2 ms·
> This will make the problem worse as the Portuguese will complain that the foreigners own the beautiful modern buildings. I don't agree. We already have expen
by jmyeet 3y ago
> This will make the problem worse as the Portuguese will complain that the foreigners own the beautiful modern buildings.
I don't agree. We already have expensive housing in every country that those who aren't wealthy might covet. Also, new construction can be done in a way where you set aside, say, 20% of the units for locals in the same way that cities like NYC try to (but, you know, better).
> Additionally it‘s important to keep in mind that this is not feasible for EU countries with the four freedoms.
That's not strictly true [1] eg Malta.
Where it isn't possible, restricting non-EU citizens would still have a positive impact.
Also, where you can't actually restrict people, you can effectively do it with taxation, like having high property taxes for non-residents. This would be perfectly legal. US states do this too (eg a non-Indiana resident pays higher property taxes than an Indiana resident).
You can also discourage rampant property speculation with high transfer taxes, again targeted at foreign buyers.
> It would be like Florida banning ownership of existing houses for Californians.
I'm a big fan of doing this in Hawaii.
> ... would totally kill the Portuguese tourism industry
Build hotels. Build dedicated short-stay accomodation. Allow hoome owners to have ADUs. Build infrastructure for tourism. Don't use theoretical hits on tourism to make locals homeless.
[1]: https://realting.com/news/where-it-is-banned-or-hard-for-foreigners-to-buy-real-estate https://realting.com/news/where-it-is-banned-or-hard-for-for...
- quonn 3y agoIt‘s not necessarily legal and the EU has already indicated for Spain that discriminatory taxes for non residents would not be permissible.
- quonn 3y agoAlso Airbnb is already banned in Lisbon, there are no new AL licenses given as far as I know. Or at least there was a plan for that.
- JetSpiegel 3y agoSure, no new licenses, but the entire AirBnB neighborhoods in the tourist areas are still there, sucking up valuable housing stock. There haven't been any reduction in the amount of AirBnB, just no new licenses are issued.