2 ms·
> Can we accept that "earth" can simply refer to the material that makes up the hard surface layer of a planet, as a different idea than "Earth" the planet afte
by thaumasiotes 3y ago
> Can we accept that "earth" can simply refer to the material that makes up the hard surface layer of a planet, as a different idea than "Earth" the planet after which it's named? Is that OK?
No, the planet is named after the substance, not the other way around.
- feoren 3y agoOf course I agree with you, which only strengthens my argument. But anyone who thinks we need to make up words like "Marsquake" clearly disagrees with you, and those are the people I am arguing against. It was a preemptive concession to ignore that point -- even if earth-the-material were named after Earth-the-planet, there's still no need to abandon the thousands of earth-related words as soon as we step foot on another planet. I felt that if I argued "Planet is named after material, therefore it's an earthquake" people would have missed the more important argument. (Not that any of this is particularly important.)