3 ms·
Wrong. Consider two hypothetical versions of this. One, the exact scenario as you described - history unfolded like it did, until the 1900 alien incident. CS a
by TeMPOraL 3y ago
Wrong.
Consider two hypothetical versions of this. One, the exact scenario as you described - history unfolded like it did, until the 1900 alien incident. CS and information theory is in its infancy. You're correct that most of the necessary work would first go to physics and chemistry and their various spin-off fields, because that's what's needed to build tools necessary to inspect the machine in full detail. The math would develop along the way, and eventually enough CS to make sense of the observations made before.
Now for an alternate scenario: it's the 1900 again, with the twist that CS is already well-developed theoretical field of mathematics (IDK, perhaps the same aliens dropped us a mechanical computer in year 1800). We'd still need to push physics and chemistry (and spin-offs) forward, but this time, we would know what we're looking for. We'd know the thing does computation, we'd be able to model what kind of computation it does. The question would change from "what does this thing do" to "how exactly does it compute the specific things we know it does". I imagine this would speed up the process of getting a complete picture, because it's easier to understand a specific solution to a problem once you know the answer, than it is to figure out the answer along with the solution.
In terms of understanding the brain, we are in the second situation. We may still know little about how the gooey thing ticks, but we have a growing understanding of what comes out of all that ticking, and a very good understanding of the fundamental rules of ticking.
- mjburgess 3y agoNearly every physical system implements every algorithm -- if you wanted to find what in a laptop was 'sorting numbers' that would every part. The light emitted by the screen is being 'sorted' as it is scanned out, the heat air by the fan is being 'sorted' as it swirls around, etc. You cannot ask, "what physical system implements this algorithm?" as an investigative question, the answer is: nearly all of them. This is why computable functions, ie., pure algorithms, are explanatorily useless. They play only a (observer-relative) 'design role' in creating real programs.
- ben_w 3y agoYou're normally a lot more coherent than you have been in this thread, so… are you feeling alright? Getting enough sleep? > The light emitted by the screen is being 'sorted' as it is scanned out, the heat air by the fan is being 'sorted' as it swirls around, etc. This reads like either you're trolling, or that was written by an LLM, or English isn't your native language, or don't know what 'sorting' is, or you don't know what screens and fans do. It's so fundamentally wrong I was actually tempted to get ChatGPT to respond to it, but that would be a bit mean and add little. You're better than this. What's wrong?
- mjburgess 3y agothere's nothing garbled about this idea -- not sure about my messaging in this thread, maybe the explanations are a bit looser today A computable function is a function from naturals to the naturals typically specified as an algorithm: a sequence of steps by which input numbers are transformed into output numbers. Eg., consider sorting: 101, 001, 111, etc. Now any physical system can have any component part associated with 0 or 1. There is no reason, a priori, to suppose that voltage flux on a CPU is a "1" or a "0" any more than to associate a photon emission. If one associates a photon emission at some location with a 0, and another with a 1, then displaying content on a screen is a form of sorting. Likewise a planet orbiting the sun is implementing a while(true) i = -1*i, if one associates -1/1 with position of the planet orbiting the sun. This is the heart of 'reversible computing'. The only reason we associate some microscopic part of a CPU with 0, 1, etc. is by design it is something we as observers bring to bare on our interpretation of the physical system. But there's an infinite number of such attributions. We would only ever come to conclude that voltage flux across transitiors was relevant to the operation of a laptop via physics experiments --- no hope via computer science. This is very important for understanding why csci is presently useless and misinformative as far as the brain is concerned. There are an infinite number of 0/1 attributions to make, and infinite number of algorithms being implemented etc. almost all of those are irrelevant. Just, as you detect the absurdity, of using sorting algorithms to understand how an LCD works. This is presently less absurd than people talking about neural networks and equivocating with brain structures
- 3y ago