4 ms·
This article is...not good. > One answer is that the private-equity industry is devouring them. Another is that public companies buy them and they consolidate
by robertlagrant 3y ago
This article is...not good.
> One answer is that the private-equity industry is devouring them.
Another is that public companies buy them and they consolidate. Another is management buyouts. Another is it's harder to run a business than it used to be, for better or worse, so they close.
> One-fifth of the market has been made effectively invisible to investors, the media, and regulators.
No. You still have financial regulations to follow. If you're a medical device company, you'll still have to follow those regulations. You have employment regulations. All sorts of regulations.
You just don't have to follow regulations for public companies (such as "don't talk about this thing with anyone outside a list until you've announced it publically, because that would be unfair to other investors), which are expensive and onerous, nor follow the whims of the market, which can be expensive and onerous.
E.g. Dell went private and the quality got a lot better.
- Joker_vD 3y agoYep. "Oh no, the investors don't get reliable information about private-equity companies and so investment is way too risky" — well, then investors probably would just stop invest in them? What's the problem?
- Panezirigilloso 3y agoI think you missed a good part of the article. It says that: "A private economy is one in which companies can more easily get away with wrongdoing and an economic crisis can take everyone by surprise." Its not about the investors, is about the economy, the global economy.
- edoceo 3y agoI see how that works for a case like Dell. I've also read about PE buying up smaller medical/dental practices and squeezing the price. Happened to my old dentist in Ballard, WA -- and dang, they pushed me for x-rays on every visit (turns out there is good margin on x-rays). Dell is still run by the OG -- these PE folks are just trying to squeeze margin. And sure, they still have to follow some regulations -- but with much less oversight when you're not public. "expensive and onerous" is not a sufficient reason to not require a business to do something. Paying employees is expensive and onerous, should that stop?
- scarface_74 3y agoWhy do you care if a private company has to follow financial reporting regulations? The reason that public companies have to is because the public buys shares in the company.
- edoceo 3y agoFor a small company, a sole-prop dentist for example -- I don't. There is not enough motivation or sophistication or dollars on the table. For PE backed conglomerates I care because they can and do hide shady things in there. There is more motivation to juke the stats; more sophistication and dollars on the table. Sadly, because these companies are not public, when their anti-consumer operations are discovered there is little news about it. That results in a situation, for example, where folk don't think there is any reason to care about the issue.
- scarface_74 3y agoAgain why do you care as a consumer? If they aren’t getting money from the public market and no taxpayer money, how does that affect you? Whether the company is public or private they still have to follow the relevant laws for their industry.
- edoceo 3y agoI care because these PE backed firms can (and do) screw the consumer (me, my family, my friends, you) and there is no visibility. Do you understand it's possible to follow the law and still use greed to screw the consumer? Are you being intentionally naive?
- scarface_74 3y agoI’m asking you for a specific case where a PE firm could specifically screw you and you have no choice but to be a consumer in a way a public firm couldn’t?
- onlyrealcuzzo 3y agoMost of this goes away when you have positive real interest rates. It makes sense to take on massive amounts of debt to buy things when you get paid to be in debt. Companies that do leveraged buyouts are going to have a good time. When money isn't free - companies that do leveraged buyouts aren't going to have as good of a time.
- lukas099 3y agoDo you mean higher real interest rates? They have been positive almost all of the last 10 years. https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/REAINTRATREARAT10Y https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/REAINTRATREARAT10Y
- michaelt 3y agoThat's the interest rate for people willing to lock their money up for 10 years. Look at https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/REAINTRATREARAT1YE https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/REAINTRATREARAT1YE instead, the 1 year real interest rate, and it's barely been positive between 2009 and 2022.
- lukas099 3y agoOh gotcha, you’re right.
- onlyrealcuzzo 3y agoMy understanding is the 10-y is not relevant to venture debt or leveraged buyouts: https://www.svb.com/startup-insights/venture-debt/how-does-venture-debt-work https://www.svb.com/startup-insights/venture-debt/how-does-v... And anyway - yes - a 1% real return really only existed in a long capacity since the 2000s, since QE became main stream.
- DragonStrength 3y agoDid you read the full article? The majority of it is defending why public financial oversight is good. Saying the article is "not good" while ignoring its central argument to make a tangential point is not convincing.
- robertlagrant 3y agoThe majority of it seemed to be very cherry-picked and caveated claims, with the claims being far more prominent than the caveats. If you want to avoid boom and bust cycles and the pursuit of growth at all costs, you probably want to avoid the public markets if you can, or at least for as long as possible.
- em500 3y ago> This article is...not good. I agree. The opening paragraph reeks of picking numbers to fit a narrative. It states that the number of US listed public firms declined from 8000 in 1996 to 4000 today (suggesting but not explicitly claiming that a significant part has been devoured by PE), but leaves out that the valuation of the public companies in that period increased from 5T to 40T.
- dathos 3y agoI’m not arguing for their suggestion. But if their logic is that this happened because of PE and those PE owning also a big chunk of those public firms, doesn’t your argument proof they are devouring a large part of the economy?
- robertlagrant 3y agoPrivate equity by definition isn't invested in public firms.
- paulryanrogers 3y agoPublic firms can be partially owned by PE, hence the phrase "big chunk"
- robertlagrant 3y agoThey can be owned by firms called "PE firms", but that's not private equity. Their shares will be treated as public shares, obeying the same rules as anything else. The article is concerned about investments that can't be measured in the public markets or regulated as public investments.
- dangus 3y agoYou could also say “all private equity is not created equal.” I think that the common belief that private equity swoops in and sucks the company dry like a vampire is only a half-truth. The “company flipper” style private equity companies are usually buying companies that are not doing all that well in the first place. Not unlike a venture capital firm investment in a startup, private equity firms probably don’t expect 100% of their investments to pan out. The idea is to buy a struggling company for pennies on the dollar, turn it around, make a big return on that investment. However, turning around a struggling business isn’t always going to happen, and when it fails the private equity firms are perceived as vultures. A good example of a company that has done well under private equity ownership has been Popeyes. They launched their extremely popular chicken sandwich under private equity ownership. The parent company has for the most part left the strong parts of the business alone (keeping the product up to a good enough standard) while appeasing franchises’ need for more profitable operations, leading to growth in its footprint.