4 ms·
I mildly disagree (although your final conclusion is correct: it indeed does nothing for science). The deepest fundamental structures in the brain[0] are quant
by ben_w 3y ago
I mildly disagree (although your final conclusion is correct: it indeed does nothing for science).
The deepest fundamental structures in the brain[0] are quantum fields, which are also the deepest fundamental structures in everything else.
There is no known quantum field of "soul" or "intelligence".
The right abstraction is higher, and could still be a whole lot of things; but as maths can be implemented in logic, which can be implemented in electronics or clockwork or hydraulics, it doesn't matter what analogy is used — and my mild disagreement here is that such inspiration has been useful and gotten us this far.
[0] that we know of
- mjburgess 3y agoThe process of evolution acts on organic systems, it doesn't act on quantum fields. I appreciate there's some (imv strange) sense of 'intelligence' where 'finding the right puzzle piece' counts. I cannot fathom why we care about such a notion, and it seems to have almost nothing to do with what we do care about re 'intelligence'. We care about that thing animals do, that thing which some do better than others. That thing which evolution brought about for (rapid) adaptive fitness to one's environment. 'Everything else is stamp collecting' We already have a perfectly good understanding of puzzles and their solutions -- animals are their inventors Intelligence isnt in the solution to a puzzle it's in its design, and especially, in what one does when one cannot solve it -- ie., how one adapts The csci view of 'intelligence' is an act of self-aggrandising, it turns out to be: csci! This is none-sense.
- ben_w 3y agoWe can simulate evolution in a computer, and this is used as a form of AI directly. That said, the way you're using biological evolution in your comment sounds as much like a strange analogy as all of the others: we may have some genetically programmed responses to snakes (bad) and potential mates (good), but we can also say that a loss of hydraulic pressure in our brain is a stroke, and use electrical signals to both read from and write to the brain. What we evolved to think, while interesting from a social perspective, seems to me like the least interesting part of our brains from an AI perspective — it's the bit that looks like a hard-coded computer program, not learning, on the scale of a human life and seen from within.
- mjburgess 3y agoi'm referring to evolution as the process by which animals were built if aliens had come down and given us laptops, rather we invented digital machines, then likewise i'd be talking about the relevant materials science, physics etc. reverse engineering a laptop to figure out how it works would require extremely little computer science, and 'only at the end' the reason digital computers are interesting and useful is that they route electricity around devices which are designed to be responsive to one another. the patterns of activation, as managed by the CPU, are weakly describable by abstract algorithms like sorting starting with a laptop, and no further information, we'd be 100(s)+ years of research away from needing to understand that CPUs were implementing a sorting algorithm and importantly, that it is doing so has almost nothing to do with the value of the device -- which lies in its ability to provide 'dynamical power and modulation of operation' using electricity we're in the same situation with animals and people think that, what, understanding gradient descent or backprop is helpful? this is just some csci bs
- ben_w 3y agoI'm not really following you, sorry; this is all too disjointed. > we're in the same situation with animals and people think that, what, understanding gradient descent or backprop is helpful? this is just some csci bs Assuming I've actually got your point for this (and I'm not sure I have): The backpropagation algorithm itself might be "just some csci bs" (it sure has vibes of "let us shortcut the maths rather than find out how our brains did it"), but gradient descent is nice and general-purpose — much like how evolution is both good for biology and in simulation for everything else.
- mjburgess 3y agoTo get my point, imagine a laptop was delivered by an alien in the year 1900. Now, try to take that seriously and think about the laptop as an actual object of experimental curiosity -- what exactly does science need to invent, discover, describe etc. to understand the operation of that laptop? 99.999% of that new knowledge has to be in physics and chemistry, before the tiny 0.0001% of theoretical csci knowlegde is brought to bare. Consider how impossible it would be to apply any csci knowledge first: we do not even have the ability to measure the cpu state! So we could not even identify any part of the system with 0s, 1s, etc. Now: that's a laptop! Imagine now you're dealing with an animal. Hopefully its now clear how ridiculous it is to describe basically any aspect of our mode of operation by starting with trivial little csci algorithms. It would be insane even with an actual electronic computer, let alone an organic system. A system whereby clearly our organic properties are radically fundamental to our mode of operation