4 ms·
>including the obligatory claim that disagreeing with one's personally preferred form of urban planning is a "far-right conspiracy theory" You're talking about
by krapp 3y ago
>including the obligatory claim that disagreeing with one's personally preferred form of urban planning is a "far-right conspiracy theory"
You're talking about the "15 minute city" conspiracy theory[0,1], which posits that the design of cities such that amenities are available within a 15 minute walk from citizens (in other words, built for pedestrians rather than cars) is, in reality, an authoritarian plot to restrict freedom of movement and control people en masse, often linked with COVID conspiracy theories which implied pandemic measures were simply a pretext by a cabal of global elites to stage a world takeover.
How is that not a "far-right conspiracy theory?" It's literally every other "new world order" conspiracy theory promulgated by the far right, just applied to whatever new thing Twitter and Reddit decide is a globalist plot this week.
[0]https://apnews.com/article/fact-check-15-minute-city-conspiracy-162fd388f0c435a8289cc9ea213f92ee https://apnews.com/article/fact-check-15-minute-city-conspir...
[1]https://www.wired.com/story/15-minute-city-conspiracy-uk-politics/ https://www.wired.com/story/15-minute-city-conspiracy-uk-pol...
- ajvs 3y agoBecause you're missing the context of what's actually happening in the UK such as ULEZ making travel more expensive (thus monetarily restricting your movement) and councils implementing 15-minute city-aligned schemes which also limit movement.
- seagullriffic 3y ago> missing the context of what's actually happening in the UK such as ULEZ making travel more expensive I'm more than 95% sure that you, a Hacker News commenter, do not have a non-compliant vehicle in the UK which you "need" to visit London, which has the best public transport in Europe. So why spread this FUD except to make it harder to enact these policies to clean the air? Why, just why, are people against clean air? "Yes, but not like that!" > councils implementing 15-minute city-aligned schemes which also limit movement. Just where does this come from. If you want to visit or live in a city, then you appreciate density. Private cars are anathema to density. The logic is not hard.
- Zpalmtree 3y agoyes, the only possible reason to want the government not to limit your travel is because you hate the environment
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- jodrellblank 3y agoWhat about when trains and busses were privatised, made more expensive (thus monetarily restricting your movement)? What about when tax on petrol and diesel was increased making travel more expensive (thus monetarily restricting your movement)[1]? What about speed limits and one-way streets and no-entry signs existing and restricting your movement? What about increases in cost of parking over the years (same again) or for employees of hospitals (restricting freedom of employment)? "ULEZ making travel more expensive" - isn't that what people who claim to love freedom so often want, free markets which adjust things based on monetary incentives? [1] https://www.rac.co.uk/drive/news/fuel-news/chancellor-facing-backlash-after-substantial-rise-in-fuel-duty-set-for-2023/ https://www.rac.co.uk/drive/news/fuel-news/chancellor-facing...
- Amezarak 3y agoI don't think the discussion is about the truth or untruth of the motivations behind "15 minute cities", but the fact the author of the article clearly believes that disagreement with the policy is disinformation and should be made illegal. The author is not writing in good faith in the first place by taking the weakest and most conspiratorial arguments and holding them up as "the" opposition, and they think it is a shame this Online Safety Act did not make disagreeing with them illegal. I caveat this with the statement that, were I dictator, all cities would be 15 minute cities, and I would bulldoze all subdivisions and American-style suburbs, which I regard as ridiculous encroachments on my preferred rural home.
- didntcheck 3y agoExactly. If one wants to make the point that people are mixing up 15MC with ULEZ and other traffic-restricting measures, sure, any pertinent point of fact is welcome. But instead there's been a fairly transparent attempt to take advantage of a contemporary political moral panic, and go with the lazy option of insinuating that anyone with fairly pedestrian (heh) objections to current council and government policy is a dangerous QAnon alt-right anti-vaccine... whatever other completely unrelated folk devils you want to throw in. Politicians have realized that they can drag the most random topics into the "culture war", declare that disagreeing with them is a "conspiracy theory", and enjoy free repetition of that thought-terminating cliché by allegedly "anti-establishment" journalists desperate to find a new frontier to declare their moral superiority in And for the record, I tend to agree with the majority of the proposals anyway, but I can still object to the extremely bad faith response to locals exercizing their democratic right to question them. And confused at the number of people who will openly say "fuck cars" and explicitly advocate for making driving more difficult (as a primary goal), then claim it's a conspiracy to say they ever supported that
- strogonoff 3y agoI know smart, very adequate people who point out that efficient public transport, planning for walkability and (consequently) restricting private vehicles are policies that benefit authoritarianism. Those people don’t necessarily believe in COVID vaccine chips and whatnot; their logic, pretty straightforwardly, is that it makes you depend on the government for movement. Even though I am a staunch opponent of sprawling suburbia and I love a dense walkable city with functioning transport, I have to admit that they have a point. It’s true that I can’t recall any relevant examples that align with their opinion. Plenty well-planned walkable cities with in democratic regions, and plenty sprawl and chaotic traffic jam hells in dictatorships. Yet I can think of a few recent examples where control over public transportation was used to suppress protests. To dismiss their argument out of hand and refuse to empathise is to unnecessarily expand an already deep gap.
- jodrellblank 3y ago> "is that it makes you depend on the government for movement [...] I have to admit that they have a point." You already depend on the government for building and maintaining the roads and the traffic lights and all accoutrements, the government can already close roads and restrict you. Public transport doesn't need to be government provided, it can be privatised (although this works badly in the UK). You also depend on the government in various ways for food and water and electricity - from land use and transport to crime prevention to upholding trade and food safety requirements and the value of currency; everyone in a city does, at least. Picking the car as the important thing for "freedom" is a ... weird one. And doesn't address the idea of "freedom from having to have a car". > "Yet I can think of a few recent examples where control over public transportation was used to suppress protests." "The PMLN-led federal and Punjab governments have closed several roads leading to Islamabad from various Punjab cities and Khyber Pakhtunkhwa (KP) province in an effort to stop PTI activists from marching on Islamabad."[3] - there's control over the roads used to suppress something or other (I don't know what PTI activists are, but I'm assuming this isn't in the middle of a war because that probably wouldn't be using shipping containers and talking of 'activists'). What about the COVID lockdowns preventing people from going outside at all? Having a car didn't give you freedom then, and public transport wasn't involved. What about The UK[2] making it legal for the police to shut down protests because the protestors might walk slowly down roads - no control over public transport needed to stop the protest (and on the flip side, car drivers depending on the government to keep cars moving). In Paris: "Every first Sunday of the month is the new car-free day in Paris. It's an initiative appreciated by many Parisians, who have fallen under the spell of a capital free of motorized vehicles and noise pollution. The capital's first four arrondissements are closed to car traffic on one Sunday a month."[1] - more showing that governments can shut roads and therefore car drivers are dependent on the government for freedom of movement, as well as public transport users are. [1] https://www.sortiraparis.com/en/news/in-paris/articles/175623-paris-centre-pieton-the-first-4-car-free-arrondissements-on-sunday-november-5-2023 https://www.sortiraparis.com/en/news/in-paris/articles/17562... - [2] https://www.theguardian.com/world/2023/jan/15/police-to-get-new-powers-to-shut-down-protests-before-disruption-begins https://www.theguardian.com/world/2023/jan/15/police-to-get-... [3] https://dailytimes.com.pk/940632/govt-closes-all-roads-leading-to-islamabad/ https://dailytimes.com.pk/940632/govt-closes-all-roads-leadi...
- manonthewall 3y agoI have certainly had conversations with redditors who prefer this kind of government control planning down to the meter. I am 100% behind zoning laws that -allow- just about any kind of building in "neighborhoods" rather than "residential only" or "business only" to have these 15 minutes cities by organic growth, leading by the carrot rather than by the stick.