2 ms·
How does pointing to rainbow tables indicate that salt should be secret? That's one of the things that salt prevents, and it does it without being secret. A 32
by dpark 15y ago
How does pointing to rainbow tables indicate that salt should be secret? That's one of the things that salt prevents, and it does it without being secret. A 32-char random salt could be publicly published for each of your users and it would still do its job. Secrecy doesn't matter.
Data integrity is not trustworthiness. Data integrity means I got what you said I should get, not that you are trustworthy (and therefore I can trust what I got from you). If you want secure assurance that you got what I really sent, then you need secure assurance that I am who I say I am, and no hash will get that. You need a signed file (or hash). A hash by itself is indeed nothing but a robust a checksum in this case.
There's no point in arguing about the md5 for downloads. You're assuming that it's for security, and it's really not. It's primarily for people who are paranoid about corruption. It is also useful for validating when downloading from a mirror, though.
- donpark 15y agoLet's just stop here. Given that we can't even agree on meaning of words, I think continuing this discussion will produce only further disagreements or misunderstandings. I do, however, appreciate your cordial and elaborate responses for which I thank you.