11 ms·
The HDI of Thailand in 2023 is 0.802 while that of the PRC is 0.768. The HDI of the poorest region of Thailand (Northeast Thailand/Isan) is 0.780. The only pro
by alephnerd 3y ago
The HDI of Thailand in 2023 is 0.802 while that of the PRC is 0.768.
The HDI of the poorest region of Thailand (Northeast Thailand/Isan) is 0.780. The only provinces in Mainland China that have a comparable HDI are Zhejiang, Liaoang, Guangdong, and Jiangsu. Every other province of China has a lower HDI than the poorest province of Thailand. The only provinces in China that can match Thailand's HDI are Zhejiang, Jiangsu, and Guangdong yet still lag behind Bangkok region.
The average life expectancy in China still lags by 1-2 years compared to Thailand.
The median income in Thailand is around $7,000 [0] versus around $4,000 [1] in China
> How is that? China has overly concentrated wealth, basically?
Kinda. The Chinese development story is amazing. China basically went from undeveloped in 1990 to middle income by 2020. In 1 generation that is an amazing transformation. Yet, the low hanging fruits of reform and development have largely been harvested.
Now comes the hard part - building a welfare system, reforming business and taxation law, tamping down on corruption, investing in human capital.
Thailand, South Korea, and Malaysia were all in a similar position in the 1990s during the Asian Financial Boom (caused by Japan's stagflation) and the subsequent Crash. South Korea was able to develop by working on the hard part above for a generation, but internal poltical strife in Thailand and Malaysia caused them both to fall behind their peer.
It takes around 2-3 generations to actually go from undeveloped to developed. Some countries can do it in 1.5-2 generations, but then they are still stuck with jurisdictional bad practices (SK, Israel, and Poland are notable examples).
[0] - http://statbbi.nso.go.th/staticreport/page/sector/th/08.aspx http://statbbi.nso.go.th/staticreport/page/sector/th/08.aspx
[1] - http://www.stats.gov.cn/english/PressRelease/202201/t20220118_1826649.html http://www.stats.gov.cn/english/PressRelease/202201/t2022011...
- z2 3y agoJust a minor nit on the provinces, you excluded Beijing, Tianjin, and Shanghai which have province level status and almost 60 million in population combined, close to Thailand's 70 million, and a weighted average HDI of 0.87. Heterogeneity is and perhaps will always be a thing for China, and part of the question is if the poor parts have any low hanging fruit left to mimic the success of the earlier-developed and now high HDI areas, or have those fruit withered by now.
- alephnerd 3y agoGood catch! I left Beijing, Shanghai, and Tianjin out due to the fact that they are governed differently than provinces, as they are under direct administration of the State Council and they are almost 100% urban. This makes them a bad comparison with Thailand as a whole. At a micro level, it might be interesting to compare BKK versus Beijing/Shanghai/Tianjin but Thailand allows free movement and domiciling, so it's not a great comparison. > the question is if the poor parts have any low hanging fruit left to mimic the success of the earlier-developed and now high HDI areas, or have those fruit withered by now It's a tough question and depends province to province. The provinces around Manchuria are probably all tapped out, but there might be some opportunity left in Guizhou, Yunnan, Sichuan, and Guangxi, but local and mid-level governance in China (like other middle income countries) sucks. I have written a lot about this in a previous life, but I'd rather not write a whole Econometrics white paper on HN
- z2 3y agoTrue! This is well outside of the original point, but Beijing and Tianjin are interesting cases and perhaps useful for regional aggregates because they are essentially black holes that have taken GDP and capital out of their surrounding areas, explaining some portion of the neighboring provinces' underperformance. Kind of like how New York state would look very different without New York City maybe? https://www.npr.org/sections/parallels/2017/04/16/523632920/beijing-mega-region-plan-aims-to-alleviate-poverty-but-some-are-wary https://www.npr.org/sections/parallels/2017/04/16/523632920/...
- alephnerd 3y agoExactly! This can be seen first hand with Beijing+Tianjin versus Hebei. Those 2 cities were under direct State Council control so it was easier to push economic reforms versus a largely rural province like Hebei, plus they were close enough that it made sense for anyone half ambitious in Hebei to leave for the big city than to stay back. This is what happened in NY State as well with NYC and IL with Chicago. It's called the primate effect in economics.