3 ms·
Exactly. No one forces these businesses to sell. It’s the owners easiest retirement plan instead of passing them down to their kids who may not want to or ha
by scarface_74 3y ago
Exactly. No one forces these businesses to sell. It’s the owners easiest retirement plan instead of passing them down to their kids who may not want to or have the skill set to run the family business.
- TeMPOraL 3y agoSure, no one is blaming any individual business for selling. Nor would you blame any particular drop of water for flowing downhill. Still, too much water will make a dam burst and most of the water will flood the land; too much business owners realizing their retirement plan by selling out to PEs, and everyone suffers - including those retirees.
- scarface_74 3y agoAre you going to tell these mom and pop shops they can’t sell?
- TeMPOraL 3y agoOf course not. The problem aren't the mom and pop shops. The problem are the PE companies making those offers. These are the ones to go after.
- scarface_74 3y agoHow is that any different? You’re still trying to stop mom and pop shops from selling out to PE’s. Are you also going to stop startups from getting acquired to? Seeing that only 6 of the hundreds of companies that YC has invested in have ever gone public, acquisitions is the most likely exit
- TeMPOraL 3y agoThe difference is that PE is just one of many kinds of buyers, but the one that has a particular tendency of doing trades with nasty externalities. It's this pattern of buying that is a problem, and I don't see fighting it any different than fighting factories dumping toxic waste into rivers. Factories, in general, are not a problem. Actions that have destructive impact on people at scale are a problem. Startups are a bad example because I absolutely would stop startups from being acquired as a general phenomenon. The pattern of startups seeking an exit is one of the worst economic innovations that happened to the world. They at best just waste time of their users/ customers before inevitable rugpull, and at worst, they actively disrupt whole market segments - not creatively disrupt, just in the "blow the whole thing up with VC money, disappear when it's clear the business was never sustainable" kind of way. And again, it's not the acquisitions as a concept that are the problem - it's the pattern of startups being created with acquisition as the goal that is a problem.
- scarface_74 3y agoAll startups have acquisition as a goal. If not, they aren’t paying attention to statistics. This very site you are on is funded via VCs where only 6 of the hundreds of companies that have been funded have gone public. Who is going to buy these mom and pop shops? Are you going to say that startups can’t be acquired and either have to go public or go out of business when the large companies just put a few people on a clone of their project and crush them?
- TeMPOraL 3y ago> All startups have acquisition as a goal. If not, they aren’t paying attention to statistics. That's a problem, though. I'm under no illusion that startups are founded for purely altruistic reasons, but there used to be more focus on creating an actual business, one that makes money by delivering value to customers. Nowadays, the focus is on exit - and the main strategy is to hype up a shitty MVP to force rapid growth, and then either trick some incumbent corporation into acquiring the startup, or go public and run away with the profit before people figure out the company is just hot air. I'm looking at this from the POV of a customer and a member of society, and as such, I see contemporary startups as wasting everyone's time and hopes, at scale. A perpetual flashy mediocrity that slows progress by starving would-be legitimate businesses for oxygen, and occasionally destroys a random market segment in the process. Once again, the pattern is a problem. Startups are fine, acquisitions are fine, keeping an eye for an exit is fine. The issue is that the entire startup ecosystem - founders and investors alike, and increasingly even acquirers - found a way to game the system, and is busy printing money without doing anything of lasting value, while still burning resources and dumping externalities on the rest of the economy.
- ryandrake 3y agoWhy would a PE firm be buying (for example) a doctor's office if the doctor-owner was retiring? The doctor is why the business exists in the first place. Without him, it's no longer a doctor's office, it's a charming little suite with front desk people and a few nurses running around. We had a local machine shop (that I used to go to for welding) sadly go out of business because the owner was retiring. I asked him if he considered selling it instead so it could stay open and he said "Who would buy it? I am this shop and I'm retiring. In 5 days it's just going to be a pile of tools."
- scarface_74 3y agoFor the patients and as a slow “exit”
- delfinom 3y agoYea I don't see PEs buying a doctor's office. I have seen "mergers". A doctor will join up with another doctor and then disappear in a year or two. That let's them legally sell the practice while weening patients over. I have had a CPA start that process recently too. Suddenly announced he's joined up with this new CPA firm . Not to worry, he'll still be here to take care of our corporate needs and has transferred everything over (he's late 60s and snowbirding already) A PE may buy up a already larger medical practice chain or something, but never individual practices. The machine shop example is rough, he could do a merger retirement as well, but he needs to have consistent clients that he can bring over to another shop before slowly phasing himself out. Which may not have been scenario unfortunately.