4 ms·
There are some comments here critical of the article (calling it insane, asking how dare people ask how to make a profit off of WWIII), but they seem to be misu
by crazygringo 3y ago
There are some comments here critical of the article (calling it insane, asking how dare people ask how to make a profit off of WWIII), but they seem to be misunderstanding it entirely.
This isn't an article about how to make money off of WWIII, and it goes out of its way to "of course place financial damage a long way down the list of horrors."
The article is actually about how the degree of current political instability that could lead to a WWIII-type situation isn't reflected in current markets at all, and so raises the important question:
1) Are markets correct, and there isn't really any risk of WWIII right now? Is it all unwarranted fear and hype?
2) Or is there a real risk of WWIII, but markets are bad at predicting geopolitical disruption of that potential magnitude?
The article then concludes that the second position is more likely -- don't use a lack of market movement to underestimate the potential for global war, as if it were an accurate prediction market. Because in an actual nuclear war, financial markets cease to mean anything at all.
- sgjohnson 3y ago> Because in an actual nuclear war, financial markets cease to mean anything at all. That would largely depend on the sides getting hit with the nukes.
- zabzonk 3y agoum, all of them?
- ajsnigrutin 3y agoBefore nukes, with conventional weapons... sure... with enough nukes... we're all fucked, no matter how far away from the targets you are.
- rhelz 3y agoAnybody within hundreds of miles of New York, London, Frankfurt, and Shanghai would be dead. That's just 4 h-bombs, and thousands would be exploded. Get a grip man, any war between any two nuclear powers simply cannot be priced into markets. Surely to determine a market price for anything presupposes the existence of the market.
- thmsths 3y agoNukes are powerful but not that powerful, most modern nukes are under a megaton because more power does not scale well in regards to more destruction, instead we moved to multiple smaller warheads. According to nukemap[1] a Russian SS25 with a 880kt yield would devastate NYC city but not much more. Furthermore, a good argument can be made that a counterforce strike (a strike aimed mostly at military objectives and command and control infrstracture) is more probable than a countervalue strike (a strike targeting large cities and economic and industrial centers). [1] https://nuclearsecrecy.com/nukemap/?&kt=800&lat=40.72422&lng=-73.9961&hob_psi=5&hob_ft=9511&ff=50&psi=20,5,1&zm=9.960699143345442 https://nuclearsecrecy.com/nukemap/?&kt=800&lat=40.72422&lng...
- rurp 3y agoThis line of thinking terrifies me. Nuclear war between major powers would be the end of the world as we know it, full stop. Russia and China know that if they launch a nuke at New York the response will be overwhelming, so their only shot at surviving retaliation would be to hope that a first strike can be definitive. They are never launching four nukes at American cities. If they launch at all it will be hundreds. At that point, the destruction will be so immense that most people outside of the blast zones will be in for an awfully rough time for whatever remains of their lifetime.
- thmsths 3y agoOh just to be clear, I fully agree. I brought up the counterforce vs countervalue topic because I thought it was an interesting way to further the discussion. But I have to admit that the arguments in favor of "they would only target our silos and major bases" never really convinced me. I just wanted to point out that nuclear weapons aren't that powerful and can't destroy an area hundreds of miles in diameter. The real danger as you said is that major powers have huge stockpiles and can basically afford to blanket an entire continent with warheads. Which mean guaranteed game over for both parties.
- FFP999 3y ago[dead]
- willprice89 3y agoAgree, but I think the title chosen for the article shows that the editor was hoping for such a knee-jerk reaction.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- beebeepka 3y agoYou're right. Understanding how a WW3 would affect investors is of utmost importance. Who cares about death, destruction, radiation and stuff. The most important thing is protecting the investments. A lot of sociopaths on this site.
- ajsnigrutin 3y ago> 1) Are markets correct, and there isn't really any risk of WWWIII right now? Is it all unwarranted fear and hype? This should be compared to more recent events (since markets change, trade changes, and with current markets, with stock ownership lasting milliseconds, things are drastically different). How did markets act before the 2008 crisis? Did they predict it (in hindsight at last), or was it "great" until "whoops" and "taxpayers help"?
- The_Colonel 3y agoI guess it's at least in part caused by the fact the article is behind a paywall and people read the title only. > Because in an actual nuclear war, financial markets cease to mean anything at all. I think this is a false dichotomy. Both US and Russia/Soviet Union believe (or at minimum believed at some points) that a limited nuclear war is possible without triggering all-out exchange. In such a scenario, the markets would crash, but likely survive.
- ParanoidAltoid 3y ago>https://www.metaculus.com/questions/2534/world-war-three-before-2050/ https://www.metaculus.com/questions/2534/world-war-three-bef... Metaculus hasn't moved at all. There's some recent comments debating why this is, and some posting reasons to think the market should move upwards. My guess is this is some evidence for no WWIII, though metaculus can easily be assumed to be at least 10% off at any given moment, given that it's play money and relies on the interest of it's users. And they might not be interested in using their play money on long-term predictions. The needle has moved on nuclear detonation by 2050: https://www.metaculus.com/questions/4779/at-least-1-nuclear-detonation-in-war-by-2050/ https://www.metaculus.com/questions/4779/at-least-1-nuclear-... I'm no geopolitics expert, there might be a reason why nukes went up but not WWIII. Or it might just be that nukes has one-third the activity and so is more moveable. Not sure which of the two to take more seriously.