3 ms·
> Rules exist for a reason. The trouble is sometimes they don't. Or they do exist for a reason but the rules are still absurd and net harmful because they're i
by AnthonyMouse 3y ago
> Rules exist for a reason.
The trouble is sometimes they don't. Or they do exist for a reason but the rules are still absurd and net harmful because they're incompetently drafted. Or the real reason is bad and the rules are doing what they were intended to do but they were intended to do something bad.
> If China builds amazing AI tech (and they will) then the rest of the world will just use it.
Not if it's banned elsewhere, or they allow people to use it without publishing it, e.g. by offering it as a service.
And it matters a lot who controls something. "AI" potentially has a lot of power, even non-AGI AI -- it can create economic efficiency, or it can manipulate people. If an adversarial entity has greater economic efficiency, they can outcompete you -- the way the US won the Cold War was essentially by having a stronger economy. If an adversarial entity has a greater ability to manipulate people, that could be even worse.
> If you want to live in China, go live in China. I assure you you will not find it to be the law less free hold of “anything goes” that you somehow imagine.
But that's precisely the issue -- it's not an anarchy, it's an authoritarian competing nation state. We have to be better than them so the country that has an elected government and constitutional protections for human rights is the one with an economic advantage, because it isn't a law of nature that those things always go together, but it's a world-eating disaster if they don't.
- wokwokwok 3y ago> Or they do exist for a reason but the rules are still absurd and net harmful Ok. …but if you have a law and you’re opposed to it on the basis that “China will do it anyway”, you admit that’s stupid? Shouldn’t you be asking: does the law do a useful thing? Does it make the world better? Is it compatible with our moral values? Organ harvesting. Stem cell research. Human cloning. AI. Slavery. How can anyone stand there and go “well China will do it so we may as well?” In an abstract sense this is a fundamentally invalid logical argument. Truth on the basis of arbitrary assertion. It. Is. False. Now, certainly there is a degree of naunce with regard to AI specifically; but the assertion that we will be “left behind” and “out competed by China” are not relevant to the discussion on laws regarding AI and AI development. What we do is not governed by what China may or may not do. If you want to win the “AI race” to AGI, then investment and effort is required, not allowing an arbitrary “anything goes” policy. China as a nation is sponsoring the development of its technology and supporting its industry. If you want want to beat that, opposing responsible AI won’t do it.
- AnthonyMouse 3y ago> ...but if you have a law and you’re opposed to it on the basis that “China will do it anyway”, you admit that’s stupid? That depends on what "it" is. If it's slavery and the US but not China banning slavery causes there to be half as much slavery in the world as there would be otherwise, it would be stupid. But if it's research and the same worldwide demand for the research results are there so you're only limiting where it can be done, which only causes twice as much to be done in China if it isn't being done in the US, you're not significantly reducing the scope of the problem. You're just making sure that any benefits of the research are in control of the country that can still do it. > Now, certainly there is a degree of naunce with regard to AI specifically; but the assertion that we will be “left behind” and “out competed by China” are not relevant to the discussion on laws regarding AI and AI development. Of course it is. You could very easily pass laws that de facto prohibit AI research in the US, or limit it to large bureaucracies that in turn become stagnant for lack of domestic competitive pressure. This doesn't even have anything to do with the stated purpose of the law. You could pass a law requiring government code audits which cost a million dollars, and justify them based on any stated rationale -- you're auditing to prevent X bad thing, for any value of X. Meanwhile the major effect of the law is to exclude anybody who can't absorb a million dollar expense. Which is a bad thing even if X is a real problem, because that is not the only possible solution, and even if it was, it could still be that the cure is worse than the disease. Regulators are easily and commonly captured, so regulations tend to be drafted in that way and to have that effect, regardless of their purported rationale. Some issues are so serious that you have no choice but to eat the inefficiency and try to minimize it -- you can't have companies dumping industrial waste in the river. But when even the problem itself is a poorly defined matter of debatable severity and the proposed solutions are convoluted malarkey of indiscernible effectiveness, this is a sure sign that something shady is being evaluated. A strong heuristic here is that if you're proposing a regulation that would restrict what kind of code an individual could publish under a free software license, you're the baddies.
- wokwokwok 3y ago> Of course it is. You could very easily pass laws that de facto prohibit AI research in the US, or limit it to large bureaucracies that in turn become stagnant for lack of domestic competitive pressure. … > A strong heuristic here is that if you're proposing a regulation that would restrict what kind of code an individual could publish under a free software license, you're the baddies. Sure. …but those things will change the way development / progress happens regardless of what China does. “We have to do this because China will do it!” is a harmful trope. You don’t have to do anything. If you want to do something, then do it, if it makes sense. …but I flat out reject the original contention that China is a blanket excuse for any fucking thing. Take some darn responsibility for your own actions.