4 ms·

I'm also a heavy user of ad blockers, but there is something to be said in defense of YouTube. Creators have the final decision on the ads shown. I have a YouT

I'm also a heavy user of ad blockers, but there is something to be said in defense of YouTube. Creators have the final decision on the ads shown. I have a YouTube channel, and I always disable monetization on all my videos, so no ads are ever shown on my channel. If you see an ad, it's because the creator decided to include one. YouTube is simply the platform that enables this choice.

radley 3y ago
That's not correct. A few years ago YouTube changed their TOS, so they're now allowed to show ads on any content, regardless of settings.
- amadvance 3y ago
  You're mixing up two different things. It's true that YouTube now places ads to small channels that have not reached the monetization requirements. But after the channel satisfy such requirements, like 1000 subscribers, the creator gets control of the monetization and they can choose. For any major channel you watch, it's the creator decision that you see ads or not.
bongobingo1 3y ago
Is it an on-off switch, or a slider for how many and when?
- iforgotpassword 3y ago
  Your can individually toggle pre- mid- and Post-Roll ads. Your can even set suggested spots within the video for the mid-roll ads, but that doesn't really control how many will actually be played. This applies to videos with no copyrighted content. If you use any excerpts or music that someone else claims, anything might happen to your video regarding ads.
windowsrookie 3y ago
That's not necessarily true. If you are not in the Youtube partner program, Youtube can still monetize your videos and keep the ad money for themselves.
samplatt 3y ago
My YT account has a total of five personally-recorded videos (from the era where smartphone cameras still sucked) with no music in the background and no monetisation on any of them. One of the videos was hit with an automated DMCA takedown, one was hit with a "mature content" takedown, and the remaining 3 have ads on them now.
Prickle 3y ago
They are actually removing the ability to control ads in the near future. To my understanding, the only ads creators will have full control over are midroll ads. They will be improving ads on the platform by removing the creator's control over them. > optimizing creator revenue and taking the guesswork out of which ad formats to use by removing individual ad controls for pre-roll, post-roll, skippable, and non-skippable ads on newly uploaded videos. https://support.google.com/youtube/thread/233723152/simplifying-improving-ad-controls?hl=en https://support.google.com/youtube/thread/233723152/simplify...
- amadvance 3y ago
  From what is written, they plan to reduce the control of where ads are placed, but still allow enabling or disabling them. Anyway, at present it's possible to disable them if you have reached the monetization requirements on the channel, like 1000 subscribers and some amount of hours viewed.

radley 3y ago

That's not correct. A few years ago YouTube changed their TOS, so they're now allowed to show ads on any content, regardless of settings.

amadvance 3y ago
You're mixing up two different things. It's true that YouTube now places ads to small channels that have not reached the monetization requirements. But after the channel satisfy such requirements, like 1000 subscribers, the creator gets control of the monetization and they can choose. For any major channel you watch, it's the creator decision that you see ads or not.

bongobingo1 3y ago

Is it an on-off switch, or a slider for how many and when?

iforgotpassword 3y ago
Your can individually toggle pre- mid- and Post-Roll ads. Your can even set suggested spots within the video for the mid-roll ads, but that doesn't really control how many will actually be played. This applies to videos with no copyrighted content. If you use any excerpts or music that someone else claims, anything might happen to your video regarding ads.

windowsrookie 3y ago

That's not necessarily true. If you are not in the Youtube partner program, Youtube can still monetize your videos and keep the ad money for themselves.

samplatt 3y ago

My YT account has a total of five personally-recorded videos (from the era where smartphone cameras still sucked) with no music in the background and no monetisation on any of them. One of the videos was hit with an automated DMCA takedown, one was hit with a "mature content" takedown, and the remaining 3 have ads on them now.

Prickle 3y ago

They are actually removing the ability to control ads in the near future. To my understanding, the only ads creators will have full control over are midroll ads. They will be improving ads on the platform by removing the creator's control over them. > optimizing creator revenue and taking the guesswork out of which ad formats to use by removing individual ad controls for pre-roll, post-roll, skippable, and non-skippable ads on newly uploaded videos. https://support.google.com/youtube/thread/233723152/simplifying-improving-ad-controls?hl=en https://support.google.com/youtube/thread/233723152/simplify...

amadvance 3y ago
From what is written, they plan to reduce the control of where ads are placed, but still allow enabling or disabling them. Anyway, at present it's possible to disable them if you have reached the monetization requirements on the channel, like 1000 subscribers and some amount of hours viewed.