3 ms·
A general rule, when you find a "beautiful work", it usually is trying to sell you a story that seriously lacks in historical detail. There are exceptions, but
by cyberax 3y ago
A general rule, when you find a "beautiful work", it usually is trying to sell you a story that seriously lacks in historical detail. There are exceptions, but they are rare.
Regarding bison, it's likely that the final blow was not from overhunting, but from habitat encroachment that constrained their migratory patterns. This in turn started an epidemic of tick-borne disease, that resulted in a total collapse of their population within just 2 years (1881-1883).
There's a really nice overview article: https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0190052818300087 https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S019005281...
- Mistletoe 3y agoStoner is a fictional campus novel about a college professor…all beautiful works aren’t aiming for historical detail.
- zdragnar 3y agoFiction requires a suspension of disbelief- that a certain person is real, or that certain things have happened, etc. Good fiction asks its audience to accept things that don't require special knowledge. Bad (historical) fiction presents false things in such a way that the audience accepts them without realizing that is is part of the fictional narrative, because they lack the specialized knowledge to understand when artistic liberties have been taken. Since the audience is already in a state of suspended disbelief, they aren't prepared to be skeptical of what is presented as real but is not. I have a similar quibble with American Gods. Several times I've seen people parrot ideas from the story that sounded like one of many historical facts but were actually very wrong, such as the background of Easter. Edit: I may have been overly harsh with the use of the word "Bad". They're good stories in their own rights, but this particular bone has been stuck in my craw for a long time.
- AlbertCory 3y agoStoner is a great book. It's not "historical fiction".
- morelisp 3y ago"Overhunting" vs. "undermanagement" feels like a distinction without a difference outside a small circle of purely scientific inquiry.
- cyberax 3y agoNot really? They are almost entirely different. The situation with bison in the US was deeply unnatural when you think about it. Bison are large herbivores, that can reproduce fairly quickly, and that don't have any consistent predators. Nothing in the US can hunt them successfully and consistently. A wolf pack can take down a grown bison, but it's risky for them, and the wolf population was nowhere large enough to control the bison population numbers. Cougars and coyotes can prey on calves, but not on healthy grown bison.
- dev_tty01 3y agoUnnatural? Not sure I understand the use of the term here. They were here for several hundred thousand years so there were only natural forces at work. There must have been some kind of balance if they thrived for that long. At the very least food availability would have limited their numbers in some way. It isn't dissimilar to the situation with bears. Just guessing, but I would think there would have been a lot of cougars eating a lot of calves. That would also have some restraining impact on the population.
- cyberax 3y ago> They were here for several hundred thousand years so there were only natural forces at work. Only if you include Native Americans in the "natural" forces. They were responsible for the disappearance of the local megafauna. > At the very least food availability would have limited their numbers in some way. Or maybe periodic population collapses due to disease. > It isn't dissimilar to the situation with bears. Grizzly bears have one of the slowest reproduction rates, though. They simply won't have cubs if there isn't enough food. In Africa, it's a similar story with elephants, nothing can hunt them consistently, but they reproduce so slowly that they can't really overpopulate the area.