5 ms·
.US harbors prolific malicious link shortening service
- gamache 3y agoThe .us TLD is trash. I've walked away and am just letting my .us domains expire. Fun fact: they, in contrast to just about every other TLD, refuse to redact WHOIS information. Having my address and phone number connected to my domains is so fun! I feel so young again.
- VWWHFSfQ 3y agoWHOIS for .us domains are required to be public information. That's by design. If you want WHOIS privacy you can register a .me or something.
- gamache 3y agoSure, I can register a .me, or a .com, or a .net, or a .org, or like 100 other TLDs. I don't have this issue except on .us. WHOIS redaction is a standard feature of domain registrars these days, about N-1 TLDs support it, and like you said I can vote with my feet (and I am).
- kube-system 3y agoThere are hundreds of TLDs that prohibit proxy registrations. .us is one of many. e.g. https://www.domain.com/help/article/domain-management-tlds-not-supporting-privacy https://www.domain.com/help/article/domain-management-tlds-n... It is quite logical for TLDs with nexus requirements. Not every TLD operates like a free-for-all in the way some of the more popular gTLDs do.
- ssnepenthe 3y agoSomething I've been wondering about lately - maybe you have some insight into how this works? The .in TLD doesn't allow privacy protection as seen in the list you linked above but whois still shows "Redacted for Privacy Purposes" for everything but the country and state/province of the registrant.
- kube-system 3y agoI'm not sure about .in specifically, but it is worth noting that the information you are required to provide to register a domain and the information that is published on WHOIS is not necessarily the same.
- freedomben 3y agoGP basically already said that
- tivert 3y ago> Having my address and phone number connected to my domains is so fun! I feel so young again. I have a .us. I solved that by getting a PO Box and a Google Voice number (which doesn't ring my phone, and I think might actually be dead now).
- mminer237 3y agoRequiring public WHOIS information for .us was like half the article. It notes at the end how the NTIA is currently considering changing the rule and looking for comments as well as how security experts have been opposing it for potentially worsening the spam problem.
- someotherperson 3y agoIt's funny -- I saw the headline and immediately did a CTRL+F for NameCheap. It's the same registrar again and again[0] for what seems like years now[0]. [0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32626618 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32626618 [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24231307 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24231307
- eli 3y agoIt's the largest registrar after godaddy, and godaddy is overpriced
- px43 3y agoGodaddy is also, IMO, way worse. After a forum I was on got flooded with CSAM shit, I did some hunting and found out it was all hosted on Godaddy hosting. I collected all the info and sent it to them, and got silence. I checked around, and it sounds like tons of people had done the same thing, and the ones who got responses were along the lines of "not our problem, call the FBI", and people who reported through FBI/NCMEC still saw zero action. I was looking at years old threads of people reporting the same exact sites I was trying to report, with no one getting anywhere. These are straight up child porn sites, hosted by GoDaddy hosting (not just the domains), which were up for years on the plain internet, not on Tor, or even something where passwords were required or something. This wasn't a long time ago either, this was like, a few years ago, and no one at GoDaddy gave a shit. Absolutely infuriating.
- unethical_ban 3y agoWhat could be the rationale? Not wanting to validate the CSAM for fear of becoming responsible for it, or not wanting to hire the staff/buy the infrastructure to "cleanly" handle such stuff?
- neilv 3y agoI wouldn't expect GoDaddy to care, unless they'd had a compliance fear of G-d put into them. But if the proper US authorities were knowingly permitting that material and activity to persist on a big US company's servers, one theory would be that they're using it to map out people who produce, distribute, and seek that material. This resulting in more people encountering the evil material might only increase political support for this and other surveillance efforts. Or maybe this is actually small potatoes among the tasking of the authorities, and they don't have enough resources for all of it, so they have to triage.
- joering2 3y agoThe whole thing about .us needing real name and address of a person and you cannot hide your identity is hilarious. Everytime I had someone spamming me from .us and their data were obviously fake (Registrant name: Tom Cat, Address: Local trash can), the registrar didn't even bother replying to my emails. This has happened with GoDaddy and Dynadot, NameCheap (which is outsourcing all their support to Eastern Europe countries like Russia, so these people are actually looking at your sensitive data) cannot talk for others.
- freedomben 3y agoyep, the net result of that policy is basically restricting/hurting the law abiding citizens while only minorly inconveniencing the spammers.
- tantalor 3y agoIf you outlaw fake whois then only outlaws will fake whois.
- avgcorrection 3y ago> which is outsourcing all their support to Eastern Europe countries like Russia, so these people are actually looking at your sensitive data Russians are looking at my data? Oh wow(?)
- tredre3 3y ago> NameCheap (which is outsourcing all their support to Eastern Europe countries like Russia, so these people are actually looking at your sensitive data) Is it really called outsourcing when they are themselves located in Ukraine (formerly Russia)?
- croisillon 3y agomore like malicio.us
- wil421 3y agoI found some scammers who were registering portions of public addresses as URLs. Not sure where they scrapped them from but it was surely to get around detection. URLs would be like 123NotRealSteetCA, or even otRealStreetCalifornia, where NotRealStreet are actually real US addresses or portions or real addresses.
- jszymborski 3y agoIt seems I've inadvertedly taken the same path as the hackers: migrating from namecheap to namesilo ages ago. Will likely be slowly transferring my domains to porkbun.
- autoexec 3y agoAt this point I consider every link shortening service to be malicious. The "good" ones, at best, take down the URLs that are reported to them but they don't do anything to stop the same scammers from creating more. They don't even seem to bother searching for other active URLs pointing to the same malicious content.
- hunter2_ 3y agoThat seems a bit like saying DNS is malicious, networking is malicious, information is malicious. Almost everything in this world could be used maliciously, and that can't easily be stopped with great success.
- autoexec 3y agoEverything can be abused, some things are abused more often than others. There comes a point when something becomes more trouble than it's worth. DNS/networking/information hasn't hit that threshold, but open DNS resolvers, open SMTP relays, and URL shorteners seem to have.
- kapp_in_life 3y agoYep, wish there was a good up to date list of every link shortener I could block by default but instead it seems like every day some new one pops up. Probably because the last domain they created got blocked on enough sites and its trivial to write one that is unmoderated and abused by CSAM spammers.
- uconnectlol 3y agooh yes they harbor malicious links no, what actually happens is they run a stupid global shared phonebook and le bad people add entries to malware in it. le bad people could just as well do this (whatever it is the'yre doing) without domains at all. but i don't expect anyone who's hobby horse is DNS to tell the forest from the trees. the fact that people get uppity over stuff like this is a testament to the internet being too locked down (it also costed billions of dollars of tax money to get here). i don't get why nobody remembers 20 years ago when they knew how every malware scam etc was obvious and trivial to avoid except for their bumpkin parents.