3 ms·
>It's a hobbyist set of bands, and encrypting traffic is against the hobbyist spirit of it. No, it is not. Hobbyist web masters practically all use encryption.
by charcircuit 3y ago
>It's a hobbyist set of bands, and encrypting traffic is against the hobbyist spirit of it.
No, it is not. Hobbyist web masters practically all use encryption. It should be possible to use modern protocols like HTTPS. Encryption is the default of modern network protocols. On the internet trasitioning from a hobby website to a commercial one is seamless.
>Part of the beauty of ham is being able to go along the dial and be able to observe the traffic.
MitM attacks are a security vulnerability. If people want to observe traffic they should observe their own traffic. His is like saying that we shouldn't use Rust because students will be unable to exploit vulnerabilities.
>Your insulting of people who try to maintain radios for emergencies is unnecessary, too.
Unneccessary, but their use case is rather niche compared to what we see the internet used for. It is a sign of stagnation.
- unethical_ban 3y agoYou conflate unicast web traffic with city-wide and world-wide broadcast. It's a different medium.
- nullc 3y agoPedantically, use of amateur radio as a broadcast medium is prohibited in FCC land except for special exceptions like beacon stations. This, like the wholesale prohibition on music is also antiquated in my view -- already commercial broadcast radio is dying because of streaming. The public interest would be maximized by allowing a degree of non-commercial broadcast and music usage over amateur bands, subject to restrictions. For example, it would be pretty rad to have an event with an orchestra linked between two nearby cities with full duplex ultra low latency radio--- which can achieve much lower latency than ordinary internet due to the line-of-sight nature. Now I realize that by 'broadcast' you don't mean the rule-violating one-way-communications kind but the literal propagation characteristics. But at UHF+ it's easier to have a directional signal than an omnidirectional one, and once you get to a few GHz it's quite natural to have laser beam like signals. Plus, at 2m+ signals are naturally limited to the radio horizon (except for exceptional cases). Personally, when I've advocated for relaxations on encryption and other content restrictions I've done so for UHF+ (or even SHF+) bands where the degree of under-utilization and potential for spectrum reuse through directionality are very high, and abuse is inherently geographically limited by physics.
- GuB-42 3y ago> On the internet trasitioning from a hobby website to a commercial one is seamless. And that's exactly the kind of transition people into ham radio don't want. > MitM attacks are a security vulnerability. A vulnerability on what security? Everything done on the ham bands is public, it makes no sense to transmit on these bands and not want to be heard. It makes sense if you are trying to send a secret message, which is what ham is explicitly not about. As for the comparison with Rust. The Rust memory model is about preventing bugs. But the lack of private communication on public ham bands is a feature, not a bug. The Rust of ham radio would be a system that prevents accidental encryption and ensures that everything is understandable by everyone. If you want the internet, use the internet. There are already many frequency bands for that.
- charcircuit 3y ago>And that's exactly the kind of transition people into ham radio don't want. Which is a problem. It would be cool to experiment in these bands and then later switch to others when you want to commercialize. >A vulnerability on what security? If you wanted to send a private message to someone the expectation is that the message should be private and not publically snoopable. >Everything done on the ham bands is public Everything on the internet is public too in the sense that people who can listen in between have access to what is sent. >If you want the internet, use the internet. This is accepting defeat to the internet. I say that we should see more competition.
- GuB-42 3y ago> This is accepting defeat to the internet. I say that we should see more competition. I think here is the misunderstanding. There is no competition. Ham operators happily use the internet to communicate when appropriate and at the same time use the ham bands for playing with their radio equipment. I don't think many of them want to use their radios to do what they do with their smartphones and vice versa. It is like saying that gliders and airliners are in competition. Even if both are about aerodynamics, no glider pilot is mad because using a glider is inconvenient for travelling overseas, no one thinks gliders have "lost" to airliners because of the insistance on not using engines (motorgliders exist but they are still inadequate for practical travel). Glider pilots take the plane like everyone else when going on vacation. It doesn't mean gliders are useless, a few of them have practical applications, and they make excellent training for "useful" plane pilots, in fact most of the best airline pilots have flown gliders, and some still do. Same idea with ham radio. Mostly but not completely impractical, and many of the people who now work with "useful" radios like the one that's in your phone giving you internet access started as amateurs.
- Sporktacular 3y agoThe Internet has the bandwidth to accomodate private channels. You don't know what you're talking about. There are no security vulnerabilities where there are no secrets. That's the point of ham. Go look at a spectrum chart. If you're worried about stagnation, go after the stupidly under-utilised swathes of military allocations. Let the hobbyists keep their narrow kHz. Not everything needs disruption.
- charcircuit 3y ago>There are no security vulnerabilities where there are no secrets. Have you considered that there may not be any secrets because it doesn't allow for privacy? The law is holding it back from its true potential.
- Sporktacular 3y agoI have. You're talking about the demands of non-hams now. These bands aren't for them.
- TheSpiceIsLife 3y agoYou seem to be implying HAM should be something different than it is, to the point the two become largely undifferentiated.
- wl 3y agoObscuring a message, by itself, does nothing to prevent MitM attacks. If you're worried about message integrity on the amateur bands, the rules do nothing to prevent the use of digital signatures.