3 ms·
Yup. YouTube Premium is exactly what everyone claimed they wanted, and when they released it (at a price of like one sandwich a month) no one wants to pay. This
by paxys 3y ago
Yup. YouTube Premium is exactly what everyone claimed they wanted, and when they released it (at a price of like one sandwich a month) no one wants to pay. This is a perfect example of why straightforward monetization on the internet will never work, and we will be stuck with ads and tracking forever.
- ixwt 3y agoIt left a sour taste for many people when they gutted features from the YouTube app to put them behind the paywall. You used to be able to play videos with the screen off. But it is now required to be on to play videos, unless you have premium. I also don't believe that they make $14/month from that ads that I would have to endure to watch content otherwise. It strongly feels like a premium to not be assaulted with ads to enjoy content.
- kolbe 3y agoThere is a middle ground that Google chooses not to take: reasonable amounts of ethical ads. I don't mind ads that inform people of products. I mind ones that actively seek to harm my life--whether it's by ripping me off or encouraging my use of drugs and alcohol--which is 90% of what I see. But if I (someone who has been alcohol free for over a decade) have to watch 30 seconds of people living a happy and prosperous life drinking whiskey, it's them trying to hurt me.
- bananapub 3y ago> There is a middle ground that Google chooses not to take: reasonable amounts of ethical ads. where can I see an example of this sort of thing, using ads you approve of, that scales to generating tens of billions of USD a year (to cover the costs of running YouTube)?
- kolbe 3y agoThere's a reasonable way to ask this question without being a child about it. If you want to talk, we can. But I'm not going to engage someone resorting to absurdities like equating "ads I don't approve of" with ones that actively seek to harm their viewers.
- elondaits 3y agoI agree, but it shouldn’t be YouTube’s decision, because they can change their mind when the numbers are red or the CEO changes. Your government should establish those limits, so they apply in perpetuity and across all online and broadcast services.
- jsbisviewtiful 3y agoSure - but YouTube has been around so long that most users started using YouTube many years ago for free and without being absolutely pummeled by ads - being forced to watch 5 ads for a 6 minute video kind of pummeled. I personally don't find enough value in YouTube content to warrant yet another $15+/month subscription, so I don't mind watching a few ads - even though those ads often have no relevance to my needs. However, the level of ad intrusion on the free tier doesn't make me want to pay for YouTube. Rather, I just don't want to use the service at all anymore.
- okdood64 3y agoAgreed. People will do all sorts of mental gymnastics to justify them expecting a service without offering nothing in return. (I say this as someone who used to live a life on the high seas, but now happily pay for Premium.) Check out r/youtube, for example.