4 ms·
> that requires you to surrender some of your most precious human rights in order to access it I'm genuinely curious, which human rights? I created an account,
by crazygringo 15y ago
> that requires you to surrender some of your most precious human rights in order to access it
I'm genuinely curious, which human rights? I created an account, don't really use it... and don't feel like I've had any human rights taken away.
- tedunangst 15y agoThere's a distinction between having something taken and giving it freely. Facebook haters have the cognitive ability to make this distinction, but lack the integrity to do so.
- tikhonj 15y agoAd hominems never help your argument but do degrade the discussion. Please avoid them. The idea of "giving away" a right is not that simple--for example, I think there are certain rights you cannot legally waive. Even if what Facebook is doing is legal (which it probably is), this same principle can reasonably be extended to condemn what they are doing from an ethical standpoint. Additionally, Facebook does not only affect the people using it. Information about people without accounts (provided by people with accounts) is still archived and searchable, potentially by unsavory entities. For these people, a certain right to privacy is basically taken away, and certainly not given away.
- tedunangst 15y agoI'm serious. Deliberately failing to make that distinction is intellectually dishonest, and that degrades the discussion. As to your second point, Facebook is not running around taking pictures of you. Your friends are. If your privacy is being violated, it's your friends (to use the term loosely) who are doing it. Facebook provides a platform, but they are not the primary actor. That's another distinction I don't see being made frequently enough.
- 9999 15y agoPrivacy and free speech.
- mikeash 15y agoI see privacy, but how do you give up free speech?
- 9999 15y agoCan you post a picture with nudity in it? No? There you go.
- mikeash 15y agoOf course. Not to Facebook, but free speech doesn't imply a particular venue.
- mike_ivanov 15y agoSo I assume you can post a picture with nudity on the NYT website?
- taligent 15y agoThis has to be the most vapid and ridiculous example of free speech I've heard in a while. The reason nudity is not allowed is because minors are on Facebook and it would be illegal to do so.
- getsat 15y agoWTF? Freedom of speech is freedom from censorship by the government. Even that has restrictions, though. You can't incite violence against other people or cause other people to come to harm through your speech (yelling "Fire!" in a theatre being the canonical example). You're agreeing to Facebook's Terms of Service when you use their site. You are agreeing not to upload that kind of content when you sign up.