13 ms·
You can just go look this up instead of trying to rebut it through axiomatic derivation from a meme. Doctors washed their hands in Semmelweiss's time. There's a
by tptacek 3y ago
You can just go look this up instead of trying to rebut it through axiomatic derivation from a meme. Doctors washed their hands in Semmelweiss's time. There's a reason writeups of his contributions often include the recipe for his decontamination solution; that's the novelty, of antiseptic washes versus ordinary soap and water.
Similarly, you can just go look up Semmelweis' mental state at the time of his commitment.
The difference between Semmelweis's incorrect theory of what was causing childbed fever and reality is a big part of why his interventions were rejected (that, and the fact that he was apparently an unholy asshole) --- he was trying to convince his colleagues to disinfect their hands from particles that sometimes could not have existed, and the colleagues noticed that. If you're trying to evangelize a new medical intervention, don't get hung up on an explanation that can't possibly be correct, is one lesson to take from this.
Complicated dude. Read more about him than you have. It's interesting stuff. His story is more than just the airport bookstore management parable that it's become.
later
As a quick PS: the "gentleman's hands" thing came up on an AskHistorians thread I just read, and it's apparently a misquote. It's not "gentleman don't wash their hands"; it's "a gentleman's hands are clean". As in, doctors already keep their hands clean. What they didn't do was chlorinate the water they used (or clean all that hard).
That's obviously false! The contagionists and aseptics were right, the spontaneous generation people were wrong, and obviously aseptic procedure before Gordon and later Holmes and later Semmelweis was inadequate. I'm not defending the guy who said that. But he didn't say what you think he said.
- matheusmoreira 3y agoThe incompleteness of the theory is completely irrelevant. He published results and reproduced his findings. He correlated a rise in mortality to the time the necropsies started, and he demonstrated a decrease in mortality after implementing his hand sanitization method twice. That's more trustworthy than quite a bit of what passses for science even today. Doesn't matter how much of an asshole he was, when faced with that undeniable evidence clearly showing that women were dying less the last thing those scientists should have done was dismiss it out of hand and condemn women to death for their negligence. To me it sounds like they deserved every bit of denouncing they got and then some.
- tptacek 3y agoAll of this matters. You write as if he provided a succinct record of a series of experiments he conducted; in fact, he infamously wrote ponderous and impenetrable litanies on the precise cadaveric origin of the particles he thought he was combating. I understand the message board rhetorical strategy of trying to put me on the other side of the aseptic revolution, but (1) no and (2) that has nothing to do with what I'm writing. The bar you need to clear here is much higher than "Semmelweis was correct about chlorinated lime".
- matheusmoreira 3y ago> he infamously wrote ponderous and impenetrable litanies on the precise cadaveric origin of the particles he thought he was combating Which doesn't invalidate the fact that women provably died less after his methods of combating those particles were implemented and published. Faced with that evidence, they should have accepted the method even if they don't agree simply because you can't argue with results. They could have saved women and followed up with further study on the exact nature of the problem which would only become clear when Pasteur came along. They chose to institutionalize him out of embarrassment. I'm not "putting you on the other side" of anything. I don't agree with your minimization of the guy's achievements nor with your characterization of him as "crazy".
- tptacek 3y agoThe scholarly debate about Semmelweiss is whether he had syphilis or young-onset dementia. He was not committed to a sanitarium out of pique over his demands that people chlorinate water. Again: you can just look this stuff up! These points might seem kind of nitpicky, but Semmelweis has become a sort of patron saint for brooding nerds with strong but iconoclastic ideas, a shibboleth for "history will show I was right all along". Semmelweis was not, in fact, right all along, and his evident failure to persuade his peers --- stemming from what was in a sense an opposition to the germ theory of disease --- probably set science back a little bit, on margin. Not by much, though; Semmelweis was in his time one of several people expounding the same intervention.