45 ms·
> Can someone explain again how an ML system scanning and training on a copyrighted work is different from a highly skilled artist doing the same? Its legally
by dragonwriter 3y ago
> Can someone explain again how an ML system scanning and training on a copyrighted work is different from a highly skilled artist doing the same?
Its legally different because the human brain is not considered a fixed medium under copyright law, so a human experiencing and learning something is not making what is potentially a copy or derivative work under copyright law, and therefore not exercising, potentially without permission, one of the exclusive rights granted to the copyright holder.
> There are artists that can study a painting for a few minutes and then recreate it from memory
Right, and those artists violate copyright at the moment they recreate it in a fixed medium without permission, but encoding it into computer storage media is already a copy, so a machine (or, rather, the person using the machine) hits that threshold before creating an actual visual output.
> That is, we focus on the output of the process to determine infringement
No, we focus on what is set in a fixed medium. If that is done at an intermediate step of the process, rather than being an output, it can still be infringement.
Its just that a human doesn’t always need to make a copy in what is legally a fixed medium until the output, but that is not the same as categorically only treating outout of a process as legally relevant.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- jncfhnb 3y agoPeople betting on all “lossy compression” being equivalent will lose. It’s a lame argument. Can you encode images to be basically 1:1 with embeddings? Absolutely. Is that what these embeddings are doing? No. If artists try to argue that all copies are equivalent, but are unable to recreate their works from the embeddings, their argument will fall flat. This argument also only applies to sharing models, which is doubly dumb because we want open source models, not closed source models. It’s a harmful status quo to try and enforce.