6 ms·
Qualcomm Snapdragon X Elite Performance Preview: A First Look at What's to Come
- tiffanyh 3y agoQuestion: is this the first chip created by the folks from NUVIA (the crew behind Apple Silicon), that Qualcomm acquired 2-years ago? https://www.qualcomm.com/news/releases/2021/03/qualcomm-completes-acquisition-nuvia https://www.qualcomm.com/news/releases/2021/03/qualcomm-comp...
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- goosedragons 3y agoYup.
- agloe_dreams 3y agoYes, the same team that got their pants sued off by like a bunch of other companies such as ARM and Apple.
- MikusR 3y agoIt's also is the design ARM (the company) is suing to be destroyed. Like literally destroyed.
- lvass 3y agoI'm hoping this one and many more get stuck in legal hell for ages so we finally move away from proprietary ISAs.
- MikusR 3y agoARM is proprietary
- vetinari 3y agoThat's the point. If developing high-performance ARM cores are considered risky, maybe the vendors could switch to an ISA without these risks.
- soapdog 3y agoNot gonna happen for anything big enough like a server or laptop class of computers. There is too much gap in terms of software to justify adopting a new ISA. Also, designing those high-performance ISAs cost a lot of money, both in terms of professionals involved but also resources. Any company attempting that will need to make sure there is software to run on it and that they can make money. That is beyond the reach of a lot of companies.
- aseipp 3y agoThere's nothing risky about developing ARM cores. Well, other than the fact that doing it wrong is very costly. Millions of them ship every year, and there have been many third-party designs, shipped in millions of units, by many different companies, for years and years and years at this point; it was actually the primary way they (ARM) did business for a long time, until ARM realized that focusing on designing better cores than their customers was a great way to make money, as increasing design complexity put them in an overall better position to do it versus third parties. The Qualcomm/ARM dispute at its core has nothing to do with the ISA, it's fundamentally an IP dispute, concerning an existing agreement after a buyout and market pivot. These kinds of disputes aren't new. The risky thing is "violating license agreements." Licensing a RISC-V core from a company under specific terms, getting bought out, and then changing trajectory of your product with that IP in a way that might violate the terms could result in the company coming after you. Put more simply, "violating the terms of a license agreement means you could get sued." This isn't strange. It's a complete non-story. The other real risk is one that exists in any processor design, that it costs tens of millions of dollars to develop validated, high-end, high-performance and energy efficient processors, no matter the ISA, and tooling them is an entirely different matter. These risks mean the vast majority of Production-Ready designs come from corporations that need to ship high volume, high margin products, based on projected returns. There's relatively little actually "open" about the processors from SiFive, Ventana, Rivos, etc, other than the fact they adhere to a specific version of a ratified software standard, a PDF you can download. If you come at it from a software point of view, all of the "ingredients" are basically proprietary. You aren't getting masks, RTL files, DV tools, bringup tools, or any capability to validate any of those are what you expect. You cannot reasonably modify and reproduce them -- a single wafer on a modern process can take months to actually pattern before the packaging process even begins. And they aren't going to give it to you, because that's their competitive advantage and the reason you buy their cores, instead of their competitors cores. The whole bellowing about "proprietary ISAs" or "ARM vs RISC-V" on places like this is mostly totally misinformed upvote farming, and has no bearing on how reality actually works.
- nicpottier 3y agoLooks promising. Can we get one of these in a Framework laptop now?
- masterofsome 3y agoJudging based on how difficult it was to transition to also making AMD mainboards, I doubt we would see this for YEARS.
- soapdog 3y agoDoubt it, I suspect Microsoft will get an exclusivity deal going on with them so they're only sold to Windows-on-ARM machines.
- wyldfire 3y agoFrom the article: > Regardless, the primary purpose of the Linux demo was to showcase that Linux was working on the Snapdragon Elite X as well – that it’s not just for Windows – as Qualcomm has aims of getting the SoC into Linux laptops as well. Some person on the internet [1] says "The good news is that the exclusivity of Microsoft's Qualcomm 8cx series has ended. Moving forward, we will be able to encounter the 8cx series in a greater variety of form factors. For instance, there are plans to incorporate the 8cx Gen4 into Chromebooks as well." I'm not sure if exclusivity of 8cx Gen4 is different from X Elite though. [1] https://x.com/Tech_Reve/status/1670038184405901313?s=20 https://x.com/Tech_Reve/status/1670038184405901313?s=20
- magnio 3y agoThe past 5 years in personal computing has been surreal. After years of Intel dominating and stagnating the desktop and laptop market, competition from AMD (Ryzen) and subsequently Apple (Apple Silicon) has been a real treat for consumer. After years of Apple squarely beating the shit out of Qualcomm and years of Qualcomm not giving a shit due to its Android monopoly, competition from MediaTek (Dimensity) forced them to up their game. Now Apple is setting the standard for laptop performance, AMD is reviving the Windows laptop scene, Qualcomm is catching up to Apple CPU, outperforming its GPU, and realizing the Windows ARM dream. Exciting, exciting times ahead.
- re-thc 3y ago> and years of Qualcomm not giving a shit due to its Android monopoly What Qualcomm has is a modem and modem patent monopoly. There were early Android SoC competitors e.g. nVidia Tegra. The issue was the modem. Not the CPU.
- GeekyBear 3y agoWhat Qualcomm did have was an undisputed patent monopoly on one of the possible ways that cellular communication could be done. Now that 3G is being turned completely off in much of the world, the last vestiges of that advantage are going away and Qualcomm will have to learn to compete on a more level playing field.
- hmottestad 3y agoWhat alternatives are there to the current 5G Qualcomm modems?
- GeekyBear 3y ago5G is an open standard and patent holders are required to make a binding commitment to license their patents on FRAND (Fair Reasonable and Non Discriminatory) terms to all comers before their patents can become part of that standard. Even low cost Mediatek SOCs have a built in standards compliant 5G implementation. https://www.mediatek.com/technology/5g/5g-modem https://www.mediatek.com/technology/5g/5g-modem
- airstrike 3y agoNo M2 Pro comparison?
- conjecTech 3y agoGary Explains gave some numbers that seem to indicate its on-par or a bit better than M2 Pro at similar power levels. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_8wzGkTWdP8&t=348s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_8wzGkTWdP8&t=348s
- mkl 3y agohttps://www.notebookcheck.net/First-Snapdragon-X-Elite-benchmarks-Impressive-gains-over-M2-Max-Ryzen-9-7940HS-Intel-13th-gen-H-and-14th-gen-desktop-CPUs.763149.0.html https://www.notebookcheck.net/First-Snapdragon-X-Elite-bench..., discussion here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38070449 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38070449
- fh9302 3y agoThe Snapdragon X Elite CPU is closer to the M2 Pro / Max, while the GPU is closer to the regular M2. This makes comparisons a bit difficult without knowing price and resulting battery life.
- 127361 3y agoIt would be really nice to have Raspberry Pi-like developer board with this chip. At one point Qualcomm released full documentation for their SoCs, with a publicly available manual with near complete register documentation. I think it was for the APQ8064. It even included Adreno GPU registers and some GPS/WiFi baseband related stuff. * An unfused SoC, so no secure boot etc. The Efuse VPP pin is tied to ground so no possibility of bricking it by blowing the fuses inadvertently. * Fully open bootloader, e.g. U-Boot based. * Mostly complete register documentation for the SoC, that would be good enough. * Mainline Linux support. Such a board would take the open source world by storm.
- wmf 3y agoAn X Elite board would probably be $500 though.
- snvzz 3y agoI would look at RISC-V instead. Competitive very high performance cores already available for licensing include SiFive P870, Ventana Veyron as well as Tenstorrent Ascalon or Alastor. We just need the SoC.
- user_7832 3y agoYes but then there's the question of software support. Arm supports android which has a huge ecosystem. And there are way more linux and other obscure/niche OSes which support arm like raspbian. If there was an easy way to run arm or x86 code on risk-v like rosetta that could help, but arm still has much better support than risk v.
- snvzz 3y agoBox64 supports RISC-V as host ISA. Refer to e.g. youtube to see it in action. I have personally used qemu-user, another solution, to run ARM binaries.
- blinkingled 3y agoI don't care about Qualcomm and its ARM offerings for the PC - Windows side there's no reason to and Linux side because hardware longevity will be hobbled by lacking kernel and driver support beyond the first year or two. You can't really beat Intel and AMD unless you're at least as good as supporting the hardware and peripherals and for as long. I can see Intel and AMD getting better at power use but I have a hard time seeing ARM ecosystem become as open as the PC one.
- wmf 3y agoFor desktop Linux, Qualcomm and the community are upstreaming drivers so you should be able to upgrade the kernel.
- Terretta 3y ago> You can't really beat Intel and AMD unless you're at least as good as supporting the hardware Worth a read: Amazon is the most successful manufacturer of Arm server chips, accounting for just over half of Arm-based server CPUs currently deployed, while some chipmakers are also now betting on Arm-based Windows PCs. This information comes from a report issued by Bernstein Research which estimates that nearly 10 percent of servers across the world contain Arm processors, and 40 percent of those are located in China, as we reported earlier. But that total is beaten by just one company – Amazon – which has slightly above 50 percent of all Arm server CPUs in the world deployed in its Amazon Web Services (AWS) datacenters, said the analyst. https://www.theregister.com/2023/08/08/amazon_arm_servers/ https://www.theregister.com/2023/08/08/amazon_arm_servers/
- wyldfire 3y agoQualcomm is really trying to turn things around - on all fronts. Upstreaming is clearly a higher priority now than it's been in the past, e.g. "Upstream Linux support now available for the the Qualcomm Snapdragon 8 Gen 3 Mobile Platform" [1] Disclaimer: I'm a Qualcomm employee. [1] https://www.linaro.org/blog/upstream-linux-support-now-available-for-the-the-qualcomm-snapdragon-8-gen-3-mobile-platform/ https://www.linaro.org/blog/upstream-linux-support-now-avail...
- almatabata 3y agoThis part had me the most worried. Given Qualcomm's history they really need to show they mean it otherwise they will have trough convincing people to invest in their chip. With mobile and automotive Qualcomm had a habit of dropping the support after 3 years unless the OEM paid up. As an end user i do not want to own an insecure laptop after 3 years just because the manufacturer did not want to pay qualcomm. If they actually sustain this effort I can see this new chip becoming a success regardless if it beats the M2 or not. It only has to have decent performance and decent linux support. Fingers crossed, I hope they succeed.
- dingi 3y agoAFAIK that's just the bare minimum to get Linux booting. GPU and host of other things are missing.
- wyldfire 3y agoThat doesn't correspond to what the article itself says. GPU might not be supported yet but it doesn't look like the bare minimum either. EDIT - looks like there's GPU support too. https://www.phoronix.com/news/Linux-6.5-MSM-Adreno-A690 https://www.phoronix.com/news/Linux-6.5-MSM-Adreno-A690 ~~~~~~~~ With the recent series of patches released by Linaro, the following features are enabled for the Snapdragon 8 Gen 3 Mobile Platform: Qualcomm® Kryo™ CPUs, including DVFS (Dynamic voltage and frequency scaling) and Power Management System foundation: Clocks, Power controllers, PMICs Low-Speed I/O: I2C, SPI, RTC, Buttons, LEDs High-Density Storage: UFS 4.0, SDXC High-Speed Peripherals: PCIe Gen3 and Gen4, USB Version 3.1 Gen 2, USB-C PD Qualcomm® Hexagon™ Processor SubSystems: Audio, Sensors, Compute and Modem Mobile Display Subsystem + DSI Engine, Touch Controller Communication: WCN7850 Bluetooth
- snvzz 3y agoI am not sure what Qualcomm is hoping to accomplish by releasing this, rather than committing to RISC-V.
- lloyds_barclays 3y agoImpressive. I have used laptops with Snapdragon 835 and 850. Native app and battery performance are passable. I wish Microsoft and Qualcomm could bring PCs the same portable experience as Apple Silicon devices.
- jeffbee 3y agoI wonder to what extent their 8-channel memory controller is helping. Intel has been selling 2-channel memory subsystems into the desktop and mobile market for a long time, still doing that even on 24-core CPUs. I believe the cheapest 8-channel CPU Intel offers costs $2000. Perhaps this level of competition will help them fix that.
- wtallis 3y agoDon't count memory channels, count the total bus width. 128 bits wide is nothing special, even if it is divided into eight channels of 16 bits. That's exactly how Intel and AMD support LPDDR, too.
- jeffbee 3y agoThanks, I often forget this distinction.
- menaerus 3y agoSo, when Apple says 128-bit or 512-bit or 1024-bit wide interface to LPDDR4x/LPDDR5, does this really mean just a number that is derived from number_of_channels x channel_width? E.g. 128-bit memory wide bus in case of LPDDR type of memory is really just 8x 16-bit channels or, in a different word-size configuration, 4x 32-bit channels. If that is so, my understanding is that Intel Tiger Lake with its 2x 64-bit channel design would equal to the same 128-bit memory bus width as M1, although, coupled with different type of memory chip technology - DDR4 instead of LPDDR.
- wtallis 3y agoDDR4 and earlier DIMMs are 64 bits per channel. DDR5 is still 64 bits per DIMM, but split into two 32-bit sub-channels. LPDDR is typically 16 bits per channel. For processors whose memory controller supports more than one of these standards, the total bit width is what's fixed in silicon and the processor's pin count; which kind of memory the processor is connected to will determine how many (sub)channels the bus is split into. For about two decades, mainstream consumer x86 platforms have almost always had a 128-bit memory bus. On desktop platforms with DDR4 and earlier, this can be accurately described as dual-channel, and that's the terminology marketing departments and end users are most familiar with. But it's never been accurate for mobile systems that use LPDDR, and DDR5 makes it less accurate for desktops, too. High-end platforms like AMD's Threadripper have supported memory configurations like 256-bit ("quad channel DDR4") and 512-bit ("8 channel DDR4") and now 768-bit on the latest EPYC servers, and over the years Intel has had server or workstation platforms with 192-bit (LGA 1366 socket), 256-bit (LGA 2011), 384-bit (LGA 3467), 512-bit (LGA 4677) memory interfaces (per socket). I believe Apple was the first to ship something wider than 128-bit in a laptop, and AMD plans to be the second in a year or so (not too surprising given what they've been shipping for the console market).
- speed_spread 3y agoThey're big on showing parallel benchmarks but nothing that would give a hint of what the actual single-core IPC is. This doesn't bode that well IMO.
- lern_too_spel 3y agoThose are just the benchmarks Anandtech chose to run. Other sources ran single core benchmarks that show higher performance than any other Arm core. https://www.xda-developers.com/snapdragon-x-elite-benchmarks/ https://www.xda-developers.com/snapdragon-x-elite-benchmarks...
- lostmsu 3y agoAccording to Wikipedia, this one uses 4nm node while M2 is on N5P.
- therealcamino 3y agoWell, as of 13 minutes ago Apple announced the M3 which is on the N3 process.
- neurostimulant 3y ago> Showcasing reference designs for performance purposes is very typical overall for Qualcomm. This is also how the company handles their smartphone testing – in most years we’ll get to benchmark a Snapdragon mobile SoC running in a Qualcomm Reference Device (QRD) as a preview before retail devices are available. Even though they’re not a vertically integrated company, they still need to develop devices to test their own hardware, and they like to use those to initially show off their designs. What's stopping Qualcomm from manufacturing their own phones and laptops and sell them directly to consumers?
- Vt71fcAqt7 3y agoAt least one aspect is that they don't want to compete with their largest client (samsung). And they don't have the manufacturing ability that samsung has to actually win that competition.
- dingi 3y agoThese SOCs could have a better future if they had Linux support to a satisfactory level. I wouldn't touch a Windows ARM device with a ten foot pole, unless of course I can boot Linux on it. Software support is abysmal. On the other hand, due to open source nature of Linux land, the software support is vastly superior provided that the OEM provides upstream drivers.
- DrNosferatu 3y agoThen when are we having Hackintoshes on ARM?