4 ms·
Serious question: what is the actual story or solution here? Are food manufacturers breaking California law or not? And given that it's the cacao beans themse
by crazygringo 3y ago
Serious question: what is the actual story or solution here?
Are food manufacturers breaking California law or not?
And given that it's the cacao beans themselves with lead and cadmium (not factory contamination or something), is the solution to test every batch from each farm individually, and then just throw half the beans into the garbage? Or shut down half the cacao farms worldwide because of tainted soil?
Or is this pretty much in line with food safety levels generally, there's nothing to be worried about, and California guidelines are overly strict?
I just find it unfortunate that the article presents all the facts but basically zero analysis or context.
- adrian_b 3y agoThis problem is not specific to cocoa. The seeds of many plants concentrate lead and cadmium whenever they are found in their environment, so with most seeds and nuts there is always a risk of high lead or cadmium content. In most countries there are legal limits for the lead and cadmium content of seeds and nuts, but the limits are much more lenient than for other products, because there are few sources of seeds and nuts that are not affected, so setting low limits would eliminate most products from the market. So the only recommendation is like for fish, which should not constitute a too large part of the food due to the risk of high mercury content, also most seeds and nuts should not be a too large part of the food, due to the risk of high lead and cadmium content. The pollution caused by human stupidity has converted some of the healthiest foods into health risks.
- aksss 3y agoIn second to last paragraph, you mean that for these reasons of contamination, fish and chocolate should not constitute too large a part of one’s diet, correct? Just trying to clarify.
- adrian_b 3y agoYes. Consuming them from time to time should not be a problem, but eating a chocolate (or fish) every day presents the risk of excessive intake of contaminants. Unfortunately, most of us cannot afford to make a chemical analysis of every food we buy, to determine whether it is safe or not for consumption, so it is better to be cautious. Even the legal limits for the lead and cadmium content of cocoa and of most seeds and nuts are rather high also based on the reasoning that on average they should be only a minor part of the daily intake.
- goda90 3y agoSeeds like grains that make up most of people's diets and the diets of most livestock? That doesn't sound great.
- adrian_b 3y agoActually products like white flour or white rice have significantly less contaminants than whole grains. I do not agree with the propaganda about whole grains being healthy. Whole grains have more contaminants and more anti-nutrients, e.g. phytic acid. Whole grains would be healthier in comparison with white flour or white rice only for someone who would eat nothing else, and even then they would not be healthy enough. A healthy diet should include processed grains like white flour or white rice as a source of cheap proteins and of energy and it should also include some sources of healthy fat and many other sources for the nutrients that are necessary only in small quantities, like vitamins, minerals or proteins rich in lysine (which is insufficient in cereals). Whole-grain products have inflated prices, while a combination of e.g. white flour with various vegetables is simultaneously cheaper and healthier. Relying on whole grains to provide what is missing in white flour or white rice is completely inefficient and it also adds the risk of an excessive intake of contaminants.
- crawfordcomeaux 3y agoHow did you come to the idea that processed foods are part of a healthy diet
- bobthepanda 3y agonot all processed foods are healthy, but also not all raw foods are healthy either. most of the issues with processed foods are with the ultra-processed foods, those foods that are manufactured into a food product with minimal or no cooking required. and there's the stuff like iodine or niacin fortification and pasteurization, which we know has had systemic positive effects on nutrition. there's also where exactly you draw the line for processing. fermentation is like the oldest food preservation method we have (kimchi, cheese): is that processing? the raw diet people even believe cooking of any time is processing.
- mensetmanusman 3y agoFish also have selenium which counters the mercury effect. https://edis.ifas.ufl.edu/publication/FS437 https://edis.ifas.ufl.edu/publication/FS437 Eat a lot of fish like the Japanese, you might even become less violent for some reason :)
- Slava_Propanei 3y ago[dead]
- chris_va 3y ago(disclaimer: I make bean-to-bar chocolate) As background, food often concentrates whatever is in the soil, and cacao perhaps more so. The shell around the cacao bean is a big filter, and tends to accumulate stuff. This concentration isn't specific to cacao, e.g. see rice and arsenic, etc etc. Volcanic soil naturally has a lot of cadmium, for example, so you end up with it in the final product for cacao from some regions. The growing areas more popular with large manufacturers (i.e. cheaper cacao) just so happens to be areas with high cadmium levels, so there is a a bit of a correlation between cadmium levels and the size of the operation. I've been told that pretty much all larger chocolate organizations do test each batch for cadmium, lead, etc. The smaller ones are usually sourcing cacao from higher quality distributors, and those distributors also test everything (and also do transparency reports on labor, handling, and such). Fundamentally, the guidance on what is an acceptable level is not clear, though I cannot speak for the decision making at the companies listed in the article. CA's particular threshold considered low, and you can get equal amounts of Cd/Pb from a lot of other food sources (generally people don't eat multiple chocolate bars per day, but they might have a cup of rice and get a similar amount of cadmium). Maybe that's also a problem. Lead though, really should not be in there. It's not from the soil, and it's mostly in the shell, which should be removed in processing.
- crazygringo 3y agoThank you -- that's very helpful context!
- tomcam 3y agoGreat post. I’m dying to know what company you have/work for? Theo by any chance? AFAIK bean to bar is highly unusual, done by only a dozen or so companies. You appear to be living the dream!
- chris_va 3y agohttps://spinnakerchocolate.com/ https://spinnakerchocolate.com/
- 3y ago
- klipt 3y agoYou should see how much lead is in the average carrot. Last I checked, baby carrots can have similar lead/lb as the chocolates they're talking about here. And people chow down on carrots thinking they're "healthy".
- soperj 3y agoCan you provide some back up on that? I can't seem to find anything.
- klipt 3y agoSee table 7 in https://www.nature.com/articles/s41598-021-91554-z https://www.nature.com/articles/s41598-021-91554-z Carrot is just one example. 0.027 mg lead / kg carrot. Or 0.027 micrograms lead / g carrot. According to the asyousow.org report linked above more than 0.5 micrograms lead per day is bad, which is just 20g (0.7oz) of fresh carrot. Celery and beetroot are not far off either, around half the lead of carrot by weight.
- soperj 3y agoI don't know that a study conducted in Poland with polish goods actually gives you the lead & cadmium levels in an average carrot. Thank you for providing the study though!
- klipt 3y agoIt's hard to find data for commercial vegetables in the US. I did find one study looking at urban gardens (e.g. carrots grown in your backyard if you live in the city) and the levels were like 100x the Polish figures shown above.
- downrightmike 3y agoOdd how the only one that had levels in the teens was Lindt, from Europe. Seems like manufacturers could and should be doing more in the USA.
- Glant 3y agoNot sure if all Lindt products in the USA are made there, but they do have a manufacturing plant in New Hampshire.