4 ms·
> The only policy solution to this is to force some kind of deduction from paychecks into retirement accounts. Or to admit that privately managed retirement ac
by lmm 3y ago
> The only policy solution to this is to force some kind of deduction from paychecks into retirement accounts.
Or to admit that privately managed retirement accounts were a mistake, and ramp social security up to the point where it's enough to live on, taking enough contributions to cover that.
Investment should be money that someone can afford to lose. Treating privately managed investment as the way to do retirement savings is going to leave some people destitute.
- missedthecue 3y agoThe demographics of the world mean that social security and government pensions are no longer going to work very well. They will need to be cut, and can certainly not be raised even higher. In your lifetime, most countries will have 1 worker per retiree. Some, like South Korea, will have two retirees per worker. Good luck paying all your normal taxes as well as increased levels of medicare and social security all on one income. Investment will continue to be the cornerstorne or retirement, the math for redistribution just doesn't work. Especially if you increase the distributions.
- lmm 3y agoThe government can invest just as well as individuals can. The only difference is that everyone would get the average growth, rather than the wise or lucky getting more and the foolish or unlucky getting less. If we can't afford to fund people's retirement that way, they can't afford to fund it themselves either, and investment accounts were only ever about shifting the blame.
- HDThoreaun 3y agoSocial security invests in low interest bonds, if they invest at all. Having the government invest everyone's retirement savings will at best lead to sub-optimal returns and more likely lead to corruption and theft.
- lmm 3y agoIf the government can't figure out how to invest for decent returns, how is it remotely reasonable to expect individual citizens to?