5 ms·
Strikebreakers arrived by taxi to Tesla's workshops in Sweden
- diggan 3y agoTranslation for the 99% who don't happen to speak Swedish: > Strike escalated on Monday - "Tesla has brought people here" > Unknown people in workshop clothes reportedly arrived by taxi on Monday morning at several Tesla workshops, according to picketers around the country. > - "There are strikebreakers working inside the premises right now," says Carola Andersson, chair of IF Metall in Umeå. > Around eight o'clock on Monday morning, a taxi arrived at the Tesla car workshop in Umeå, where almost all workers went on strike on Friday. Picketers from the trade union IF Metall noticed four people, dressed in workshop clothes, getting out of the car and entering the workshop. > - We have at least five strikebreakers here who have come from somewhere else. They are completely new guys who have not been here before. They work with Tesla clothes on inside the workshop. Extensive strikebreaking," he says. > - "We discovered that overtime was planned for the weekend, so we had picketers there on Saturday and were then told that there was also work on Sunday. We can't know one hundred percent that it was workshop work, but I saw with my own eyes that cars were being driven out of the service doors," says Karl-Henrik Rosberg, IF Metall's ombudsman in Gothenburg. IF Metall is one of the largest trade unions in Sweden, and the union involved with Tesla right now.
- ActionHank 3y agoIsn't this just the norm though? Most companies seem to do this to keep things ticking over whilst strike action is ongoing, is strikebreaking illegal in Sweden?
- tmikaeld 3y agoIt's not illegal, but it's frowned upon.
- tom_ 3y agoIs "scabs" not editorialisation? It's rarely used other than in a derogatory fashion.
- bdcravens 3y agoAccording to Google Translate (and OP's comment), the title should be "The strike escalated on Monday - 'Tesla has brought people here'"
- hotnfresh 3y agoThe neutral descriptive term for a bad thing still tends to be colored negatively. E.g. murderer.
- thepasswordis 3y agoA “scab” is a person who works for a company when other people are trying to extort that company for higher wages. The “scab” is fine with the current wage. Scab is definitely a derogatory term for a non union worker.
- gizajob 3y agoStriking isn't extortion. Same as capitalists trying to keep their costs as close to zero as possible isn't extortion.
- thepasswordis 3y agoYeah I agree this word has a negative connotation but I’m not sure if another one. They’re trying to collectively quit working at the same time (and use government power to force the company not to actually terminate them) as a way of pressuring a company to raise their wages. It feels like holding a company hostage? Like for instance a protection racket: this feels identical (pay us or you lose your business) is engaging in the same thing, but feels “worse”. I think the thing that makes this extortion for me is the government involvement. If it was just “we aren’t willing to work for that wage anymore”, that’s just bargaining.
- bragr 3y agoI'm slightly confused by the tone, but perhaps it's the machine translation. Is strike breaking illegal in Sweden or are they just surprised that it has happened? Is strike breaking very unusual in Sweden? Because as an American, this is exactly what I expect Tesla to do.
- striking 3y agohttps://www.thelocal.se/20231027/tesla-threatens-to-bring-in-strikebreakers-as-swedish-workers-strike https://www.thelocal.se/20231027/tesla-threatens-to-bring-in... > "If they bring in strikebreakers then that's completely unique," IF Metall's bargaining agreement secretary, Veli-Pekka Säikkälä, told the newspaper. "That would be crossing all boundaries. That kind of thing happened in Sweden in the 1920s and 30s." > "If they start employing strikebreakers and actively try to break the strike, then they have mobilised the entire union movement against them. Not just the Swedish Trade Union Confederation, but all of them. Then the issue at hand becomes less important."
- eesmith 3y agoFurther HN discussion about that link at https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38036143 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38036143 .
- mcv 3y agoI think strike breaking is pretty much not-done in most of Europe, and hasn't been done for nearly a century. How this will play out is not something I can predict, but it's definitely an escalation and could result in massive boycotts and the end of Tesla in Sweden. It's certainly not a constructive step towards resolving the conflict.
- bitshiftfaced 3y agoIsn't the alternative just not repairing cars or doing maintenance? In the long run, that's equivalent to not doing business in Sweden anyway isn't it?
- zer00eyz 3y agohttps://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38070432 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38070432 It's gonna be interesting to get some clarity on this topic.
- sorenjan 3y agoThe source is teslaclubsweden.com[0], not exactly impartial journalism. The comments to that article doesn't agree with it either, here's some top level comments translated to english: My colleague who is still working says that Tesla is lying today. Half the staff is gone and those who are working are stressing themselves to death. Ingem takes care of the employees. He is going to resign. Mafia methods against those who want to go on strike: giving access cards, keys, etc. Threats and harassment - Managers have threatened that you will be dismissed if you participate in the conflict. They also have an option program where you get shares for X number of years. They have also threatened to withdraw this if you take part in the conflict as an employee. [0] https://teslaclubsweden.se/strejken-som-inte-fanns/ https://teslaclubsweden.se/strejken-som-inte-fanns/
- brightball 3y agoIt's more shocking to me that anyone is surprised by this. When you take an action as aggressive as a strike, what exactly prevents the company from making an aggressive action in response. A strike is your way of saying, "You need us and we're going to exploit that need to accomplish our goals." The company bringing in other people who will happily do the work in your place is their way of saying, "I guess we'll see if you're right." If you play chess, the other player gets moves too.
- gizajob 3y agoYes but the players in this case are unionised, same as the workers in all the companies that Tesla need to use in Sweden. It's not a great strategy to break a strike when you depend on other companies, and those other companies then face the risk of strikes from doing business with you. Furthermore, if your customers are also heavily unionised, then they won't want to buy your products.
- soco 3y agoEven in chess, if you slam the table all bets are out.
- sorenjan 3y agoGo to war with European unions and then try to keep doing business as usual. Another union (Transport) has announced that they will stop unloading Tesla cars from ships in Swedish harbors starting November 7, and that's just the first sympathy measure. IF Metall and Tesla will continue negotiations again tomorrow, so maybe Tesla signs a deal before then.
- rsynnott 3y ago> When you take an action as aggressive as a strike, what exactly prevents the company from making an aggressive action in response. In that part of the world, the implicit threat of further escalation from the other side.
- occz 3y agoThis is probably not going to turn out well for Tesla. As a point of reference, check out the story on how Toys'R'Us, which had a blanket no union-policy in the 90s, faired against the Swedish unions: https://www.huffpost.com/archive/ca/entry/what-canada-can-learn-from-swedens-unionized-retail-workers_n_6888328 https://www.huffpost.com/archive/ca/entry/what-canada-can-le... tl;dr: every single Swedish union had their members refuse to interact with the company, leaving them completely blocked out from the Swedish market until they backed off. I would not be surprised to see a repeat of that story this time around - the unions really don't want to let this become a precedent. Best case scenario, Musk gets humiliated again.
- vextea 3y agoWorth noting that Transport (different union but also affiliated like IF Metall with LO) already signaled that they'll go on a sympathy strike at several of the largest shipping terminals refusing to (un)load freight destined to Tesla.
- codeduck 3y agoHah, yep, and so the snowball starts rolling.
- LeanderK 3y agoI really don't get how a blanket no union-policy is legal? Wouldn't this just deny the workers basic rights (to unionise)? To me it feels like "blanket no minimum wage policy" or "blanket no workplace-safety standards policy". Wether to form a union, and collectively bargain, should be the decision of the workers without any say of the corporations. It really feels to me like "I am sorry about you trying to establish workplace safety standards but we unfortunately follow a global no workplace-safety standards policy and do not agree to minimum workplace safety standards in other parts of the world".
- occz 3y agoMods/admins - why do all union-related stories on HN keep getting buried as soon as they pick up steam? Could it have something to do with the political convictions of the owners?
- diggan 3y agoI've noticed this as well, but didn't want to make any claims either way. But seems this story it the frontpage and disappeared quickly. I'm guessing the comment/votes ratio wasn't good enough, or some people flagged the submission for some reason which makes things disappear from the frontpage quickly.
- occz 3y agoPretty sure it's foul play at this point. It keeps happening to literally every story about unionization.