5 ms·
I was expecting restrictions like encryption to be removed so you could use modern network protocols. Amateur radio will continue losing to the internet where
by charcircuit 3y ago
I was expecting restrictions like encryption to be removed so you could use modern network protocols.
Amateur radio will continue losing to the internet where actual growth and innovation is happening instead of old guys larping how they are going to save the world by knowing morse code or something.
- genmud 3y agoI thought the encryption restriction was only for analog radio, not digital?
- unethical_ban 3y agoNo. You can encode data digitally, per a specification, but you can't encode it.
- genmud 3y agoSo, why wouldn’t you be able to encrypt the data you send before digital encoding?
- BenjiWiebe 3y agoBecause it is against the rules.
- unethical_ban 3y agoI meant you can't encrypt it. And the other person is correct. It's simply against the rules and the spirit of ham radio.
- unethical_ban 3y agoIt's a hobbyist set of bands, and encrypting traffic is against the hobbyist spirit of it. Part of the beauty of ham is being able to go along the dial and be able to observe the traffic. That would die with widespread encryption. Your insulting of people who try to maintain radios for emergencies is unnecessary, too.
- charcircuit 3y ago>It's a hobbyist set of bands, and encrypting traffic is against the hobbyist spirit of it. No, it is not. Hobbyist web masters practically all use encryption. It should be possible to use modern protocols like HTTPS. Encryption is the default of modern network protocols. On the internet trasitioning from a hobby website to a commercial one is seamless. >Part of the beauty of ham is being able to go along the dial and be able to observe the traffic. MitM attacks are a security vulnerability. If people want to observe traffic they should observe their own traffic. His is like saying that we shouldn't use Rust because students will be unable to exploit vulnerabilities. >Your insulting of people who try to maintain radios for emergencies is unnecessary, too. Unneccessary, but their use case is rather niche compared to what we see the internet used for. It is a sign of stagnation.
- unethical_ban 3y agoYou conflate unicast web traffic with city-wide and world-wide broadcast. It's a different medium.
- nullc 3y agoPedantically, use of amateur radio as a broadcast medium is prohibited in FCC land except for special exceptions like beacon stations. This, like the wholesale prohibition on music is also antiquated in my view -- already commercial broadcast radio is dying because of streaming. The public interest would be maximized by allowing a degree of non-commercial broadcast and music usage over amateur bands, subject to restrictions. For example, it would be pretty rad to have an event with an orchestra linked between two nearby cities with full duplex ultra low latency radio--- which can achieve much lower latency than ordinary internet due to the line-of-sight nature. Now I realize that by 'broadcast' you don't mean the rule-violating one-way-communications kind but the literal propagation characteristics. But at UHF+ it's easier to have a directional signal than an omnidirectional one, and once you get to a few GHz it's quite natural to have laser beam like signals. Plus, at 2m+ signals are naturally limited to the radio horizon (except for exceptional cases). Personally, when I've advocated for relaxations on encryption and other content restrictions I've done so for UHF+ (or even SHF+) bands where the degree of under-utilization and potential for spectrum reuse through directionality are very high, and abuse is inherently geographically limited by physics.
- nullc 3y agoAgreed-- at least relaxing the restriction for UHF/SHF signals on a "secondary usage" basis (traffic must yield to plaintext). Potentially with with reduced power (say 100w) or minimum directionality, but I think a 'secondary usage' would be sufficient. Without doing so virtually all non-HF experimentation will continue to be deflected onto the ISM bands and we will lose our allocations through disuse. So long as identification is still decodable, spectrum usage can be managed. It's sufficient to prohibit commercial usage you don't need plaintext to do so. The old threat of tow trucks and cab services moving onto ham-bands had long since been mooted by ubiquitous cellular, but even if it weren't any significant commercial usage will eventually have a whistleblower. Usage that is obscure enough to not be vulnerable to whistleblowers could also be hidden just as well in "plaintext" traffic that was really uncrackable steganography. As it stands you can't even lawfully log into your own personal systems over amateur radio even if you take the unreasonable steps of using specially modified software to authenticate-but-not-encrypt because inevitably some third party will send a message to you via the internet that contains some naughty words that aren't permitted over the radio. Without relaxing the encryption rules, innovative radio usage like meshtastic (https://meshtastic.org/ https://meshtastic.org/) will continue to be pushed onto ISM bands where (1) they're still technically unlawful because the homebrew hardware is not type-accepted (amateur bands are the ONLY place where homebrew intentional radiators are allowed!) and (2) where the band choices, power limit, and EIRP limits are detrimental to full exploration of the possibilities. Besides, the FCC has long allowed proprietary, license fee bearing, patent encumbered digital modes. These are very close to encryption in terms of their ability to lock others out of ham comms, and have frequently been used by amateur radio groups to establish "lid free" communications channels. (Because most of the more irritating people aren't technically sophisticated enough to adopt some new mode without help, and people won't help them...). The rules as they stand punish honest people who follow the intent and spirit of the rule in favor of people willing to just ignore the rules (including operating unlawful devices in ISM bands), willing to use stego, or willing to use obscure protocols to achieve the same ends that they'd otherwise achieve with encryption. It blocks modern networking by disallowing standard internet-grade software use with radio since all of it has integral encryption which generally can't be disabled to prevent downgrading and cross domain attacks in contexts where the encryption is needed -- or because in some cases the protocols are designed in such a way that authentication without encypherment isn't possible. 73s, NT4TN