3 ms·
> Making a realistic CG fire isn't hard. I can (and do) do it by myself on my home desktop. Can you really? On the clothing of a human body that's in motion in
by crazygringo 3y ago
> Making a realistic CG fire isn't hard. I can (and do) do it by myself on my home desktop.
Can you really? On the clothing of a human body that's in motion in a strong wind? That accurately illuminates that human and the environment around them? And the fire and illuminated objects are all properly reflected on adjacent shiny surfaces like car window and car hood?
Because that's the scenario presented at the very top of the article. And it does indeed sound dastardly difficult. Or while it's maybe possible with enough painstaking work, it's difficult enough that no movie would ever have a large enough budget for it. (Although I really do wonder if we have accurate enough physics models of the igniting gases to truly realistically show the way licks of flames ignite in a strong wind -- as opposed to a more bog-standard campfire type.)
- aceazzameen 3y agoI disagree for the need for complete physical accuracy. The illusion of accuracy can be equally as strong in film. Film has always been about creating successful illusions. But figuring out how to create the illusion for a specific shot takes an experienced artist time. Time they are rarely given these days and aren't being paid enough to do. I think OP is saying he has that freedom and time to do exactly that on his desktop.
- crazygringo 3y agoBut the article is about so many examples of unsuccessful illusions. So that's what I'm questioning: do we really have the technical ability to create realistic-enough fire in these types of complex scenarios? Even given a reasonable but realistic timeframe? Just because we can easily make realistic-enough fire in some scenarios doesn't mean we can in all. And clothing on fire on a human body in motion in the wind sounds like one of the hardest scenarios of all.
- aceazzameen 3y agoYes, but you won't see it often because VFX artists aren't paid what they're worth, are given unrealistic timeframes, and are even given sloppy direction that is counter to what a realistic effect should look like.
- Notatheist 3y agoSorry I'm late. I wasn't saying all they needed to do to get perfectly realistic fire in all scenarios is hire one guy with a 1950x. Our pipeline still ends on a supercomputer. I'm saying if you see a garbage fire in a film you don't need to write an article about "why fire hard". The answer is "they were unwilling to pay for a realistic fire". We're not talking billions of dollars here. Not everything is Avatar. But like I said, studios often expect miracles for little to no money. Fire isn't like skin/faces which is actually genuinely ridiculously hard to pull off. >Although I really do wonder if we have accurate enough physics models of the igniting gases to truly realistically show the way licks of flames ignite in a strong wind -- as opposed to a more bog-standard campfire type That would make an excellent article because you don't actually want a "realistic" fire. Don't forget we're doing entertainment, not science. Turbulence in media is just a noise function. I want a pretty vector field visual to indicate where and how my sim will move. Pyrotechnics is the same. We want control. Realism is undesirable. It's like asking for realistic silencers. John Wick is amazing because the silencers aren't realistic. The explosions and fires you see in film/tv aren't functionally realistic (though manipulated to appear so) and that's a good thing.