3 ms·
We're discouraged by moderation here from arguing about why things are flagged. If you think something is flagged erroneously, the thing to do is to mail hn@yco
by tptacek 3y ago
We're discouraged by moderation here from arguing about why things are flagged. If you think something is flagged erroneously, the thing to do is to mail hn@ycombinator.com and tell them; they'll look at who's flagging and what the story is, and sometimes remove the flag weights.
There's a way to write the same comment without begging for this kind of meta-argument: just write a paragraph that doesn't talk about ranking and flagging but says what you found unexpectedly interesting or thoughtful about the article.
- user_7832 3y agoThanks for your comment. > We're discouraged by moderation here from arguing about why things are flagged. Thanks for informing me, I wasn’t aware of that. I did know the part about emailing. Though, I wonder how this impacts in a fast-moving forum like HN where if a post fails to meet a critical threshold, it gets dropped. (I am aware of the second chance queue but I don’t know if they too have similar weights of “needing upvotes steadily to survive”. I think the posted article was important for HN readers to see and hence asked in my first comment.)
- tptacek 3y agoI don't think stories like this have much of a chance on the front page regardless. There's more than one force pushing them down: they're political, which attracts flags, they're not technical, which (usually unreasonably) attracts flags, and they're volatile, which sets off the flame-war detector. The big thing though is you can't stage a debate about flags on the thread itself; whatever you think of those flags, debating them publicly works against your goal.