5 ms·
GSK doesn't have your well being as it's goal, it has it's own revenue stream as its goal. Without an ethical framework around consent for the use of this data
by jacquesm 3y ago
GSK doesn't have your well being as it's goal, it has it's own revenue stream as its goal. Without an ethical framework around consent for the use of this data the potential for abuse is substantial, upsides are optional. They need to make that money back somehow.
- solardev 3y agoIf my worthless genomic data contributes to a drug that one day helps even one other person, I'm fine with this. Would I prefer all this data be free and open? Sure. Failing that, would I want to hold onto it? No. I'd still rather some mega evil pharma have it and be able to develop some overpriced medication that may one day be genericized. It's not doing me or anyone any good just sitting in my body. Hell, I'll spit for anyone wanting to do research, for profit or not. I think there are very few true "good guys" in the world. But if mega evil pharma corp has even a 1% chance of accidentally doing some tiny good as a byproduct of their evil... that's already more than would've happened if 23andme didn't share it with them. It's cool with me if they make some money in the process. My DNA isn't some creative work that I need royalties on. What nature giveth, I spiteth.
- MerelyMortal 3y agoJust because you value something as worthless, does not mean everyone else values it as worthless.
- solardev 3y agoI'm not demanding anyone else give theirs. I'm just happy to give mine. Different customers of the same company can respond differently to their actions. In this case my opinion is that this a net good. Others can and will disagree, of course!
- jacquesm 3y agoAre your children and your parents also on board with this? If not: did you realize you just contributed half of their DNA as well?
- MerelyMortal 3y agoI feel bad for the children whose parents post about their medical conditions on social media, your comment reminds me of that travesty.
- solardev 3y agoEven I agree with this, despite not having kids. Their lives aren't mine to monetize or publicize. Let them have whatever semblance of a childhood they can have under the already too harsh spotlight of modern media, yeesh. It was bad enough in the 2000s when my mom liked all my Facebook posts. Real travesty here.
- solardev 3y agoNo kids and never will (vasectomy). Parents couldn't care less. They were intrigued by the ancestry stuff though. They're not long of this world anyway and probably won't live to see genetic medicines become an everyday reality :( My partner's bigger family also contributed a lot of their DNA to this or similar services. I'll have to ask her what they think of sharing it with third (fourth?) parties. Be an interesting data point at least. I feel like the HN crowd holds a lot of uncommon opinions (not good or bad, just different from most people I know IRL).
- jacquesm 3y agoOk, that makes you a minority in the sense that I think that the potential negative fall out from your decision is limited enough that you were entirely free to make it. But the bulk of the people that sent their family data to 23andme isn't that well informed and likely has no idea about the potential for abuse of such data. Maybe it is the 'dark side' in me or maybe it is simply seeing so many corporate abuses over a lifetime in IT that I can't see beyond the abuse to the possible good. The fact that it has Google backing is one major strike against it, as is the fact that they were going to commercialize the data itself right from the get-go whilst giving their paying customers something the amounted to expensive infotainment. It's clear that they wanted the data, not clear that there would be benefits to the participants, the data returned is just too coarse for that and akin to doing a lot of screening without symptoms, a practice that the medical profession has warned against repeatedly.
- nonrandomstring 3y ago> It's not doing me or anyone any good just sitting in my body. That's funny dude! Not laughing _at_ you, but you just nailed self-objectification and reification better than a whole chapter of social scince jibberjabber or pschology babble.
- solardev 3y agoMakes sense! I'm also a "yeah they can poke and prod my body and harvest my organs, not like I have any use for them after I'm dead" kinda donor. At least it's consistently materialist, eh? (as opposed to spiritual dualism, etc.) This is probably not a controversial stance here on HN, but IMO humans are essentially wet, mostly hairless sacks of proteins and dreams. It's kinda cool that despite that, we are motile and can pass for sentient (some days of the week).
- nonrandomstring 3y agoUgly Bag of Mostly Water! :) (A Trek TOS thing I think)
- itishappy 3y agoMy favorite web-comic describes us as "bag[s] of no-longer-potable water." https://www.schlockmercenary.com/2003-03-13 https://www.schlockmercenary.com/2003-03-13
- flandish 3y agoI wish the data would be combined with things like Vanderbilt’s BioVU databanks, etc, for actual translational research and not for swift for profit research. This is just another version of “socialized research privatized profit.”
- fsckboy 3y ago> GSK doesn't have your well being as it's goal, it has it's own revenue stream as its goal. Without an ethical framework around consent for the use of this data the potential for abuse is substantial I don't like that you seem to be trying to drive a wedge between revenue streams and ethical goods. Measuring how much money societies spend on things is the best measure we have of how much societies value those things. Companies (and people, including employees and customers of companies) do all sorts of horrible, unethical things. But profit (surplus) is a good thing overall, as is symmetric information and competition.