4 ms·
I used to think this was just restricted to pre-college math, and to East-Asian parents. After I had erstwhile-parent types infantilize me over my adult hobbies
by lambdasquirrel 3y ago
I used to think this was just restricted to pre-college math, and to East-Asian parents. After I had erstwhile-parent types infantilize me over my adult hobbies, I realized, you need a creative person in order to facilitate creative discovery. But it takes guts to try to learn something the "right" way. Imagine going through a whole semester, never once learning what was going to be on the AP test. And it takes some stature to teach it too. Imagine doing a writing class, where there absolutely must not be any rules or criteria for grading, where you really must say, I'll know it when I see it, but there really are going to be some yeses and nos.
What do you want to produce? People who can come up with new solutions to new problems on their own, or people who do cookie-cutter rules? How do you keep doing that throughout your life, long after school? People say they want the former until they come up against the reality of uncertainty, the possibility that there might not actually be any answers, and then they go right back to memorizing and teaching rules. They go back to justifying things the way they are.
- wizzwizz4 3y ago> Imagine going through a whole semester, never once learning what was going to be on the AP test. This is how I learn mathematics – mostly because I'm empirically incapable of doing otherwise. I will achieve a lower grade than I “could”, and miss out on many opportunities as a result.
- anonymouskimmer 3y agoThere are a few colleges/universities that use non-grade evaluations. Evergreen State uses a narrative evaluation: https://www.evergreen.edu/registration/transcript-format https://www.evergreen.edu/registration/transcript-format Really smart people, and sometimes even just moderately smart people, coast along as A, B, or C students while learning what they want and just doing the minimum of the requirements to coast along. And then a bunch of other people have academic-like side-interests that they pursue in their free time.