6 ms·
Tesla Model X Owner Has Had Enough of Minimalism, Adds Physical Buttons
- fidotron 3y agoMinimalism in the sense of overuse of capacitative interfaces is purely a cost cutting measure, not aesthetic. Moving parts == things which go wrong and need a lot of tedious installation and testing.
- digging 3y agoMaybe the installation and testing is tedious, but I have far more confidence in my 2008's physical radio buttons than an iPad glued to the dashboard. The only thing that's every gone wrong is the volume knob getting loose, and it's a minor annoyance which - crucially - doesn't affect any other functionality and could be easily replaced if I cared. Best of all, I don't have to take my eyes off the road to use them. Touchscreen controls are, frankly, idiotic in my opinion.
- wtallis 3y agoCapacitive buttons aren't just on touchscreens. It is now very widespread for cars to use capacitive touch sensors behind static labels. They're reliable in a way that touchscreens aren't and at least have fixed locations and functions, but the lack of tactile feedback still makes them an abomination.
- olyjohn 3y agoTouch screens still go bad all the time, just like buttons. Do they just put touch screen in cars and not test them? I don't see how a row of 12 buttons is any more difficult to test than a touch screen.
- joshl32532 3y agoThe dumbest "minimalism" was removing the turn signal stalk. That's how Teslas can keep their margins higher than the Detroit Big3. And no union helps Tesla I guess.
- mmanfrin 3y agoMy Model 3 has a turn signal stalk, unless you're talking about something other than the lever you tap up or down to turn on your signal. e: So apparently that's been removed in newer models. What a stupid fucking decision.
- mcpeepants 3y agoIt has been removed on the "refreshed" M3
- dzader 3y ago[dead]
- 542458 3y agoLots of news articles about this - they dropped it from the latest iteration of the 3 a little while ago, after dropping it from the S and X a couple years ago. https://www.forbes.com/sites/brookecrothers/2023/09/08/tesla-drops-the-stalk-on-model-3-highland-posing-safety-questions/?sh=371ed83039c4 https://www.forbes.com/sites/brookecrothers/2023/09/08/tesla...
- digging 3y agoThey're probably referring to this example in the first paragraph of TFA: > "the replacement of turn signal stalks with steering wheel buttons on the facelifted Model 3"
- rcdemski 3y agoThey removed them on the Model S and replaced them with capacitive steering wheel buttons when they launched the steering yoke
- sp332 3y agoModel S a couple years ago https://jalopnik.com/lets-bitch-about-teslas-removal-of-the-turn-signal-stal-1846151374 https://jalopnik.com/lets-bitch-about-teslas-removal-of-the-... Model 3 recently https://www.forbes.com/sites/brookecrothers/2023/09/08/tesla-drops-the-stalk-on-model-3-highland-posing-safety-questions/ https://www.forbes.com/sites/brookecrothers/2023/09/08/tesla...
- kelsey9876543 3y ago[flagged]
- pavon 3y agoPart of what makes physical controls better on standard cars is that their diversity of size, shape and feel makes them easier to identify by touch. A knob on the left for volume, a button in the middle of the knob for radio on/off, a pair of buttons for scanning stations, etc. My CRV has a strip of identical buttons along the side of the display, and I find them just bad as touch screen for all but the top and bottom buttons. I imagine this would have simular issues.
- m3kw9 3y agoNot sure why they haven’t used tactile vibrations on the screens like iPhones but stronger and more accurate plus finger hovering sensors to indicate/enlarge the button focus when your fingers get close. Part of hardware buttons is getting an instant feed back that you’ve switched it without looking.
- nvy 3y agoBecause those things cost money. Tesla went with the touch screen as a cost cutting measure.
- pests 3y agoI don't think the screens are even "automotive grade" - not meeting temp and vibration standards that it will definitely experience in a moving vehicle exposed to the elements. This is how Tesla was able to use such a large screen for so long while other manufacturers have yet to catch up.
- fgsfds028374 3y ago[dead]
- Kirby64 3y agoThat's the older Model S screens (the vertical ones). As far as I know all the current models are automotive grade.
- iambateman 3y agoIf you are a “passenger” sitting in a car being driven by Tesla, the massive screen makes a lot of sense. Tesla would get more credit for their approach if full-self driving were more complete - and I believe Tesla thought they would be further along with FSD than they are. As it stands, driving a car with a massive screen is annoying and relatively dangerous.
- imilk 3y ago> I believe Tesla thought they would be further along with FSD than they are Well Musk has been promising that it will be fully ready next year for the last decade. Which sounds like a horrendous expectation to work under as an engineer.
- digging 3y ago> Tesla thought they would be further along with FSD than they are That's because they have either been lying or willfully ignorant of how insanely hard FSD is. Their engineers know what the physical challenges are, but I don't know about leadership.
- digging 3y ago"This is a pretty cool mod if you can't live without buttons in your car, but it obviously defeats the whole purpose of minimalism." I don't even agree that the tablet is minimalism. The tablet interface is complicated, dense, and compact. That is not even what minimalism means, it's just the arrogant vision of one stupid futurist. (I know Musk is intelligent, but not nearly as much as he thinks he is, which is how I like to define stupidity. Perhaps I'm using it more as an opposite to "wise" than "intelligent"?) Minimalism is about having less detail. I mean technically minimalism is an art movement, but using it in the modern sense, minimalist car UI design would have to remove options that control things precisely. So unless the Tesla's tablet interface has fewer capabilities than a traditional dashboard, there's nothing minimalist about it. In some senses, it's less minimalist than a good traditional dashboard because it adds a very stupid layer of complexity.
- nwsm 3y ago"We moved all the options into a screen. That's minimalism right?" Sure, if your definition of minimalism is the physical aesthetic of the car when it's turned off and you don't need to interact with it in any way.
- Xymist 3y ago"The occupant doesn't need to interact with it in any way" is, I think, an actual design goal for Tesla. Not that they'll get there, probably, but to have people get in, touch nothing, and get out at their destination does fit the evident dream.
- rs999gti 3y ago> minimalism More like minimalism in terms of cost. A tablet can be used in many cars as an interface, the only cost is the different software for each model. No need to make molds and manufacture physical buttons and a console.
- fgsfds028374 3y ago[dead]
- par 3y agoNothing makes me more upset, as a builder/tinkerer, is when I spend money on a expensive/luxury technical product that I have to iterate on to make it acceptable for basic functions.
- BillyTheMage 3y agoPersonally I consider luxury items to be inherently broken and avoid them at all costs. They're just expensive, almost never of any actual quality. Status symbols and whatnot.
- mrguyorama 3y agoWhen you buy something expensive that has lavish marketing, you can be pretty sure most of the difference in price went to marketing.
- n1b0m 3y agoCould someone please explain how this works? How do the physical buttons control the touchscreen?
- rob74 3y agoThe article is pretty light on details and pretty heavy on empty phrases like "To each their own, we guess. Like it or hate it, owners are free to personalize their vehicles". As a Hacker News reader, I'm mostly interested in how this "hack" works, but the article unfortunately doesn't offer any details on that (ok, at least they warn you that the video is in Mandarin, so a few seconds saved there).
- digging 3y agoAgreed, the article is more like throwing a lit match into a barn than educating a good hacker. I think there's some good discussion happening here about design but on reflection this whole thread probably doesn't need to exist because nobody is learning how to hack their Tesla's dashboard.
- bo1024 3y agoYeah, how does it work!?
- masto 3y agoThere has been a set of buttons available for a while from a popular aftermarket vendor (https://abstractocean.com/products/s3xy-buttons https://abstractocean.com/products/s3xy-buttons) that interface through the OBD2 port. There is a good amount of reverse-engineered information out there on Tesla CAN bus messages (e.g. https://github.com/joshwardell/model3dbc https://github.com/joshwardell/model3dbc). If you have some coding and electronics experience, it'd pretty much be a matter of gluing some libraries together. Probably easier than gluing the physical buttons to the car.
- Kirby64 3y agoAlmost certainly via wiring into the CAN bus. There's quite a few aftermarket addons that require you to run a line to the internal CAN bus to have certain things function (like popping the trunk, for instance). I've also seen some Bluetooth based ones that require using your phone, which then relay to the Tesla app to perform functions. Not sure who's using those quite frankly, seems like a bad solution. Also this panel appears to do thing you cannot do in the Tesla app, so I don't think it's using that method.
- kristopolous 3y agoI was test driving recently and it's crazy how many cars have gone all in on the screen-only interfaces. Only the cheaper models still have the tactile haptic interfaces. Tesla is the Apple of the car world - they've been christened the virtuous God and thus things must be created in their image. It's absurd. If someone loved Teslas, they'd go buy one. They're looking at, say, Hyundais, because they already said no to Tesla - so stop trying to be a knockoff. I blame the managers for this. Copying tesla is the CYA move.
- digging 3y agoThing is, Apple actually improved things by making phones (almost) all-touch. Touchscreen phones fucking rule, despite the challenges presented, because there are so many different applications you need to control on your phone that physical buttons would be pretty cumbersome and would always feel like a poor hack. A car does not have the same functionality or purpose. Touchscreens are a distinct step backward when replacing radio and lighting controls. I'm not going to play Baldur's Gate 2 on a damn Tesla because I have to drive it, and if I didn't have to drive it in a world where self-driving was good, I'd just play it on my damn phone. (Actually I'd play it on my Steam Deck, because the physical controls are best-in-class.)
- kristopolous 3y agoRight but that's not it with Apple. Things like multiple SIMs, microSD, headphone jacks --- early android phones even had micro-hdmi ports and removable batteries. They also used to be a more convenient form-factor before Apple started trending towards phablets. It also took about a dozen years before they would not easily crack because Apple, and thus the rest of the industry, insisted on a design that looked more like a fashion accessory than something you use on a daily basis. Every move Apple did, basically the entire industry cloned. iPhones are readily available. If a consumer wanted it they'd get it. Instead of the much vaulted diversity or thousand flowers supposedly blooming, you just get different brands of the same decisions. This goes back to a Ries&Trout quote from the 90s: If your competitor is selling coca-cola, it's probably easier to start selling snapple than wannabe coca-cola. But that's not what tech does. Instead, a designated leader is deputized king bullshitter and all the other players chase it. It was anathema to progress when Microsoft occupied that space in the 90s and it's still that way today.
- jmyeet 3y agoTouch screens are cheap and lazy design. Worse, it's more dangerous because physical interfaces have tactile feedback so you can use them to some degree without looking at them. It's more dangerous too. On a phone it makes sense because of limited real estate and mixed utility. The real reason car manufacturers do it is to push design problems into being software problems. Sucky UI? We can fix it in a software update! We can ship sooner too because we can update later. This is cheaper and faster than having to think through the UI/UX before you build it. I don't know anyone who likes driving a giant iPad.
- norir 3y agoI think an interesting approach might be a hybrid system that works with both touch and physical buttons. The bottom of the screen could have some generic buttons that could be used to navigate the interface eyes free with some optional audio feedback. For example, I'd imagine a row of buttons like in the OP where maybe the left two buttons are up and down. Depending on the context, the buttons do different things but those two always mean up and down although up and down might mean volume up/down, fans up/down or menu scroll up and down. The screen could then give huge display feedback for those things that wouldn't require much if any driver attention. The nice thing about the touch is that it allows for a giant display that requires less visual attention when used in conjunction with buttons. It also gives flexibility to add (hopefully inessential but pleasant) functionality or fix interface design mistakes after the fact. It just shouldn't be the primary interface while driving. Like I have no problem with the audio system having an eq app with just a touch ui because I probably don't need to adjust eq when driving, unlike say volume which ideally would just be a physical knob or rocker. But yes I agree that most current touch interface are horrible lowest common denominator solutions. They are easyish to learn but tend to require significant visual attention which is obviously poor design for something that is used when driving.
- photonbucket 3y agoI wasn't able to find a link to the original video or where I could get a similar device. Anyone able to help?
- Justsignedup 3y agoI love the marketing: Let's make the most uncomplicated to manufacture design possible, with basically a touch screen, and we can design the software forever, and call it "minimalism". Meanwhile it is not minimalistic or simple. As it has been said in many contexts before "make things as simple as possible, but no simpler" I chose a Mazda as my car because of the physical knobs they put in to control the infotainment, I absolutely swear by it, and I love it. It is far less distracting then trying to tap a spot on a screen while my hand is shaking due to small bumps on the road while I'm desperately trying to not look away from the road itself.
- Terr_ 3y agoIMO while capacitative surfaces are often bad design for car controls, it's worth noting that it's a strong correlation but not absolute. It's technically possible to make a capacitative button (A) always in the same spot and (B) textured and (C) gives audio/haptic feedback when activated and (D) isn't activated by the merest exploratory brush. Satisfy those "do it by touch" requirements, and the kind of switch underneath becomes an implementation detail.
- happytiger 3y agoDriving a 2016 Land Cruiser and then immediately going to drive a Model 3 right afterwards was shocking. The Land Cruiser ergonomics were so good and everything was physical and I didn’t have to think about much (except for the air conditioning which is a pain in the ass — and is touch screen). The Model 3 made me do work and I noticed myself talking to it a lot while I hunted around for stuff and looking at the screen a LOT while operating the car. It’s a good touch screen but touch screens without haptics are a broken paradigm. Software defined cars demand them I guess, but it is something I absolutely hated about the Tesla. I can’t speak for others, but for me the gigantic touchscreen was a net negative and put me off the car.
- sotix 3y agoI would have maybe kept my Tesla if it came with this! The software update in December 2021 that moved the buttons for features like the defroster that I had grown accustomed to over 2 years of use was maddening.
- dakial1 3y agoCars are the best example of how decades of usability tests, feedback and research can evolve the UX of the driver tremendously. How many things we do at the car without even looking at the controls (because we need to pay attention to the road). Then comes the industry "foreigners", ignore everything that was learnt and put all controls behind the screens "because we need to be minimalist". Now the UX inside the car is worse because drivers need to look to the screen (and away from the road) to find the AC control (I had a though time finding it on a Polestar the other day).