3 ms·
Sure, and that deserves more critique than this. But the critique there is that you're being marketed a product under false pretenses. I'll give you an example
by godelski 3y ago
Sure, and that deserves more critique than this. But the critique there is that you're being marketed a product under false pretenses. I'll give you an example to help clarify. In another thread[0] the OP is showing off their ML programming assistant. The project is unquestionably cool and has every right to be on the front page of HN. But there are still major questions I have. The implicit critique here comes form the fact that the author says "beats GPT 4 at coding" but then their basis for this claim is simply via HumanEval performance. In reality the evidence does not support the claim (it doesn't say the contrary either, it simply is indeterminate -- not to be confused with orthogonal/irrelevant). This is marketing. I'm not sure if it is dishonest marketing, but I would not call it honest marketing either. It's in the gray. The thread originally had an intro from OP who was specifically requesting comments too and so the context is appropriate, other than the nature of simply being on HN.
[0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38091869 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38091869