3 ms·
Between killing Rabin and the settlements this isn't going to stop for decades to come unless something changes, and for that to work both sides will need to wa
by jacquesm 3y ago
Between killing Rabin and the settlements this isn't going to stop for decades to come unless something changes, and for that to work both sides will need to want to solve it. I don't see that happening, and you seem to think that only Gaza citizens have the power to stop the conflict. But for that to work they'd have to have something to work with and that just isn't happening. De-occupation is clearly not sufficient to allow a nation state to be established, it needs a lot more security than that. That 6 to 8% of the entire adult male population makes it to Hamas (a figure which I can't verify but it sounds entirely believable) is a reflection of how little people in Gaza have to live for.
- edanm 3y agoI think it's true, to some extent, that only Gazans have the power to stop the conflict. (I say Gazans and not Gaza citizen, because I think it's Hamas that has the power, not the actual citizens, which is part of the reason we're in this mess.) Israel does a lot of bad things, like the settlements in the West Bank. No question about that. But if Israel were to stop with those tomorrow, I honestly don't think it will make a difference. See e.g. what Israel did with Gaza - it forcibly removed its own citizens, left Gaza entirely, and what we got in return was Hamas. On the other hand, if the Palestinians agreed to a peace treaty whereby they get some land and give up their right to destroy all of Israel, the war would be over. Period. This was offered to the Palestinians several times, and they refused several times. I'm not saying Israel is faultless, far from it. But at the end of the day, Israel is in a situation where the other side wants something that Israel can't agree to - they want Israel gone. That's the heart of this conflict and something you just can't negotiate around.
- jacquesm 3y agoAgreed, but: Israel is losing support all over the world because of the settlements and that in turn can be used by the Palestinians (and actually the rest of the Arab world) to claim they are justified in doing whatever they do. You can't effectively point at others while you are doing stuff yourself.
- edanm 3y agoYes. This is one of the reasons I usually vote for the most far-left party in Israel, and one of the reasons (though admittedly not the main reason) that large amounts of Israelis have been protesting our government for the last year.