4 ms·
Iran allows paying compensation to kidney donors. You can study how they are doing. Hint: they don't have much of a wait list. > I do not like the thought of
by eru 3y ago
Iran allows paying compensation to kidney donors. You can study how they are doing. Hint: they don't have much of a wait list.
> I do not like the thought of desperate people selling their internal organs to survive one bit.
See https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Repugnant_market https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Repugnant_market
Do you prefer desperate people have fewer options? Especially, do you prefer taking options from people that they prefer to take?
- mort96 3y ago> Do you prefer desperate people have fewer options? Yes. For an individual poor person, one could argue that the individual would be better off if they were allowed to sell their internal organs. But this isn't just about individuals, this is about societies. A society which pushes poor people towards selling their organs to survive is worse than a society which doesn't do that, in my opinion.
- mort96 3y agoThe extreme example would be: I think an IRL version of something like the Squid Game should be illegal, even though that means "desperate people have fewer options".
- taylorius 3y agoYes. Because the second order effects of giving those desperate people the option of donating their organs is worse for the society going forward.
- taylorius 3y agoYou can justify anything with that argument, no matter how horrific. Why not permit people to allow themselves be killed in entertaining ways, for a pay per view audience, with their surviving family getting 80% of the proceeds? It's possible that that would be the most money they will ever "earn". Don't you want to give poor people as many options as possible?
- eru 3y ago> Why not permit people to allow themselves be killed in entertaining ways, for a pay per view audience, with their surviving family getting 80% of the proceeds? We already allow shades of that, and society hasn't collapsed. Ie we seldom allow people to consent to outright death, but we certainly allow them to take on a great deal of risk of injury or death in return for fame or money. If you repeat a 1% chance often enough, you are going to hit the jackpot sooner or later. So I'm not sure your reductio ad absurdum works here.
- taylorius 3y agoWe certainly do allow such activities (MMA fights, extreme sports competitions etc). But such activities are fundamentally different in my view. While risky, they are not designed to permanently damage the competitor. If a participant emerges victorious and unscathed, they can enter next year's competition. That's not the case with selling a kidney (nor with my admittedly extreme example above).
- Suzuran 3y agoRemember, if you can sell it, then a debt collector can force you to sell it. I'd much rather say "People can't sell their organs" than have a future where debt collectors manipulate people into parting out their bodies.
- nyssos 3y ago> Remember, if you can sell it, then a debt collector can force you to sell it. This is not true at all. Debt collectors acting on their own can't take anything. A court can force you to sell certain things if you lose a lawsuit, but many assets are protected. They can't seize your 401k, in most states they can't take your primary residence unless the debt was taken on to purchase it in the first place, they can't garnish more than 25% of your income (and in some states can't garnish anything for consumer debt), they can't take social security income, and so on.