4 ms·
The point 9 about falsifiability needs a lot more nuance. The problem is that we cannot get away from unfalsifiable hypotheses. No matter how far we probe into
by kazinator 3y ago
The point 9 about falsifiability needs a lot more nuance. The problem is that we cannot get away from unfalsifiable hypotheses. No matter how far we probe into some phenomenon, there is always the question "why?" beyond which we don't know.
When we are left with a "why", our only choices are (1) take an agnostic stance and decline to make hypotheses, (2) make unfalsifiable hypotheses. If we choose (2) there are unfalsifiable hypotheses that are superior and those that are inferior. The superior ones are ones which postulate less. The best unfalsifiable hypothesis is the one which postulates no hidden variables. The answer to "why" (why things are the way they are, and not in some other arrangement) is that (a) other arrangements for a universe are valid and exist, but we are biased because we are intelligent beings which live in a particular arrangement and only that one is observable to us (the "anthropic principle"); and (b) in fact, why not: all the other possible universes exist, just not "here". (If they don't, then we need to come up with a hypothetical reason why they don't, which is more complicated than assuming there is no reason: by Occam's Razor, we just trim that out.)
What we don't want to be doing is spouting some unfalsifiable hypothesis as if it were unvarnished truth; but nevertheless, we can pick the best one and defend it against the others, when they come up.
I should add that there is nothing wrong with postulating theoretical entities and processes; doing so has served us well, and in many cases, additional discoveries lended reality to the postulated entities. E.g. atoms were originally a philosophical construct based on the idea that subdividing matter into smaller pieces has to bottom out at some indivisible particle; and that's where we got the atom word. Subatomic particles were postulated initially too. These are not exactly the same as hidden variables because their existence is falsifiable. We have evidence that there exists an electron, for instance, even though originally it was just postulated.