3 ms·
Most of the things people are worried about AI doing are the things corporations are already allowed to do - snoop on everybody, influence governments, oppress
by Animats 3y ago
Most of the things people are worried about AI doing are the things corporations are already allowed to do - snoop on everybody, influence governments, oppress workers, lie. AI just makes some of that cheaper.
- cs702 3y agoThe ironic thing is that many individuals now clamoring for more regulation have long claimed to be free-market libertarians who think regulation is "always" bad. Evidently they think regulation is bad only when it puts their profits at risk. As I wrote elsewhere, the tech glitterati asking for regulation of AI remind me of the very important Fortune 500 CEO Mr. Burroughs in the movie "Class:" Mr. Burroughs: "Government control, Jonathan, is anathema to the free-enterprise system. Any intelligent person knows you cannot interfere with the laws of supply and demand." Jonathan: "I see your point, sir. That's the reason why I'm not for tariffs." Mr. Burroughs: "Right. No, wrong! You gotta have tariffs, son. How you gonna compete with the damn foreigners? Gotta have tariffs." --- Source: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nM0h6QXTpHQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nM0h6QXTpHQ
- mplewis 3y agoAbsolutely. Those folks arguing for AI regulation aren't arguing for safety – they're asking the government to build a moat around the market segment propping up their VC-funded scams.
- ralph84 3y agoThe biggest players in AI haven’t been VC-funded for decades. Unless you mean their customers are VC-funded, but even then startups are a much smaller portion of their revenue than Fortune 500.
- concordDance 3y agoWho is "those folks"? The ones I know of have been complaining about how the term "AI safety" has changed meaning from "don't kill everyone" to "don't embarrass the corporation".
- permo-w 3y agotheir motivations may be selfish, but that doesn't mean that regulation of AI is wrong. I'd prefer there be a few heavily-regulated and/or publicly-owned bodies in the public eye that can use and develop these technologies, rather than literally anyone with a powerful enough computer. yeah it's anti-competitive, but competition isn't always a good thing
- CobrastanJorji 3y agoTurning something that we're already able to do into something we're able to do very easily can be extremely significant. It's the difference between "public records" and "all public records about you being instantly viewable online." It's also one of the subjects of the excellent sci fi novel "A Deepness in the Sky," which is still great despite making some likely bad guesses about AI.
- libraryatnight 3y agoSeems like a legitimately good reason to get a tourniquet on that thing now.
- queuebert 3y agoAnd faster than humans can police.
- j45 3y agoIf anything, LLM can help process vast troves of customer data, communication and meta data more effectively than ever before.
- carabiner 3y agoNukes are the same as guns, just makes it cheaper.
- pixl97 3y agoA snowflake really isn't harmful. A snowball probably isn't harmful unless you do something really dumb. A snow drift isn't harmful unless you're not cautious. An avalanche, well that gets harmful pretty damned quick. These things are all snow, but suddenly at some point scale starts to matter.
- Spivak 3y agoI love this way of explaining it. I've been calling it the programmers fallacy -- "anything you can do you can do in a for loop." I think in a lot of ways we all struggle with the nature of some things changing their nature depending on the context and scale. Like if you kill a frenchman on purpose that's a murder, if you killed him because if he attacked you first it's self defense, if you killed him because he was convicted of a crime that's an execution, if you killed him because he's french that's a hate crime, but if you're at war with France that's killing an enemy combatant, but if he's not in the military that's a civilian casualty, and if you do that a lot it becomes a war crime, and if you kill everyone who's french it's a genocide.
- pyuser583 3y agoYeah but ski-runs with human made snow are fine. How do we know which slippery slope we are on?
- pixl97 3y agoI don't think you can see the problem with your own analogy... Human made ski runs only will use as much snow as they need because snow is expensive. If ski runs were popular/useful based on their depth then I'm absolutely sure some greedy company would keep piling it up until disaster occurred (mining waste is another great example here). So how much 'intelligence' is enough? How much capability is too much? How fast is too fast when thinking? We will never stop improving our capabilities unless some natural law provides that limit. And we absolutely know the base limit to intelligence is the smartest person. And there is little reason to 'peak' intelligence to be limited at the level of humans and their power restricted formats.
- gumballindie 3y agoAnd just like in politics the strategy is to redefine that which you want to achieve - in this case total control of a technology - as something else that’s bad so that people will be distracted from what you actually want which is exactly that which you describe as something else. Politicians that point fingers at other politicians being corrupt or incompetent while they themselves are exactly that use the same strategy. Power and manipulation. Nothing new under the sun. What’s new though is that we can see in plain sight how corporations control politics. Like literarily this can be documented with git commit history accuracy: thousands upon thousands of people repeating the exact same phrases defending openai and the “revolutionary” product, fear mongering, political lobby, manufactured threats and of course a cure that only they can provide and so on. I would not let people that use such tactics near an email account let alone ai policy making.