3 ms·
Will the world be a better place if Google is banned from paying for default-privilege? Most users will probably switch to Google anyway, at least in the short
by pradn 3y ago
Will the world be a better place if Google is banned from paying for default-privilege?
Most users will probably switch to Google anyway, at least in the short term. Google will probably lose some market share. This means less revenue. However, the "cost of revenue" is lower as well. So it may just be a wash. When tobacco companies were banned from advertising, their big expense of advertising went down as well - and so profit rose. Google's long-term outlook looks murkier. It really is possible for new entrants to come in and steal market-share if they didn't have to pay for default-privilege. Platforms could encourage specialized search engines as well - pick one for shopping, another for maps, another for reviews - maybe we'll get a Cambrian explosion?
But the fact that no ad-support search engine has been able to beat Google all these years, even Microsoft-supported Bing - means that internet search is fundamentally a hard problem to solve. It's also relatively capital intensive - all the hardware to crawl and index the web, human SERP raters and content moderators.
As the internet becomes more and more hyper-commercialized, the value of a general purpose search-engine may decline. Why search when there's mostly garbage out there. Try going to any news website.
- soup10 3y agoNo, most people will use whatever the default is. The vast majority of search is for a few popular queries: facebook.com, wikipedia article, current event, celebrity, product etc. This isn't the 90s anymore where search engines were terrible and google was a big step up. Even among power users, the difference is not that clear.
- hughw 3y agoIs that true for Bing? Do most Windows users the default Edge and leave default search on Bing?
- bobthepanda 3y agoGoogle spends a lot of money on ads to get you off edge, and users are pretty much conditioned to ignore MS defaults. Before Chrome existed it was pretty common for people to suggest downloading FF out of hand. So the habit has existed for years, on top of the ad campaigns that Google runs for chrome.