3 ms·
Here's something Microsoft and Google seem to not get in a big way: iPod. Put out a lower-cost non-phone device already! Call it whatever you want. The W7/8
by robomartin 15y ago
Here's something Microsoft and Google seem to not get in a big way: iPod.
Put out a lower-cost non-phone device already! Call it whatever you want. The W7/8 "Gamester" or whatever. Offer that choice and your market just multiplied tremendously. Follow the iPhone<->iPod model.
Case in point. Each of my kids has their own iPod. They'll don't have their own iPhones. What mother wants to hand a 3 year old their phone at a restaurant? We've done it for those unavoidable emergencies (you have to know three-year-olds). There's a huge market for non-phone devices like this and it just blows me away that these guys are battling hard over phones while ignoring the huge market that non-phone but 100% software-compatible devices represents.
As a developer I see that the iPhone + iPod ecosystem multiplies the number of devices that my apps go into by a significant and non-trivial number. Furthermore, it expands the demographics as well. These are all important factors when considering which platform to focus on. Add to that the code-compatible iPad and you have an absolute 1-2-3 punch winner.
Google and Microsoft (and everyone else trying to beat Apple at this game) seem to be blind to this for some strange reason.
Am I missing something fundamental?
- MatthewPhillips 15y agoHeard of the Zune?
- killedbydeath 15y agoThere is Galaxy Player: http://www.samsung.com/us/mobile/mp3-players/YP-G70CWY/XAA http://www.samsung.com/us/mobile/mp3-players/YP-G70CWY/XAA
- atpaino 15y agoGoogle actually does have an iPod competitor of sorts in the Samsung Galaxy Player (in both 4.0 and 5.0 inch screens). The adoption of these hasn't been great, however this might be due to the lack of advertising for them (especially when compared with Apple's rather large marketing campaigns for the iPod touch). I would like to see a non-phone device running WP7/8 though.
- roc 15y ago> "Am I missing something fundamental?" Price. Apple's supply chain, the one that's turning out tablets that no-one can match on price, has been doing the same thing to the PMP market with the iPod Touch. Android PMPs either have a price premium over a stock iPod Touch or they simply don't run well enough to meet consumer expectations. Microsoft is in largely the same place price-wise. Though their more-controlled product should be easier to optimize for cheaper/slower hardware and their services/brands have found a better reception in the market. (XBox, Live, Marketplace, Zune) I think Microsoft is just too focused on the phone market to give it a serious try. Though a Phone 7 PMP could also be a victim of Microsoft's strategy crisis: the bit where they seem to be so hell-bent on pushing Windows onto everything, that despite the critical reception, putting Phone 7 on anything that isn't a phone is still anathema.
- Lewisham 15y ago"I think Microsoft is just too focused on the phone market to give it a serious try." My read of WP7 has been that the OS is super-chatty by design, live tiles and such. It seems a huge part of it will be knee-capped by not having an always-on connection.
- SlipperySlope 15y agoGreat idea! For those not willing to wait, its rather easy to buy a used Android phone on craigslist and simply not sign up with a carrier. I'm a developer who needs various Android phones for testing. I use them WiFi and everything works - including Google Play and Amazon Marketplace - but no data plan and no phone calls. For example, I bought a used HTC Evo 4G for Sprint for only $150. It had the micro SD card removed so I bought one of those and put it in. Still way less than what the phone cost would have cost at non-subsidized retail.
- jordhy 15y agoYou're also missing something called economies of scope. Consider the following: 1. Apple can make a lot of money of an iPod Touch since they have many content partnerships in place and the cost of production of these devices is nominal (Apple has dedicated factories, has been producing the same models for years and, thru the Apple Store, enjoys low marketing and distribution costs). 2. Google's and Microsoft's breath of content partnerships is not as broad as Apple, therefore they wouldn't make as much money per device sold. 3. Apple's iPhone and iPod Touch share many components, production and distribution facilities; lowering the total cost of unit production and distribution for Apple. 4. Apple's customers are very accustomed to a single particular line of design. This makes it easy for Apple to push a model and it also makes it easy for developers to produce apps for the platform. In this case Android's fragmentation would get rapidly compounded and make developers lives harder. 5. Microsoft and Google have partnerships with phone manufacturers whose designs differ significantly. Therefore the traction of a particular design can't be directly translated into a media player (because only a thin slice of the market is familiar with the product). 6. Microsoft already failed with the Zune, so there are some cultural issues there as well. 7. Google makes money on search which is not a fundamental (albeit important) use case of a media player. So the monetization numbers for Google are going to look really bad if they were to sell media players. 6. This is a very tough market to penetrate since the iPod has so many partnerships in place already (covers, speakers, adapters, even iPod ready cars). All and all, Google and Microsoft have a chance to boost their app stores by competing on different platforms: the TV and game consoles. Then, as they accrue content partnerships and seduce more and more developers the numbers could change in the media player scenario.
- drumdance 15y agoMy guess is that's what Microsoft tried to do with Zune.
- Steko 15y ago"Am I missing something fundamental?" Price and scale covered already. Also important: Demand: Yes parents give their kids ipod touches not iphones. But that's still a fraction of the phone market. Moreover younger and younger kids get actual phones every year so that is going away to some extent. Ecosystem: As a game based machine, your AAA gaming app library is even more of an issue. Basically every gaming website is going to tell every kid that an iPod Touch has 10 times as many games. The kids that wake up xmas morning with an W8 Gamester are going to feel like the kids who got Go-Bots instead of Transformers. Younger people feel free to substitute Digimon and Pokemon. Distribution: The carriers solve this problem for phones (even 70% of iphones are sold by carriers) but they aren't interested in selling devices that don't come with a cell radio. This is the same problem Android tablets have unless they have their own major distribution channel (which is why only Amazon and to a lesser extent B&N have been the most successful in this space).
- runjake 15y agoHow to obtain a Windows Phone iPod: 1. Buy a used Samsung Focus for $99. 2. Don't put a SIM in it. 3. Turn the cell radio off. 4. Voila! It's fast and cheaper than anything they'd sell you in a store. In all seriousness, they sorta tried this with the Zune and they're probably gun shy, especially considering WP7 isn't doing all that well, despite it being great. I think MS should dump loads of cash ensuring the most popular iOS/Android apps have feature-parity versions on WP7. They are not doing this right now.
- robomartin 15y agoAnswers to a range of comments on my post: Price: Once you start manufacturing products by the hundreds of thousands, costs go down very quickly. Any of of these large companies can easily commit to making a million of just about anything. If the BOM cost is in the order of $100 to $200 that means only $200 million to make a million units. This is chump change for both Google and Microsoft. I don't think that Apple would a significant cost advantage if competitors play at the right level. Cost is asymptotic. Buy a Samsung <model number> and don't activate: Consumers don't operate that way. They need to be marketed a solution and they need to go to Walmart or Amazon and buy that solution. Ecosystem: Valid points. Content partnerships: If you build it, they will come. Content providers want more ways to monetize their content. MS/Google designs that differ: Yes! Huge problem. Apple got it right. They design and build. Period. The Android landscape is horrific. I have zero interest in developing for Android. Fifty different devices running half a dozen (or whatever) versions of the OS? Nah, life is too short. If MS is smart they will control this very tightly and provide uniformity and consistency. Zune: Crap. Not the same concept. What I am talking about is Phone/Pod/Pad/Tablet/Desktop sharing UI elements and apps.
- Tichy 15y agoMy personal expectation would be for iPods to fade away. Who needs an iPod if you can have an iPhone? Except for kids, of course. But 3 year olds are not the big drivers behind app store sales (just a guess). Also I think you can get Android phones that are cheaper or not much more expensive than iPods already.
- corporalagumbo 15y agoFor what it's worth, I owned a Touch for the last 4 years, and when I finally decided to buy a smartphone, I chose the Lumia 800 in part because I was totally bored by iOS. Granted, I'm not your average consumer, but product familiarity isn't always a good thing. After spending so much time with the Touch, there's no way an iPhone could have wowed me. My Lumia, though not perfect in many ways, is still really fresh and fun, standing in stark contrast to iOS, which to me now feels tired.