3 ms·
Or in the case of video ads, you could stream the ad as part of the video itself instead of a separate pre roll. Back when people watched an actual "tube", ads
by userbinator 3y ago
Or in the case of video ads, you could stream the ad as part of the video itself instead of a separate pre roll.
Back when people watched an actual "tube", ads were indeed like that. Yet VCRs could easily detect and skip over them when recording. Remember that this was before AI too, so the technology exists to counter it already.
I suspect YouTube keeps the ads separate from the content because the sort of "splicing" that would be required is not trivial to do at the scale YouTube handles video. Also, perhaps they'd rather users who are adblocking not waste their bandwidth downloading ad videos which are going to be ignored anyway.
- satvikpendem 3y ago> Yet VCRs could easily detect and skip over them when recording How did they do that? Is there any more information on this topic?
- marapuru 3y agoIn the Netherlands I remember typing in a code to record something. That code corresponded to a specific start and end timestamp. So in that case it ‘skipped’ the commercials.
- satvikpendem 3y agoSeems to be similar to the SponsorBlock extension for YouTube then, where start and end timestamps are crowdsourced for various types of filler, such as intros and end credits, sponsor segments, calls to subscribe, etc.
- briHass 3y agoI think this may be referring to DVRs of the early 2000s. They used basic logic to look for a blip (dropout) in the video signal that usually happened when a commercial break was inserted. It worked surprisingly well. The parallels here are uncanny, because there were tons of lawsuits from networks unhappy about this, as well as lawsuits from consumers making similar arguments as seen in this thread about how advertisements are awful and they don't have any responsibility to watch them.
- userbinator 3y agoHere's a thread from 2 decades ago with some more information: https://www.hometheaterforum.com/community/threads/vcrs-and-commercial-skip-do-they-work.42956/ https://www.hometheaterforum.com/community/threads/vcrs-and-... In particular this interesting tidbit: Also there are tones in the audio and/or material in scan lines 484-525 whose purpose is to tell the sponsors' automatic monitoring and auditing devices that the commercials were aired at the proper times and that VCR's can also use for commercial advance ...and apparently this was available in the mid 90s: https://www.orlandosentinel.com/1995/09/20/with-this-vcr-commercials-automatically-bite-the-dust/ https://www.orlandosentinel.com/1995/09/20/with-this-vcr-com...