3 ms·
I disagree completely -- there's no significant money to be made here. Microsoft wouldn't even bother if this were a financial play, it's so small. Not that man
by crazygringo 3y ago
I disagree completely -- there's no significant money to be made here. Microsoft wouldn't even bother if this were a financial play, it's so small. Not that many people use non-Xbox controllers to begin with, and whatever licensing fees Microsoft will charge manufacturers may very well be offset by the costs of running the licensing program itself.
This seems very clearly to be anti-cheat. Advantages are not "trivial to detect" "after only a few minutes" -- there's tons of issues with false positives and false negatives. Any software detection, cheaters can learn how to go right up to the line but not cross it, and that still gives them big advantages, while genuinely really good players get unfairly banned.
This is a single-purpose gaming console, not a general-computing device. One of the big benefits of console gaming is precisely protecting gamers against cheats, which makes it different from PC gaming. Microsoft wants a fair gaming experience for everyone, which makes it more fun for everyone who wants to play fair. If your idea of fun in gaming is cheating, then use a PC instead.
- lxgr 3y ago> there's no significant money to be made here [...] Not that many people use non-Xbox controllers to begin with, and whatever licensing fees Microsoft will charge manufacturers may very well be offset by the costs of running the licensing program itself. Ah yes, original (or licensed) game console accessories, the well known non-profit operation... Yes, console prices are sometimes subsidized, but never accessories, quite the opposite. Or do you seriously believe that it costs MS or Sony $70 and more to manufacture a wireless gamepad?
- com2kid 3y agoI actually used to work with the team who made Xbox 360 controllers. Things have probably changed in the decade since, but back then I was told that MS was only making $3 or $4 profit per controller sold. Money was made in volume, not on individual units. To explain this, imagine a consumer electronics device that costs $5 to make. The manufacturer then sells it to a distributor for $10. The distributor sells it to the store for $20. The store sells it to you for $40. The original company making the device only nets the $5, but that doesn't include other costs. For example any fancy in-stores displays stands are put there by the manufacturer and come out for their initial $5 cut.
- crazygringo 3y agoAn official Xbox controller is usually around $50 on Amazon, and currently $54.99 from Microsoft, and that price is very much in line with comparable peripherals from other companies on Amazon (Logitech etc.). The Xbox controller build quality is excellent, and when you look at all the features like custom low-latency headset audio and extension capabilities, it's nothing like the generic controllers that are $30-40 and often wired and made of cheap plastic. The idea that Microsoft is making a huge profit off of their own basic controllers just doesn't hold water. If the basic controller cost $99 then sure they would be. But that's not what they're charging. (I mean, you can buy a pricey Elite controller if you want, but that's not what we're talking about here.)
- lobocinza 3y agoMaybe it will eventually cost $99
- sparky_z 3y agoIf that were the only reason, they could just ban them from online play. There's no good reason to also ban them for single-player experiences .
- crazygringo 3y agoI think the reason is the complexity of it, of dealing with controllers that work for some things but not for others. It creates customer confusion and opportunities for sales deception, people will keep buying controllers they expect to "just work" and then get pissed off as soon as they go into multiplayer because they didn't read the fine print. It's not a distinction that your average Joe consumer should need to worry about.
- TheR3alGambit 3y agoGreat example is Sony who have such a poor reporting system in place and mnk had destroyed shooters on PlayStation to a point I have crossplay off on siege. I see way more mnk on ps than I do on Xbox.