3 ms·
> But Uber drivers also tend to drive their vehicles into the ground. This higher rate of utilization can lead to a lot of damage — certainly more than Hertz wa
by crazygringo 3y ago
> But Uber drivers also tend to drive their vehicles into the ground. This higher rate of utilization can lead to a lot of damage — certainly more than Hertz was anticipating.
I'm mainly curious how Hertz got this so wrong.
They must have gathered some kinds of stats on Tesla repair rates per mile driven -- why did the math turn out to be wrong? Does driving an EV 10,000 miles over the course of a month damage it far more than driving 10,000 miles over the course of a year?
Or if they knew there were big unknowns, I'm surprised Hertz didn't or wasn't able to offset a lot of the risk of higher damage rates to Tesla as part of a fixed-fee maintenance contract or something.
There's always the possibility that a low-level analyst just messed up their spreadsheet, but it's hard to believe that passed executive review. When a team pitches their proposal to the execs, it's precisely the execs' job to look at the slides and challenge each and every number and say "hey wait a minute, these numbers for wear-and-tear seem in line with historical, but two slides ago you said 50% of the fleet will be for rideshare." If they missed it, that would be a gigantic failure of management.
- dragontamer 3y agoHertz is the original meme stock, meming its way out of bankruptcy. Its not about being wrong, its about doing things that get investors to pump money into your company. Tesla is meme-adjacent and Hertz knew that making headlines with Tesla would attract investors. Now that Hertz lost money, its not their problem. Its their investor's problem. Or perhaps more accurately: its not the Board of Directors or CEO's problem that Hertz lost money per se, they did what they set out to do (ie: sell Hertz stock during a difficult time and raise money). All the Hertz shareholders who have lost real value are... well... that's the shareholder's problem now.
- FirmwareBurner 3y ago>All the Hertz shareholders who have lost real value are... well... that's the shareholder's problem now Let's see them meme their way out of that one now.
- koolba 3y ago> Or if they knew there were big unknowns … It’s possible the driving habits in a rental Tesla are unique as well. There’s already the general principle, “Don’t be gentle on a rental”, but perhaps the novelty of an electric car with a unique pedal system (compared to a gas vehicle) leads to more aggressive driving?
- dghlsakjg 3y agoReminds me of a pithy joke in car groups. What's the fastest car in the world? A rental
- SoftTalker 3y ago> Does driving an EV 10,000 miles over the course of a month damage it far more than driving 10,000 miles over the course of a year? Assuming 10,000 miles over a 30 day month, driving every day that's over 300 miles per day. That's pushing the limit of the range if not more, so they are fully cycling the battery every day. That's not good for battery life.
- michaelt 3y ago> They must have gathered some kinds of stats on Tesla repair rates per mile driven I mean - would they? Tesla is famously secretive about defects, not putting anything in writing to customers and asking them to sign NDAs - so I doubt Tesla is handing out honest numbers to potential partners. And even if they ran a small-scale trial before making a big purchase, there's a lot of ways a small trial can accidentally be unrepresentative.
- crazygringo 3y agoWell that's what I'm saying -- if they couldn't, they should have negotiated a fixed-price maintenance contract. That's what companies do when one can't trust the other -- they hold the manufacturer responsible for the cost of repairs/replacements rather than doing it themselves. And if a manufacturer refuses to agree at a reasonable rate, you don't do the deal because that's a huge red flag the numbers are dishonest.
- listenallyall 3y agoThat's very cute of you to blame "a low-level analyst." The Tesla deal was executive hubris -- an activist CEO (INTERIM CEO at that) of a ruined global company in bankruptcy trying to make a name for himself by swinging for the fences. Employees could have produced piles of documentation and analytics predicting massive losses, low demand, high repair costs, whatever, none of that would have changed his mind. Because of that, it's more than likely there was no analysis whatsoever. This was not an analytically-driven decision, it was an impulse buy. Electric vehicles are now mainstream, and we've only just begun to see rising global demand and interest," Hertz interim CEO Mark Fields said in a statement. https://www.npr.org/2021/10/25/1048953565/hertz-will-buy-100-000-teslas-electric-vehicles https://www.npr.org/2021/10/25/1048953565/hertz-will-buy-100...
- Kon-Peki 3y ago> The Tesla deal was executive hubris -- an activist CEO (INTERIM CEO at that) of a ruined global company in bankruptcy trying to make a name for himself by swinging for the fences. I was with you all the way until you revealed that it was Mark Fields. The guy that saved Mazda, turned around Aston Martin, Land Rover, and then Ford; responsible for making sure the Mustang Mach-E was produced, and then retired after decades in the auto industry. They dragged him out of a very rich retirement, and he certainly made the mistake that Teslas are cheap/easy to operate at scale. But trying to make a name for himself - definitely not.
- listenallyall 3y agoSaved Ford? During Fields’ tenure as Ford CEO from 2014-17, Ford’s stock declined by about 40 percent During his tenure at Ford, he refused to relocate his family from South Florida to the region. Instead, he initially used Ford’s corporate jet to be with them every weekend. The disclosure sparked a furor, given that Ford was ailing at the time Fields was forced out in 2017 in the wake of Ford’s more than five percent decline in car sales. https://www.deadlinedetroit.com/articles/29110/starkman_former_ford_ceo_mark_fields_disses_detroit_yet_again_with_hertz_s_big_bet_on_tesla https://www.deadlinedetroit.com/articles/29110/starkman_form... Sounds like a guy whose reputation had been tarnished, now taking advantage of a new, unexpected opportunity as CEO to re-establish it by making big, headline moves in a short time with someone else's money. But whatever your opinion of him, an experienced, longtime executive tasked with making big turnaround moves strengthens the hypothesis that the Tesla decision was a CEO mandate without any analysis or discussion or opposition voices tolerated.