3 ms·
No, YouTube is happy to sell me a music streaming subscription I have no intention of ever touching together with the ad-free video streaming subscription I am
by lxgr 3y ago
No, YouTube is happy to sell me a music streaming subscription I have no intention of ever touching together with the ad-free video streaming subscription I am willing to pay for.
This also makes it completely opaque who gets my money at the end of the month, assuming I only use the video part: Only video creators? Or am I just paying into a global pot that is divided proportionally, i.e. would I end up paying x% for music despite neither wanting nor using that on YouTube?
Imagine Steam making you buy a movie download with every game you purchase, or Amazon requiring you to buy a box of cupcakes with every Kindle book. (Actually Amazon requiring me to pay for a video streaming service for expedited deliveries isn't too far off... Not that I'm too thrilled about that.)
- mickeyfrac 3y agoI think the idea is you won’t listen to music and watch videos at the same time. So think of it like Google Content with 2 sub categories.
- delecti 3y agoI'm sorry, but those complaints are nonsense. Either the price is worth what you'd get out of it, or it isn't. My internet provider doesn't tell me the breakdown of infrastructure/profit/uplink costs. My Netflix bill doesn't tell me the breakdown of new content creation, content licensing, video game development/licensing, infrastructure costs, profits, etc. Should I complain about Netflix making a multi-movie contract with Adam Sandler because he happens to not be my taste? You're complaining about a fantasy you invented not existing.
- lxgr 3y agoWell, it isn’t worth it for me, and I doubt that the inclusion of music is making the bundle cheaper than video by itself. The fact that there are other bundle-only deals available in the world, some of which are worth it for me and others which aren’t, has no bearing on the fact that I dislike this particular one, and Google is losing my business as a direct result of their bundling. > My internet provider doesn't tell me the breakdown of infrastructure/profit/uplink costs. A more appropriate comparison would be an ISP that also forces a Netflix or cable TV subscription onto you. In fact, my ISP offers both TV+internet bundles and internet only. If they would only offer the former, I’d switch to the competition unless it was somehow the same price as an internet-only competitor.