2 ms·
> This is not a Bad Thing (tm) I wholeheartedly agree. I am often one to critique ML systems, especially LLMs and GPT. But this is my training as a researcher.
by godelski 3y ago
> This is not a Bad Thing (tm)
I wholeheartedly agree. I am often one to critique ML systems, especially LLMs and GPT. But this is my training as a researcher. I think it is important that we recognize critiques and discussions of limitations are not equivalent to calling a tool useless or worthless. It does not even devalue the tool. Rather the discussions are beneficial for two contexts: we learn the limitations to build better tools (since no tool is perfect there will always be critiques available) and we learn how to use the tool effectively (you're still not going to use LLMs to do you differential equations homework despite this certainly being within the training set). There's also the important context that we are on a tech form in a community that is well known to be inhabited by the exact type of people that build, test, and deploy these types of systems (myself included). These are not the same discussions we'd be having in the context of sitting around with my parents who are absolutely tech illiterate.
My thoughts as a highly critical person (check my history, or even a very recent highly relevant comment in another thread) are "this is pretty fucking cool" (same to that very same thread btw). I hope to see more stuff like this. It is what makes me passionate about ML and it is what keeps me coming to HN.
Your work doesn't need to be novel to be useful. Nor does it need to be useful to be good. I'm just happy to be seeing people do shit and having fun.