4 ms·
I know what you mean. I remember one time I got off the plane in Italy and I was walking with my girlfriend to customs. At one point we branched off from all
by wkat4242 3y ago
I know what you mean.
I remember one time I got off the plane in Italy and I was walking with my girlfriend to customs.
At one point we branched off from all the other passengers and she was like "hey we're going the wrong way, everyone is heading there". And I said nope this is the EU passengers exit, look at the sign.
She couldn't believe it was right because the plane was full of others from our EU country. All those people couldn't be wrong, right? I explained I guessed they were all just dumbly following the herd without looking which wouldn't even occur to me. I don't really have that autopilot herd-following program in me. Even when I'm in a group I'm navigating as if I were alone.
So we got to the end and there were 6 free booths in front of us and all the other passengers were queuing up for the 2 unmanned non-EU passport booths :') a security guard had to let them into the right queue.
This applies to the bystander effect too. I'm not surprised about this conclusion at all.
- AndrewKemendo 3y agoI found it surprisingly helpful to use the heuristic of just pausing when everyone is doing some thing (like moving in a mass) and just literally evaluating the opposite thing to do. It’s a surprisingly useful heuristic.
- wkat4242 3y agoIndeed! It gives a fresh outlook on life and a sense of freedom, of all options being open. And a lot of us are the ones that come up with solutions to problems because we think outside the box. Or more specifically: there is no box. I could not live without that sense of freedom.
- permo-w 3y agothis effect seems to be especially true in airports. they seem to particularly inspire dumb herd behaviour. perhaps there's an increase in perceived danger leading to a stronger desire for safety in numbers? another example: queueing to board the plane. other than to fit in, why on earth would I stand there and compete to spend more time in a sweaty uncomfortable seat packed with 400 other people? plus, if you get on last, you can take advantage of empty rows before anyone else
- svara 3y agoNo need to involve hypoxia, which should subside quickly at sea level. People are tired, stressed, and many have been drinking on the plane.
- wkat4242 3y agoIn Europe most people don't really drink anymore on flights because it's no longer free on most airlines. Which is a really good thing IMO.
- xwdv 3y agoThe reason becomes apparent when you take a carry on bag and find yourself desperately searching for somewhere to put it in an overhead bin, but there is none. You boarded too late and everyone ahead of you stole your allotted space. NOW you have to check in your carry on. And waste time waiting for your bag at the baggage claim. If it even makes it. Your bag has much higher chance of being lost if checked in late.
- wkat4242 3y agoYup this. I'm not a herd person but I love boarding first so I can tuck my bag away. It means the worry of that is gone. And I actually like sitting in my window seat a lot more than at the gate.
- pc86 3y agoPretty funny use of the word "stole" in this context. The space being above a particular doesn't make it that seat's space any more than the public parking space on the street in front of your house makes it yours. And I've been on probably 8 or 10 flights this year and every time they said carry-ons checked at the gate are returned planeside upon arrival; not once have they been sent to baggage claim.
- fsckboy 3y ago>The reason becomes apparent when you take a carry on bag your unreason will become apparent when you check that bag and stroll completely unencumbered through the vast distances twixt curb and plane (x2 departure and arrival) baggage claim really doesn't take that long, and you can come up with something zen to do for 5 or 10 minutes, make a phone call or two, talk to family or friends. Life is better when you stop inconveniencing yourself and creating a rat race when there isn't one. Let everyone around you fight over the overheads.
- matthewdgreen 3y agoAlternatively: they followed the heuristic that would get them to the right place in any properly-designed airport. Unfortunately this particular airport seems to have been designed improperly.
- jeffbee 3y agoWhat does this have to do with autism, though? It is not defined by the ability to read signs, is it? A week ago I returned to America from abroad and, by reading the signs at SFO, I downloaded the CBP app and abandoned the gigantic line in favor of the completely empty line. I am evidently in the top 1% of sign readers, but I don't know if I am autistic.
- wkat4242 3y ago> What does this have to do with autism, though? It is not defined by the ability to read signs, is it? No but it's partly defined by the lower ability to form part of social groups and thus follow others on autopilot. And thus being more aware of situations. The story was not really a definition rather than a symptom. One that can be caused by more than one thing.
- depereo 3y agoIf you've spent your whole life wondering how the fuck the bulk of people seem to make confusing or challenging decisions maybe you just evaluate 'from first principals' in more situations.
- makeitdouble 3y ago> a security guard had to let them into the right queue. So, just looking at the final result they ended up in the right place ? Assuming the security guard made that adjustment because they were so many of them, the strategy seems to be paying off in that specific case.
- vasco 3y agoSomeone like the person you replied to would consider a big failure and inefficient to be told by security where to go when there are signs. I'd be thinking about it for a while after too and it'd never happen again in an airport because I'd be even more aware next time to prevent it.
- makeitdouble 3y agoI probably sit in the middle, where I see the value of good signs (and good design in general) to properly guide the users so they don't have to rely on heuristics and "blind" fallbacks. In particular for airports where dealing with huge influx of users at peak time is critical. On the other hand, for many people, having to talk to a security guard and move to the lane on the other side is a non-event, and they might have tried to talk to the guard even if there was absolutely no need for it, if they felt it wouldn't be an issue for the guard (not too busy, looks bored etc.). Efficiency could be super low on their priority list, if it wasn't they'd be paying a lot more attention to the signage in the first place.
- slim 3y agoI think the point of GP is "following the herd" is also a strategy that works 90% of the time (I would argue 99% of the time if there is no malicious intent to mislead involved). It's not by chance that this behaviour has been selected by nature. It is simple. It works in a lot of cases including cases where there are no signs or where you can't read the signs. And it makes for a great fallback strategy when you have a better strategy for the specific case.
- vasco 3y ago
- Obscurity4340 3y agoAre there connections between ADHD autism in your view? I feel like if I had my wits about me, i woulda made the same choice
- taneq 3y agoThey're highly comorbid with a lot of common traits.
- Obscurity4340 3y agoI just wonder if sociality and ease of establishing and maintaining rapport is contraindicative of ASPD/autism stuff or whether it really is not only just a spectrum in the sense of a spectrum of impairment but also on a continuum from ASPD/autism <--> "Normal" where impairment can still exist as a sort of sub-spectrum without wholly subjugating me to that subclassification where i could otherwise ddmobstrate skills and traits to the contrary Insofar as a a spectrum of impairment is referring to a spectrum of diificulty in socializing and a deficiency of adeptness at neurotypical theory of mind
- sokka_h2otribe 3y agoHi, I didn't totally understand your writing. One reason why a lot of things are comorbid: generally, few mental things have "a single gene" but are manifestations of many gene differences and nature. One reason why a lot of things are comorbid is just that more people are a little something than a lot something, and people who get diagnosed for one thing are more likely to have resources and reasons to be diagnosed for another something. After rereading your msg, I'm concerned you're looking for some sort of thing like "If I'm sufficiently good at X I can't be Y" I don't think these things work this way. Many folks on the spectrum share some social skills weaknesses, but social skills challenges are not really what makes them on the spectrum. In all, all models wrong - some models useful. An attitude of viewing these things from the lens of asking if they help you understand yourself and navigate the world is probably best. I was really worried with labels before I kept repeating to myself 'all models wrong, some models useful' Depression, ADHD, autism, all models. All 'wrong'.Still, useful sometimes. They aren't meant to be the be all end all though, and they only sometimes (maybe often) accurately represent reality, which is a bit of a silly statement, since there isn't one reality to it all. There we go, I got more confusing sorry :)
- taneq 3y agoReminds me of one time when we had a power outage in the central train station, there was a long queue of people lined up at the (stationary) escalator while the stairs next to it were empty. I just shrugged and went up the stairs, but I do wonder what all those people were thinking.
- Arrath 3y ago"Ugh, I hate the stairs I'm sure this escalator will start up any time..."
- oreally 3y agoSame here. Got an anti-herd mentality that while beneficial in some ways, is detrimental in other areas associated with the social aspects. It's also given me a bit of a misanthropic outlook as well.
- quickthrower2 3y agoI like to exploit these things but not because of autism, but opportunity. The shorter queue at the cinema that no one joins, for example, because they didn't notice because of the big queue. It is worth taking note of what other people are doing though. Maybe not so much at airports that should have everything running like clockwork, but some places communication of new information is poor, done verbally so not everyone hears. It is worth asking people "why you doing that" sometimes.
- forinti 3y agoAt the cinema everyone goes out through the door the first person went through. A line even forms while all the other doors are ignored.
- penguin_booze 3y ago> Even when I'm in a group I'm navigating as if I were alone This ring true to me about my whole life, both in a good and bad senses.