2 ms·
To clarify: the linked post is bout the DMCA safe harbor rules about takedown notices. This really isn't the bad part of the law. It can be argued that the ta
by ajross 15y ago
To clarify: the linked post is bout the DMCA safe harbor rules about takedown notices. This really isn't the bad part of the law. It can be argued that the takedowns are too easy to do and that they are honored too quickly by site administrators, that they are susceptible to automation and false positives, etc... But really that's not a huge deal.
Where the DMCA is widely reviled is in its other parts, most particularly the anti-circumvention provisions that, when the law was drafted, made things like security research or reflashing a consumer device criminal acts (c.f. the Skylarov case). It should be noted that this nonsense, while it's still in the law, has been significantly dilluted by a bunch of regulatory exemptions enacted by the executive branch.
- WiseWeasel 15y agoIt's still illegal under the DMCA to back up your own DVD/BluRay, or distribute the tools to do so, which is a load of crap.
- nsmartt 15y agoActually, at present, backing up your own DVD is exempted.
- ajross 15y agoThere's a partial of list exemptions here: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Digital_Millennium_Copyright_Act#Anti-circumvention_exemptions http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Digital_Millennium_Copyright_Ac... I was wrong, by the way: it turns out that it's the librarian of congress and not the executive branch that has the power to do this regulation. That's probably more stable and less likely to be walked back, which is good. My read is that a simple backup is not exempted though. You need to be breaking the CSS encryption for the purpose of making a fair use distribution. Obviously IANAL, you should read the law, yada yada yada.
- nsmartt 15y agoOh, oops. I think my (months) younger self must have misunderstood due to wording. >Persons making noninfringing uses of the following six classes of works will not be subject to the prohibition against circumventing access controls (17 U.S.C. § 1201(a)(1)) until the conclusion of the next rulemaking. >Motion pictures on DVDs that are lawfully made and acquired and that are protected... I must have drawn my conclusion hastily. I think I also read it expecting to find that it was legal, since I've seen comments on HN, in the past, claiming it to be. Thanks a lot (not sarcasm).
- WiseWeasel 15y agoI think schools and libraries are exempted, but individuals are not. Individuals can jailbreak their iphones, though...
- barista 15y ago>> This really isn't the bad part of the law Although this one was a success story, it has largely been ineffective in stopping copyright violation in many other scenarios. Youtube, the biggest video platform on the net, still continues to host thousands of copyrighted videos, many owned by people who are notoriously aggressive about enforcing their copyright. I don't think the takedown scales really well. It's basically you vs. the internet and you are going to lose :)
- galenward 15y agoSpot on. You stated this much better than I could.