5 ms·
Xbox's new policy – say goodbye to unofficial accessories from November
- ponco 3y agoThe security/cheating arguments are good cover for MS simply enforcing their IP rights.
- janosdebugs 3y agoI wonder how a controller can viably be used to cheat, and if so, how would rigging an official controller not have the same effect. Additionally, single player games don't have a cheating problem.
- adesanmi 3y agoLook up Xim, it gives an unfair advantage to console players by allowing a mouse and keyboard input when the developer hasn’t intended so (official APIs exist if they do). Cronus is also especially bad. It also allows you to effectively nullify recoil through custom scripts uploaded to it. It’s everywhere in multiplayer PvP games on console.
- jwestbury 3y ago> It also allows you to effectively nullify recoil through custom scripts uploaded to it. Valve seems to have done a pretty good job dealing with this in their games. Surely there exist more sophisticated anti-cheat mechanisms than "just ban third-party accessories"?
- vasdae 3y agoValve's anticheat is atrocious, Counter-Strike is an absolute cesspool (so much that they've had to separate players who bought the game from players who play the free version), and Team Fortress 2 has had more bots than players for like 10 years now. This seems like the kind of thing that is repeated so much because some people want to believe it, and most of the time I bet it's people who haven't played a Valve multiplayer game ever.
- jwestbury 3y agoTo be fair -- it's been a couple of years since I played Valve multiplayer games regularly. Has cheating increased at a high rate in the past, say, 3-4 years? I will say, I think the biggest problem contributing to high levels of cheating is the move away from dedicated servers. I actually find that VAC is historically very effective at catching cheaters, but with a necessary lag between detection and bans -- and that lag used to be handled by server admins.
- realusername 3y agoI'm sure somebody will design the exact same thing with an official controller stripped out with the buttons remapped into a mouse and keyboard with a custom pcb. There's no way to prevent that from happening with software changes.
- happymellon 3y agoDoesn't the Adaptive Controller basically give you the same thing? If people want to plug random usb controllers, this doesn't stop them. It just means that Microsoft gets to charge you for the adaptor rather than a 3rd party.
- sharperguy 3y agoThe only real solution to the cheating problem would be to get rid of automated matching systems and go back to moderated gaming rooms where there is always a human who can decide if they think someone is cheating and boot them. You do lose a lot of features that way though, such as a reliable global ranking, since it would be easy to create a room with only your friends and allow eachother to rank up quickly. It's also a huge coordination issue if you want to arrange a game of 50-100 players who aren't all total strangers to eachother. But the alternative seems to be in stripping the ancient practice of gaming of its social functions and turning it into a faceless slot machine where the only goal is to win enough times to increase a mostly meaningless number on a screen.
- PebblesHD 3y agoI don’t really see any way this could not be anti-competitive. A perfectly functional peripheral was rendered non-functional at an arbitrary date with no benefit to consumers and with an obvious benefit to the party making the change in terms of increased licensing fee income. Why is this sort of behaviour allowed? Yet another move by MS contrary to the ‘see we arent the same company as we used to be’ vibe they’ve tried to cultivate.
- shiroiuma 3y ago>Yet another move by MS contrary to the ‘see we arent the same company as we used to be’ vibe they’ve tried to cultivate. If you believe their claims about that, I have a bridge to sell you...
- adesanmi 3y agoXim users destroying the integrity of multiplayer FPS causes this, unfortunately. The fact of the matter is if you’re allowed to plug in any peripheral into a game console, you can and will get prolific cheaters in a multiplayer environment. Maybe only bring in this check if your console is not in offline mode? And please make it cheap to actually get certified. Regular accessories that don’t alter gameplay can and should always be an option for a user. If a certification process has to happen to use the accessory online, so be it, but I hope this doesn’t hurt the market too much. Edit: I’m aware that Xim currently uses controller authentication to work and therefore this specific change may not affect it. I wasn’t claiming that this would get rid of Xim, but arguing that a huge reason for this change is to begin the process of cracking down on rampant cheating in online multiplayer games (shooters in particular).
- robertlagrant 3y ago> Maybe only bring in this check if your console is not in offline mode? Or only if you're playing a multiplayer game?
- piaste 3y agoLeave that up to the game devs. Expose a platform API call with all relevant information about the accessories currently plugged into the console. That way a game can check that API whenever cheating matters for that particular game - which may mean different things: playing with strangers, playing certain 'competitive' modes, getting achievements or high scores, etc.
- apinnes 3y agoI don't fall out with the desire of an official accessory program, but to make existing accessories obsolete from Nov 12th is a really disappointingly poor decision. It needlessly creates e-waste of these products, and likely disproportionately impacts those less well off who's only option would be to pick cheaper, unlicensed accessories.
- mnd999 3y agoError 0x82d60002 seems intentionally user hostile as well.
- okasaki 3y agoStill better than "Oops, something went wrong" that most webapps do though.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- jjn2009 3y agoI think this sort of attitude towards hardware devices will massively limit the potential for attacks on our hardware via our ports. We should push for protocols that verify the hardware on the other end is either a known or approved device.
- csense 3y agoClearly, we can't have users with uses you don't approve of [/s] https://xkcd.com/129/ https://xkcd.com/129/
- whelp_24 3y agoWhat sort of imaginary attacks are you talking about? Also, removing your ability to use your devices with this device arbitrarily makes this device less "our hardware" and more 'Microsoft's Hardware".
- arp242 3y agoThese kind of attacks are pretty rare in general, and for X-Box machines even more so (if they even exist at all). It's not really a huge deal for most people, and locking everything down for everyone is a huge price to pay. It also seems to me that most actors deploying these kind of attacks can bypass these limits them without too much trouble. If you really want this protection then you can just lock it down yourself.
- edandersen 3y agoGoes against Microsoft's "green" push doesn't it? How many usable controllers in landfill now as a result of this?
- Voultapher 3y agoThe whole greenwashing thing of big tech is mostly a scam in my opinion or at best delusional. Watching the Apple event and segment on recycling made me sick. It's reduce, reuse and only then recycle. Sitting there patting each other on the back for some recycling, while simultaneously sabotaging reparability and long term use, which goes directly against reuse. And what about reduce? Wild idea, release an iPhone every two years. More innovation per release, less limited resources used. But nooo, every time there is a conflict between their bottom line and not destroying the ecosphere, they pick the money. And they in this context are capitalistic companies, including Microsoft. One can only convince me of their true values when they choose them when it's inconvenient to do so.
- sph 3y agoMeanwhile I've seen someone attach a USB hub with wheel-and-pedals, shifter and handbrake to a Steam Deck. Given the rising competition from Valve (they have solved the hard problem of running Windows games on Linux), and Sony (the Xbox exclusive selection this generation is a joke compared to the Playstation), and Microsoft's own bone-headed decisions, I'm really bearish about the long term prospects of the Xbox brand. They'll probably rebrand as a cloud gaming service soon enough.
- vinckr 3y agoValve's Anticheat is a joke
- Already__Taken 3y agothe ban hammer hits hard though
- sph 3y agoAnticheat is an all-consuming endeavour that can never be solved. The status quo these days is encrypted binaries that kill performance and kernel level spy modules. No thanks. Whatever Valve does works for Counter-Strike and Dota 2, with 1.2 million online players this very instant. A bit arrogant to say their system is a joke. It is evidently good enough.
- YPPH 3y agoWhen you play online on this locked down device, you usually end up crossplaying with PC players who have the ability to run exploits, making any anti-hacking arguments baseless. Turn off crossplay and you don't find games with reasonable latency.
- znpy 3y agoI love this, and I wish this could happen more often. I can't understand why Apple can get away with making your hardware completely non-functional but other companies cannot. More companies should go full-Apple with their software and their hardware. Maybe then we'll finally get something done from regulators.
- WhereIsTheTruth 3y agoWhat a shame.. they'll create ton of e-waste as a result.. for a problem that should have been fixed with software Xbox sells very poorly, and it doesn't look like they're trying to improve the situation https://www.vgchartz.com/ https://www.vgchartz.com/
- aboringusername 3y agoThis is why it's hard to take the 'climate change' argument seriously. Why can companies issue a software change without having to provide a public risk assessment of the impact of making such a change - especially in regards to the proper handling and disposal of the now - assuredly useless - devices? Sometimes you have to wonder about all the energy required to make the materials and components to make these products just for a software update to render them all useless...complete waste. Why not allow a longer lead time? Or deny any new made devices going forwards whilst older ones are EOL? I feel there are many better solutions than "sorry pls throw away thx". I'd really like to see studies of the human impact and cost of what a single software update can do - my understanding is it all ends up in landfill to rot and hardly anything is recycled.
- YurgenJurgensen 3y agoWhy is it that we get a "We have modified the deal. Pray we do not modify it further." moment basically every week these days?
- ralferoo 3y agoI suspect this will be a disaster. The article already hints at the reason why: "there's no indication yet that it has impacted Cronus or XIM accessories. Cronus and XIM accessories are controversial since they allow users to mimic a mouse and keyboard as an Xbox controller." Currently, most third-party accessories correctly use their own USB VID:PID pair and are recognised as controllers by virtue of correctly implementing the USB HID protocols. By deciding to block anything that isn't approved by Microsoft, they'll necessarily have to whitelist a set of VID:PID pairs for devices that have been approved, and so unapproved third-party accessories will just fake their VID:PID pairs and present as another device. Once this happens, there's no way of blacklisting the clones without impacting the genuine devices, unless they further have undocumented identification methods e.g. incorrectly responding to standard messages (e.g. the PS3 controller reported an incorrect number of axes, but would return data correctly when queried) or adding non-standard packet types.
- NessDan 3y agoTo add to this, PS4 queries the controller every 8 minutes for a challenge authentication response and PS5 controllers send the controller state, an incrementing number, and finally an encrypted hash of the above at the end of every data packet. I know because I had to try implementing it for my project https://keyboard.gg https://keyboard.gg
- pawelduda 3y agoWhy allow hall effect stick 3rd party controllers when you can only allow official ones with shitty potentiometers that will guarantee stick drift so people have to buy more. Looking at you too Sony
- whelp_24 3y agoYou shouldn't be able to remove features retroactively. Especially when it's clearly to make money.
- bastard_op 3y agoI do hope there is backlash from this, it's not like Microsoft hasn't known about the jank controllers for some time that work still, but removing them so long into the lifespan of the product just angers everyone. Most affected will be those with "hitbox" products that are mostly self-made or hobbyist-focused devices at least, which they'll be the most angry and vocal about it decrying the affront. It'll just cause a sea of current Chinese crap-gadgets to hit the landfills, then Chinese manufacturers will clone whatever security chip Microsoft mandates, and start shipping them again by the millions.
- NessDan 3y agoThis sucks. This impacts a project I've been working on for a while now: https://keyboard.gg/ https://keyboard.gg/ For those who don't know, it's near impossible to get licensed if you're not a large company. Nintendo is currently the only console now that doesn't do officially licensed accessory checks. I had spent about a month trying to add PlayStation support only to find out that they have authentication checks every 8 minutes leading to always having to unplug and plug your controller back in. I don't know... I had just been really excited to make a solid keyboard adapter that would work for all major consoles and this is extra bad news on top.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- SliceOfWaifu 3y agoAs if Microsoft hadn't already done enough to alienate the fighting game community. A lot of fighting game players use Brook adapters and PCBs for their fightsticks/controllers. Nobody wants to buy a second $200 arcade stick just to play Killer Instinct lol. This will render those adapters useless unless Brook can figure out a way to update the firmware to fool the check. I'm pretty sure that's what they've been doing on the PS4/PS5 to bypass the 8 minute timeout.