3 ms·
Do you think the creator of a piece of art has any rights whatsoever? You're basically endorsing the idea that if you stumble across some original work that you
by anigbrowl 3y ago
Do you think the creator of a piece of art has any rights whatsoever? You're basically endorsing the idea that if you stumble across some original work that you're able to make a copy of, there's nothing wrong with falsely declaring yourself the author of it and collecting money from anyone you can trick into believing this.
- alphanullmeric 3y agoYou have the right to protect it with means that are not government force. Force is only justified in response to force, and you don’t get to ransom anyone that “steals” your thoughts and pixels. Do you believe copying is force? That’s a yes or no question, and if I don’t get a yes or no answer then I’ll answer for you.
- ChadNauseam 3y ago> You have the right to protect it with means that are not government force. Force is only justified in response to force, and you don’t get to ransom anyone that “steals” your thoughts and pixels. This just sounds like your opinion, why do you think this? I really like that people can profitably write books and make movies and I think some force to allow that to happen seems reasonable.
- alphanullmeric 3y agoOf course it’s my opinion that force is only justified in response to force, disagree?
- anigbrowl 3y agoI reject your whole premise here, as many thefts can occur without force, and many legal remedies are imposed without force. You're just ducking the question; it seems you're saying that 'no, you don't have any rights that you can enforce in court.' You'd probably object to extralegal enforcement on the basis that it violates the NAP or some other glibertarian trope.
- alphanullmeric 3y agoI’ll answer for you then. Yes, you’re claiming that copying is force. I am defining force as literal force. What theft can occur without physically touching the thing being stolen? I didn’t duck the question. I answered it. I even answered it before it was asked (minus the irrelevant comment about identity fraud) - I’m against IP. Copy whatever you want.
- anigbrowl 3y agoI am defining force as literal force. What theft can occur without physically touching the thing being stolen? This is like saying you work 24-7 because breathing involves physical motion. Insisting on ur personal definitions of well-understood terms while disregarding how everyone else uses them is childish. But even if we use this, ah, special definition, legal remedies in tort cases typically don't involve force. You get a judgement of liability from the court, and and are ordered to write a check. You can complain about government force, but by your criteria your injury is wholly imaginary. Meanwhile it seems clear that you do not consider that authors of creative works to have any rights whatsoever in their output. I hear this a lot from people with no creative abilities of their own.
- alphanullmeric 3y agoMy definition of force is the definition of force. The definition I gave you was literally "literal force", and you understood that to mean something different from your interpretation of force. You are the only one trying to change definitions here. If the court orders me to do something, that's force. If you think it's somehow voluntary, then I have a few examples I'd like to ask you about. I have no idea what injury you're referring to. Yes, we've already established that you don't get the rights to pixels, sounds and ideas, and my creative abilities won't change that.
- anigbrowl 3y agoPathetic display. There is not only one definition of any word, as you can readily ascertain by consulting a good dictionary, legal or otherwise. Yes, we've already established that you don't get the rights to pixels, sounds and ideas We've established that that's what you want, and that you're unwilling to even acknowledge the concept of authorship. Your efforts at rhetorical browbeating are clumsy at best.
- ChadNauseam 3y agoTangential question, but if I buy a copy of Hamlet by someone claiming to have written it, are they not committing fraud? (Regardless, a “solution” to the problem of copyright that destroys people’s ability to profitably write books or make movies seems silly to me)
- simbolit 3y agoWhat does the creator's right have to do with lying? (1) Lying is bad. (2) Lying and "collecting money from anyone you can trick" is fraud. (3) Fraud is illegal, and that has nothing to do with copyright. You are massively straw-manning here.
- anigbrowl 3y agoCopyright is literally the mechanism that allows creators to obtain a legal remedy for such actions. I have a lot of problems with the state of copyright, but am OK with the basic concept. GP is arguing against any sort of IP rights, so these questions are reasonable. Lying isn't illegal, if there are no IP rights in a created work then anyone can legally claim authorship.
- simbolit 3y agoLying isn't illegal, but "collecting money from anyone you can trick" is. It is fraud. What is so hard about this?