guaranteed to work down to -30C, but has been tested down to -36C as well. At -25C it produce 6000W. The "SCOP" value of the Mitsubishi is 5.2, so over the heating season it should produce 5.2x as much heat as you otherwise would get for the same amount of electricity. Most of the heatpumps available are about 1200USD cheaper, but only go down to -25C, which really is plenty where most people live (not too far from the coast). Installation typically costs around 600-900USD it seems. Given our 25% sales tax and high wages it should be considerably cheaper in the US.
- SketchySeaBeast 3y agoAh, that's a single room heater, not a whole house, eh?
- bjornasm 3y agoIt has a max capacity of 8700W, if that is just enough to heat a single room you have to look into insulating house better.
- SketchySeaBeast 3y agoWell, our whole house needs about 70,000 BTU, which is ~20,000 W or 10,000 W (assuming it's still 2x efficient) input at -35 C, but our basement and second floor won't care if the living room is the only area getting heat.
- mitthrowaway2 3y agoWhat makes you think it's a single room heater? It looks like a mini-split system to me.
- LazyMans 3y agoA ducted air-source heat-pump shouldn't cost more than 10% on top of a regular AC system. In my case, the heat pump was the same price as the AC only system. Paid about $8k for a new 1.5ton Lennox condenser and furnace on a townhome. Only options are for electric heat on this property. Re-used existing ducting, line set, and power. Old condenser was toast and an r-12 system. Dual fuel/hybrid systems will be pricier, but not needed in Georgia. If designed right, the aux heat will be more than enough to supplement. Poorly sized installations in very poorly insulated homes will need more supplemental heat.
- rcxdude 3y agoThis. Heat pumps are just AC run backwards, and it doesn't take much to make an AC able to run in both directions. The only thing is if you need a lot more heating than you need cooling you may need a larger system. But because they're new a different, as well as in demand, you get price gouging on installation compared to an AC in a lot of places.
- LazyMans 3y agoSubsidies are a real problem, the installers are jacking up the prices, instead of the real subsidies being passed to the consumer. Same thing happened with EV subsidies. You have Kia dealers marking up by exactly the amount the tax credit returns to you.
- mmaurizi 3y agoIf you need a lot more heat than cooling, you can't just get a larger system, you have to also go from single-stage to 2/multi stage or inverter-based, so that you can scale down in the summer so you don't cool too quickly and not dehumidify enough.
- sidewndr46 3y agoHow did you just decide every sales man in North America is limited to a 10% markup on heat pumps?
- xnx 3y agoI've seen similar prohibitively expensive price quotes. While not identical, there are many <$1000 mini split heat pumps on Amazon (DIY installation of course).
- camdat 3y agoHighly recommend DIY'ing it. MrCool et. al are all within the range of someone willing that can handle electrical work on their home. 3 head minisplit (also in Seattle) shipped for ~4.6k
- Sohcahtoa82 3y agoJeez...I bought a hybrid gas + heat pump system a couple years ago for my house in Portland and it was $17K. It's an overkill system, for sure, but the gas was useful when one of the pressure switches in the heat pump failed (covered under warranty!) so I had no heat when it was < 50 degrees outside. Just switched the thermostat to "emergency heat" to force the use of gas, and I stayed warm.
- belval 3y agoThe article lumps a lot of things together and lacks nuance (I have two heatpumps). Wall mounted heat pumps are definitely not great to heat your house because of their placement higher on the wall means that your head is getting blasted with hot air while the air at floor level remains cooler. As a retrofit for a house with electrical heating it's just not as comfortable. As central heating in a newer construction or as a replacement for an older gas furnace it is definitely awesome as it reuses the existing ducting. Finally the "heatpump doesn't work in the cold" is definitly mostly a myth. There are several models that are spec'ed to go all the way down to -25C.
- 0_____0 3y agoI bought property thinking I could retrofit a heat pump air handler onto the existing ducting. Turns out it's all undersized for heat pumps - the air handlers don't heat air as hot as a furnace does, so you need more volume to make up the difference. Thanks for your insight on the wall units- my installer recommended wall units for the bedrooms for some reason (individual control) but I think I'd rather keep everything ducted, and I neglected to remember the difference having a ducted return would make in comfort.
- Filligree 3y agoWhat’s your plan? I’m likely to be facing the same situation soon, so any insight would be valuable.
- 0_____0 3y agoReno'ing a 2 unit house in NE USA, 3300 sqft~ Gut rehab, all new MEP and interiors except floors. Going all-electric. HVAC to be 3x condensers (1 per floor). One air handler in basement, two in attic space, with the entire system being ducted, or if somehow my installer convinces me, all ducted with exception of wall units in 3 of the bedrooms. Going for state and federal tax credits, my state has list of approved equipment. I'm going with Mitsubishi hyper-heat for the low temp performance. Even though it should be fine even w 0F winters they quoted resistive backup heaters for the air handlers. State is going to get more strict about what equipment meets their criteria in 2024, I'm getting in under the gun.
- jpm_sd 3y agoIt's not a myth. The heat pump at my house works great, but it shuts down around 12F (-11C). We don't often hit that temperature in a MA winter these days, but it does happen. Oil burning for backup.
- cogman10 3y agoHow old is the heat pump and is it a central air heat pump or a minisplit?
- btbuilder 3y agoAir sourced heat pump?
- throw0101a 3y agoMitsubishis can work down to -13F/-25C: * https://www.mitsubishicomfort.com/articles/keep-warm-this-winter-inverter-technology-for-any-climate https://www.mitsubishicomfort.com/articles/keep-warm-this-wi... * https://mylinkdrive.com/viewPdf?srcUrl=http://enter.mehvac.com.s3.amazonaws.com/DAMRoot/Original/10006%5CM_SUBMITTAL_MSZ-FS12NA_MUZ-FS12NA_en.pdf https://mylinkdrive.com/viewPdf?srcUrl=http://enter.mehvac.c...
- voisin 3y agoWhat’s the COP at -13F
- throw0101c 3y agoPer the second link PDF, under "Efficiency", 2.08.
- Aldipower 3y agoGood for Norway, but is not directly transferable to other countries. Norway has still one of the cheapest electricity in the world, because of hydroelectricity, oil to electricity and other sources. They heat with electricity since decades, where this for example was unthinkable in Germany. Yes, heat pumps are an improvement compared to radiators of course. Now, in Germany, we powered up our coal power plants again to generate electricity, feeding heat pumps. This is just ridiculous, because we have no hydro power like Norway has. And wind energy isn't enough.
- lukasb 3y agoNuclear power is a great carbon-free option.
- HansLambda 3y agoNuclear power - at least when talking about nuclear fission, not fusion - is a great way of decarbonizing the grid, but I don't know about the long term. Neither I'm sure if renewables are a sustainable way to generate energy. Maybe a mix of both would bring the best benift if we manage to develop the power grid towards a decentralized and smart grid fueld by renewables and backed by nuclear (fusion) power.
- cogman10 3y ago> This is just ridiculous Ridiculous compared to what? Burning fuel at every home? I get the distaste of needing to power up coal plants, but if you want to look at CO2 output of a mixed grid with fossil fuels + renewables vs direct fuel consumption you'll find the CO2 output is going to be much lower on average for the heat pump + seasonal coal plant fire up. That's because even if wind can't fully power all your heat pumps, it is powering a large chunk of them.
- rcxdude 3y agoEven without renewables, burning gas for electricity and using that to power heat pumps can easily be more efficient than burning that gas for heating homes directly, in most climates with commonly available heat pumps. Coal is a bit dirtier, though.
- nottorp 3y agoThe article only compares heat pumps with electric radiator heating though. They're cheaper than the most expensive heating solution and that's it?
- TheMiddleMan 3y agoIt's my understanding that, in ideal but realistic conditions, it's more efficient to burn fuel in a powerplant and use the generated electricity to run a heatpump, than it is to just burn the fuel for heat. Pretty neat!
- einr 3y agoIn a cold climate like Norway, they are literally the cheapest source of heating full stop*, and it's not close. * Except if you own woodland, chop your own firewood, and burn that for heat in a central furnace, which is not actually that uncommon in the rural Nordics
- einr 3y agoWow, I was not even aware this myth was a thing. I'm thoroughly confused. Here in northern Sweden, geothermal heat pumps are seen as pretty much the only viable option for houses that aren't connected to district heating. We get -25 degrees in winter here and it's simply a non-issue. Heat pumps are so dramatically cheaper and more efficient than any other option in cold climates that no one even considers installing electric radiators or oil/gas furnaces. The only other real option that people actually use is a wood or wood pellet furnace. It feels like near enough every home owner I talk to either has or is planning to drill for a geothermal heat pump. Air-air heat pumps are popular too for secondary spaces like garages or if you're on a tight budget. The top five countries in terms of heat pumps per capita all being in northern Europe* should tell you something about this myth: 1. Norway 2. Finland 3. Sweden 4. Estonia 5. Denmark * https://www.theecoexperts.co.uk/heat-pumps/top-countries https://www.theecoexperts.co.uk/heat-pumps/top-countries
- jfengel 3y agoHere in the mid-Atlantic, my air-air heat pump struggles once things get well below freezing. Which it does a few days a year. On those days, there's a backup resistance heater. Which is vastly more expensive, but since it's only run on occasion, it wouldn't be worth it install a geothermal heat pump. I would love to, but the additional cost is tens of thousands of dollars. The since the alternative costs perhaps a couple of hundred dollars per year, the time to breakeven is many decades. It's still quite clear that a heat pump is a very good all-electric option, especially since it provides cooling in the summer. Which is absolutely mandatory around here, and will get more and more so over the years. Which, ironically, will also reduce the use of the resistance heater from "very rare" to "practically never".
- freeone3000 3y agoI mean, kind of. Mine is rated for -20C and despite it being cheaper than resistive[1], it definitely needs a lot of help both to cool baseboards and to deal with temps even at -15C. It still does provide some heat as low as -25C, but not enough to keep the house at +20C. It also doesn’t qualify as a primary heating system where I live due to this — it can’t deal with the week and a half we sit at -30 lows, so you still need a rather heavy resistive heating load. [1] due to prices set by the government, electricity is cheaper than gas for heating in Quebec, BTU per BTU, before any equipment or fees come into play. 6.5c per kwh for the first 40kwh per day is unbeatable.
- itsoktocry 3y agoThis is my experience as well. At around -15C my heat pump will struggle to keep the place as warm as we would like. But, for those rare occasions I still have the gas furnace. Overall, the heat pump has been a money saver.
- ThinkBeat 3y agoThis article is trash. I can't believe it made it to the front page. It includes so many factual errors that it cannot possibly have been generated by AI. 1) I would like to point out that Oslo does not have harsh winters. If you wish to publish an article regarding heat pumps and harsh winters travel a lot farther north. Get into the -30C to -60 territory. Otherwise, you can say "Heat Pumps work in the southern parts of Norway where it gets cold in the winter". I live in Oslo and my heatpump works well. 2) Actually, good parts of Oslo are heated by district heating, Such as my house. Statnett thinks district heating in the northern most part may be more efficient than electricity for heating And some is already up and running. https://www.statkraftvarme.no/om-statkraftvarme/fjernvarmeanlegg/ https://www.statkraftvarme.no/om-statkraftvarme/fjernvarmean... 3) It is highly common in the North to use good old fashioned wood for heating which is a rich source of pollution. https://eng.mst.dk/industry/air/air-polluton-from-stoves https://eng.mst.dk/industry/air/air-polluton-from-stoves 4) Given the photo of the installation and the brochure the person in the picture is pointing to this is probably geothermal heat pump not an air to air heat pump֫ Those are far more energy efficient than air to air.
- throw0101a 3y ago> 1) I would like to point out that Oslo does not have harsh winters. If you wish to publish an article regarding heat pumps and harsh winters travel a lot farther north. Get into the -30C to -60 territory. What is the proportion of population that lives in IECC Zone 7 and above (or equivalent in each country): * https://basc.pnnl.gov/images/iecc-climate-zone-map https://basc.pnnl.gov/images/iecc-climate-zone-map There are folks in Climate Zone 7 in the northern tip of Maine (Caribou) that use heat pumps: * https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OcwIz6heDss&t=43m21s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OcwIz6heDss&t=43m21s Folks running stuff in Alaska: * https://cchrc.org/air-source-heat-pumps/ https://cchrc.org/air-source-heat-pumps/ The design standards are that your system should be able to handle things for 99% of the days (on average), so during maybe up to 4 days your system would be running 100% of the time and still keeping up. The rest of time it's not running as hard. Look up ASHRAE's "design days": * https://www.airequipmentcompany.com/2021/what-does-design-day-really-mean/ https://www.airequipmentcompany.com/2021/what-does-design-da... * https://www.ashrae.org/technical-resources/bookstore/weather-data-center https://www.ashrae.org/technical-resources/bookstore/weather... Are there some portions of the population where a ccASHP won't make sense? Sure: but what population percentage, especially if you invest in some good air sealing and insulation first.
- prossercj 3y agoAnyone using a geothermal heat pump with radiant baseboard heat? I have an existing oil boiler that I would love to upgrade to geothermal, but I don't want to install air ducts. I know some systems exist for this (like WaterFurnace [0]), but I have some concerns about whether it can get hot enough for this kind of system. Haven't spoken to the company who would actually install it, but I'd love to hear any success or failure stories. [0] https://www.waterfurnace.com/residential/products/geothermal-heat-pumps/504w11 https://www.waterfurnace.com/residential/products/geothermal...
- thsksbd 3y agoHeat pumps can heat in cold temperatures, but at decreasing efficiency or COP, which is how much heat you pump from the outside divided by how much heat it took to run the compressor. The theoretical COP is infinite if $\Delta T = 0$, and you can use Carnot to calculate the upper limit otherwise. Now, the whole point of having a heat pump is to have a COP (much) greater than 1 (an excellent furnace has a COP just below 1). Once the difference in ambientT-outsideT becomes large, you approach COP = 1. The heat pumps manufacture will report the actual COP vs $\Delta T$; that is including losses, vs theoretical. Now, a heat pump runs (almost certainly) on main power, and the alternative (usually) on natural gas. It's a simple matter, therefore, to calculate the CO2 and financial cross over point for a heat pump vs. a furnace. I did that calculation when I had one installed in my house (for ductless AC; heating is an added bonus). It's somewhere between about -5 or -10 C, if I recall correctly. Sure, a heat pump can work at -25C but it'll cost more and emit more CO2. This is because, dumb Joule for dumb Joule, natural gas piped to my home is cheaper and cleaner than the same natural gas piped and burned in a thermal power station [1] In my small corner of the world this means that the heat pump is usually better to run than my furnace. But I keep my furnace on anyway, basically set on idle because there is no way that a heat pump can compete with a furnace on reliability. I don't want burst water pipes. In Europe, heat pumps make 100% sense. Even though Europe is significantly north of the US, the winters are mild with few stretches below 0. In contrast, in some parts of the midwest long stretches of -20 C are not impossible. A week at -20 is not unheard of. In this situation Id be loath to have to rely exclusively on heat pumps. [1] actually coal in my case so I fudged it in favor of the HP. Coal is also the case for many of you as well because coal is typically used as marginal power during the winter since it's easy to store and gas pipelines' pressure drop in the winter due to home demand.
- jotato 3y ago> It's a simple matter, therefore, to calculate the CO2 and financial cross over point for a heat pump vs. a furnace. I did that calculation when I had one installed in my house (for ductless AC; heating is an added bonus). It's somewhere between about -5 or -10 C, if I recall correctly. How can I do this? I know my heat pump can only maintain (not raise) my house temp at 36F/2C. But I have yet to figure out at what temp it is cheaper to run my natural gas furnace. I suspect ~40F/5C but that is just a guess (see my comment on parent)
- jotato 3y agoThis is borderline a tangent, but I think manufactures should be required to provide data regarding efficiency at specific temperatures. We moved into a house with a heat pump almost 2 years ago. For the most part it is great, but I noticed that in cold(ish) temps it can't keep up. I'm not talking single digits temperatures. I called the manufacturer and asked for data about my model. They refused to give it to me because I wasn't an authorized installer. It took me a long time and many sensors and calculations later but I have learned that below 36F it can't pull heat fast enough to raise the temperature of my house. The house doesn't get colder - that is the "break even" point. To be fair, it was installed in 2010 and I'm sure it was good for its time. Why can't they just provide a spec that says how much heat/kw can be created at given temps? Even in steps like 10, 20, 30, 40 etc... I think that would go a long way to debunk the myth
- Volundr 3y agoSounds like it was undersized for your house (unless your doing something crazy like trying to hold 80+). FWIW I was able to get efficiency charts and such at various temperatures from my salesperson, but I gather most don't bother. He was pretty surprised when I asked about them and more surprised when I took the time to (kind of) understand them, which was a huge pain in the ass. I certainly understand why most people would pay attention to the SEER values and just let the salesperson size the thing.
- jotato 3y ago> Sounds like it was undersized for your house (unless your doing something crazy like trying to hold 80+). It was set to 69 and held steady at 67 running for 8.5 hours. It wasn't until the temperature outside broke 36 that the inside temp slowly started to climb. It is a 3ton system for a 2500sqft home. From what I have read it should be enough. I think the problem is that it is an older heat pump and just doesn't perform well below 35. > FWIW I was able to get efficiency charts and such at various temperatures from my salesperson, but I gather most don't bother. I think this is my point? This was here when I moved it. I shouldn't have to go to a salesperson. I should be able to look it up in the specs or even the manual. At a minimum the manufacturer should provide it when asked.
- UncleOxidant 3y agoGas Furnace went out in September so I thought I'd get bids on a heat pump to replace it. All 3 places said I was going to have to have a backup heating system for when the temps go under 35F (!). I was kind of surprised by this. Apparently this is because it's a forced air furnace replacement (as opposed to a mini-split). Others told me that if I got a minisplit they'd be good down to around 0F. But since I've already got all that ducting for the air why would I get a minisplit?
- toomuchtodo 3y agoMinisplits are more efficient than ducting because of energy loss from coils/burners to conditioned space (where as minisplit cartridges are typically directly in the room to be conditioned). In renos I've done with minisplits, you seal off the ducting and leave it in place (or if convenient and accessible, remove it, depending on objectives).
- UncleOxidant 3y agoI have the impression that going mini splits would be a lot more expensive than just a drop in replacement for the NG furnace because you've got coils&fans in every room and the tubing needed for all of them.
- toomuchtodo 3y agoJust depends on the property, hard to generalize. Running the math both ways is straightforward prior to implementation.
- eugmill 3y agoMy mini split works to -13F but at 85% of its normal efficiency once it drops below zero. A lot of Canada is on heat pumps and definitely deal with below zero
- itsoktocry 3y agoBut very few Canadian homes are heat pump only.
- nemo44x 3y agoModern heat pumps are great in spaces that are insulated well. Even when very cold outside they can get enough into the space to keep it warm. In spaces with poor insulation then a furnace or boiler is better as they can blast a space full of heat quickly. In my very old home I have areas that are not insulated and a furnace heats them. I have had renovations and those areas are well insulated and a heat pump does great.
- hasbot 3y agoSo many people see old heat pumps struggle and make the assumption that all heat pumps struggle but recent model heat pumps can definitely operate will in sub-freezing temperatures.
- NorwegianDude 3y agoWhat's up with HN and heat pumps? I've seen this multiple times over multiple years. Yes, heat pumps works when it's cold, is that really news? Why? HN is weird when it comes to heat pumps. Here is a fun one: You can increase the overall efficiency by using a heat pump on the exhaust air. That way heat from e.g. your PC can be used multiple times instead of just being thrown away. And yes, active ventilation is needed in well insulated houses as they are quite airtight.
- ZeroGravitas 3y agoOne issue is the "spark gap" in prices, which occurs when taxes and policies are misaligned. It's purely a policy thing but you can end up in silly situations where heat pumps and EVs, which directly replace fossil fuels are getting taxed as if every unit of electricity they use was increasing carbon. Ramping carbon prices and returning the money to people so they have a financial incentive to do the right thing is the pure solution, but subsidies achieve similar effects, and seem to be politically easier. Some detail on the UK spark gap: https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/price-cap-spark-gap-richard-warren https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/price-cap-spark-gap-richard-w...
- c_o_n_v_e_x 3y agoThere's a bit of strawman here. The article is comparing air source vs ground source heat pumps without mentioning the major differences. Yes, heat pumps work in the Nordics ahem with the additional CAPEX cost of installing ground loops. A ground source heat pump is NOT a drop-in replacement like an air source heat pump is. Interestingly, Google spun out a company called Dandelion Energy which focuses on installing ground source / geothermal systems.
- londons_explore 3y agoI want to see heat pumps with multiple heat sources and smart switching between them. For example, a house might have a ground well, a panel on the roof (collecting sun-heat), a thermal storage tank in the basement, an air heat exchanger and a pipe wrapped around the sewage outlet (sewage is warm). The system would then auto select the best place to get heat from to minimise operating costs. This allows time-shifting of heat demand (transfer roof heat to the storage tank in daytime, then into the house at night). It also allows generating electricity when moving heat in the same direction as a heat gradient (eg. Heating the house with water from the storage tank)