8 ms·
X Won't Demonetize Russell Brand, the Company Tells Pro-Censorship British MPs
- samketchup 3y agoDon't care for the guy but I believe bad people should be allowed to make money. I have an issue with advertisers bullying platforms to remove bad guys, but that's the way it works.
- webdood90 3y ago> I believe bad people should be allowed to make money yeah, misleading people on the internet is big business
- wand3r 3y ago> yeah, misleading people on the internet is big business So what? In America, unless you violate FDA or SEC (or similar) agencies, or are slandering or libelling, its not illegal. Also, who is the arbiter of what is "true" in your comment above? Not everything has a fact based logical answer that is generally accepted. Should pastors be kicked off YT for "misleading" people about heaven? Free speech protects EVERYONE's right to speak because from someone else's point of view, you are the one that is misleading someone. Also, in terms of Brand, or other cases, an allegation can be settled in many courts. Once adjudicated, it is appropriate to consider action.
- fzeroracer 3y agoHow do you feel about Purdue Pharma and the opioid epidemic?
- wand3r 3y agoI was personally affected and have a very nuanced thoughts about this and policy generally. However, they are not outside the spirit of what I said above? Purdue did run afoul of FDA guidelines. Regardless, US drug policy is very broken.
- webdood90 3y ago> So what? if you're asking this question then we don't have anything to talk about
- wand3r 3y agoI'm being flippant but I stand by my point. I think your line of thinking is what leads to things like the DSA in Europe. Laws already exist so when you say "bad people" who are you referring to? People breaking laws but they haven't been charged? Or people you personally are defining as morally bad?
- swatcoder 3y agoIt's reasonable for advertisers to care about where their ads appear and what content they're associated with. It's been part of placement strategy for as long as modern advertising has existed. Magazines/broadcasts/websites naturally need to be sensitive to that because advertisers are ultimately their clients. It's far less reasonable for governments to use their authority to intervene between those parties, at least without clear legal justification and prior exercise of due process.
- coldacid 3y agoThis is why the value4value model is morally superior to the advertisement financed model.
- samketchup 3y agoIn the morning to ya!
- underseacables 3y agoIs this a No Agenda reference on Hacker News!?
- nvm0n2 3y agoI don't associate companies with whatever random things their ads appear next to, I don't even remember it. I'm pretty sure this is also true for 99.9% of other people. This brand safety stuff is just an excuse for woke marketing staffers to feel like they're "making a difference" by attacking people and companies they don't like.
- gottorf 3y ago> This brand safety stuff is just an excuse for woke marketing staffers to feel like they're "making a difference" The incentive structures are clear: you do nothing and maybe get fired if your company gets embroiled in a controversy due to the placement of those ads, or you pull your ads and spend that budget in another channel, and worse case nothing will happen to you, and best case you'll be praised for proactive thinking. Woke or not, I'd imagine most people would choose the latter; the former is mostly downside with limited upside.
- cactusplant7374 3y agoAre you saying YouTube is a public utility like telephones? To me it's an application that could be replaced by another application one day. Not necessarily Rumble but maybe something else. But if you don't think it's a utility, it would be strange to believe they should be regulated like one.
- olyjohn 3y agoLand line telephones got replaced by cell phones. That didn't make land lines less of a utility. Anything could be replaced somewhere down the road. You don't really have a choice with regards to your YouTube usage, currently. There isn't anything near YouTube, and due to it's currently-established presence, we won't realistically see it getting replaced any time soon.
- cactusplant7374 3y agoThere are plenty of sites at feature parity. I don't see why anything else is relevant.
- netsharc 3y agoWould you have a problem with "Please watch this ad for samketchup's product before watching this blogger's pro-Hamas video!"? Remember, free speech means the blogger is allowed to say what they say...
- Meekro 3y agoNot the GP poster, but I would honestly be okay with that because I actually believe in free speech. As we discovered over the last 2 weeks, though, many colleges (including at least half of the ivy league) are also okay with pro-Hamas rallies -- not because they believe in free speech, but because they've chosen a side.
- khazhoux 3y ago> As we discovered over the last 2 weeks, though, many colleges (including at least half of the ivy league) are also okay with pro-Hamas rallies -- not because they believe in free speech, but because they've chosen a side. Were the rallies actually pro-Hamas, or pro-Palestine?
- Meekro 3y agoThat's a fair question. I'm sure some attendees are pro-Palestine, but many of the important organizers might not be. I've seen a few things over the last 2 weeks that led me to this impression: * While speaking at an off-campus event, Cornell professor Russell Rickford described the massacre of Israelis as "exhilarating" and "energizing". You can find plenty of citations (including video) by Googling his name; most of them come from right-wing news sources, but unfortunately the liberal newspapers didn't deem this worth mentioning. * Many examples of the protesters chanting "from the river to the sea, Palestine will be free". Wikipedia actually has an article about this phrase, which originates from before Gaza and the West Bank were controlled by Israel. In other words, the term "Palestine" referred to something other than West Bank/Gaza when that slogan was originated. In the true meaning of that phrase, "Palestine" refers to the entire region of which modern-day Israel is a subset, and "free" means "no Israel". All of this lines up with the Hamas worldview. * Black Lives Matter tweeted a picture saying "I stand with Palestine" that had a picture of a man on a paraglider. [1] That's a reference to Hamas terrorists using paragliders to cross checkpoints at the Gaza border, and then murdering innocents (including women, children, and babies). Again, the words-as-written on that tweet just reference "Palestine" while the picture makes it perfectly clear who they really stand with. Also, I'm sorry for citing exclusively right-wing sources. I swear this really happened, and is being reported correctly here; it's just that liberal sources won't cover it. [1] https://thepostmillennial.com/breaking-blm-chicago-deletes-infamous-pro-hamas-post https://thepostmillennial.com/breaking-blm-chicago-deletes-i...
- Clubber 3y ago>I have an issue with advertisers bullying platforms to remove bad guys, but that's the way it works. Yes, you'd think in 2023, platform companies could just disassociate advertisers with channels rather than just kicking someone off the platform. You don't want your ads on Brand's channel? Just uncheck the "show ads on this channel" box. I'm fairly certain that's available, but companies want people completely silenced and use their advertising money as leverage to do so, which is significantly more insidious.
- jmull 3y ago> I have an issue with advertisers bullying platforms to remove bad guys If businesses don't get to decide how to spend their money on advertising, who does?
- progne 3y agoX > Youtube on this. Demonetizing on suspicion makes slander overpowered. This is an example of the quality of the signal being improved by politically diverse media ownership. Having media moguls who are ideologically disaligned with one another makes for less centrally controlled speech.
- Meekro 3y agoThis is definitely right. It's amazing how quickly presumption of innocence goes out the window when the accused is from the enemy tribe. In this case, it's a person who hasn't even been formally indicted, much less convicted beyond a reasonable doubt. Do people really think that any sort of public accusation should be enough to have you punished, or does that only apply to people they don't like?
- jacknews 3y agoI don't know why they're even responding to the request to be honest. Whether or not you're a fan of Russell Brand, a government 'asking' media to stop paying/employing someone they don't like, without a legal mandate, is a very obvious contravention of a free society.
- fuzzbazz 3y agoTo make it public would be a good reason.
- zarzavat 3y agoThe UK is not a free society and has not been for a long time. We long since sacrificed our civil rights at the altar of various boogiemen: criminals, terrorists, immigrants, nonces, rapists. The one thing that the two major parties have consistently agreed over the years is that our rights are a danger to ourselves. This kind of thing is just par for the course in our performative democracy where the media holds the true power and the politicians’ only way to get ahead is to prostitute themselves to the media, particularly Murdoch. This letter to Twitter is one such performance.
- georgespencer 3y agoThe parent you're replying to does not appear to have read the letter in question. Have you? 1. The letter was sent by the Select Committee responsible for overseeing the Department of Culture, Media and Sport. 2. This Select Committee is not the government. It is in fact a bipartisan oversight committee comprised of Conservative, Labour, and SNP members of parliament. 3. The Select Committee has a responsibility to provide oversight for the Department of Culture, Media and Sport, to influence its priorities, and to understand the people, communities, and entities (companies, sports teams, arts galleries) to whom the Department has a responsibility. 4. One way that Select Committees do this is to request testimony and insight from relevant people/communities/entities -- particularly where they are at the forefront of something new or newsworthy which is within the Department/Committee's wheelhouse. 5. The remit of the Department is highly relevant to the Brand allegations. Most directly, the Department is largely responsible for the government's relationship and enthusiasm for funding the BBC, where Brand was employed at the time one victim alleges he abused her. 6. It is specifically part of the job of departments like DCMS, and their oversight committees, to promote the positions of government in areas outside of policy and law. 7. Nobody here is sacrificing any rights. You do not need to acquiesce to a parliamentary request. Zuckerberg has refused multiple requests for testimony both live and via Zoom. X refused to provide any information beyond what is publicly available. Brand did not have a right to due process with YouTube before he was de-monetised. Zuckerberg, X, Rumble, Brand, etc. have experienced zero change in their rights and legal protection within the United Kingdom before, during, or after they were asked for testimony. On to the rest: > The UK is not a free society I find myself writing this more and more frequently on HN: I know that you're just trying to be emphatic, but it's not generally helpful to make extremely exaggerated statements for effect. There is clearly a plurality of thought on what constitutes freedom and a free society, but it is utterly uncontroversial to say that the United Kingdom, like all modern developed nations operating something which looks and smells a bit like democratically-elected officials, is as free as it gets in the world. What specifically is your special standard of "freedom" which is not being met by the UK at the moment? > We long since sacrificed our civil rights I must have missed this! Which rights in particular? > at the altar of various boogiemen Unless we forewent our civil rights because of a dance troupe I think you mean "bogeymen"! > criminals, terrorists, immigrants, nonces, rapists All intentional communities - companies, countries, camping trips, whatever - evolve and iterate on their values and protocols as time goes by. For example: prior to 9/11, it was perfectly logical that cockpit doors be open during flights and made of unremarkable materials. As soon as somebody decided to start flying planes into buildings, we began closing and locking cockpit doors, and reenforcing them. So hopefully you agree that societies and their leaders get new information from time to time which requires them to change things? I'd love to know, and I mean this in a spirit of genuine curiosity, which specific civil rights were afforded to you in your lifetime but which were then stripped due to your list of bogey/boogie-men. For example, what are you legally prohibited from doing today which you once were not, as a result of pedophiles (nonces to non-UK readers)? > The one thing that the two major parties have consistently agreed over the years is that our rights are a danger to ourselves. Again I know this is a rhetorical device, but no major UK party or member of a major UK party has made the claim that "our rights are a danger to ourselves". For one thing it's such a facile thing to say that they would probably be mocked for saying it, but even if you pretend it isn't lowest common denominator conspiratorial nonsense, there are very few examples of orchestrated bipartisan efforts to curtail civil rights at all – let alone any which do not have widespread public support or a plausible public good as their intended outcome. > This kind of thing is just par for the course in our performative democracy where the media holds the true power Oh brother. > and the politicians' only way to get ahead is to prostitute themselves to the media, particularly Murdoch. Ah yes, of course! Who can forget Joe Biden's cozy relationship with FOX News in the run-up to the 2020 election? And of course Keir Starmer's seemingly-unassailable lead in the polls is black magic from Labour's propaganda arm, News International. I'm being facetious but you see my point: say what you mean. I would consider the two examples I provided to be disproof of your claim that "the politicians' only way to get ahead is to prostitute themselves to the media", which is the kind of bubblegum thing people say unchallenged, but which really doesn't appear to be the case. Trump is the GOP frontrunner and he openly derides the entire mainstream media including FOX News. tl;dr: if you understand the responsibility of this committee, then you understand that this is an entirely appropriate and necessary letter for them to write. If you read the letter, then you understand that it is benign. And finally, I'm guessing here, if you try to enumerate specific civil rights you have lost down the years, you'll fall some way short of what I, a reasonable person (hehe) would consider sufficient to say "the UK is not a free society". But maybe!
- speak_plainly 3y agoMany politicians and elites in the UK seem to believe that the only way to weather the storm of a declining society is to take away the rights of its citizenry. It's a shallow attempt at self preservation by the rich and powerful and that's simply not going to work in the modern era. The only thing that will work and will protect their cushioned existence is if they work to improve the lives of citizens, like not in token ways, perhaps not even monetarily, but meaningfully. Few are buying into these nonsensical 'safety' arguments and the good will of everyone is being stretched.
- coldacid 3y agoNot just in the UK!
- generic92034 3y ago> Few are buying into these nonsensical 'safety' arguments and the good will of everyone is being stretched. Are you sure there is any good will left?
- arein2 3y ago>and that's simply not going to work in the modern era It was working until Elon bought twitter.
- georgespencer 3y ago> Many politicians and elites I hate to break it to you, person of the people, but anyone with your raw intellect (proxies: commenting on Hacker News, above average vocabulary and English proficiency, somewhat thoughtful opinions about abstract notions such as civil rights and sociology) is axiomatically an elite. (What do you consider the 'elite' to be, btw?) > in the UK seem to believe that the only way to weather the storm of a declining society is to take away the rights of its citizenry. Is somebody taking away citizens' rights? Which ones? How did you read this letter and conclude that it was sensible to begin discussing the erosion of civil rights? Did you read the letter? Do you understand what a select committee is?
- autoexec 3y ago> It's a shallow attempt at self preservation by the rich and powerful and that's simply not going to work in the modern era. I'd say it's working for them very well so far. The commoners may no longer believe the bullshit excuses, but they've still proved powerless to prevent the erosion of their freedoms. The rich and powerful are only getting richer and more powerful while the gap between them and everyone else widens. You call it "a shallow attempt at self preservation" but they're not just surviving, they're thriving.
- shipscode 3y agoWhat's the likelihood that pharmaceutical companies paid his accusers due to his anti-pharmaceutical media appearances? The timing is extremely coincidental.
- kolektiv 3y agoNot very likely? I mean sure, it's theoretically possible, but like all conspiracies it requires a lot of people to keep a very juicy secret perfectly, so... probably not. The number of people previously well disposed towards pharmaceutical companies that are now not because of Russell Brand probably doesn't have the boards quaking in their boots either - the likely shareholder overlap is not high.
- Theodores 3y agoThe notion that a conspiracy requires the silence of thousands is a myth. All that is needed is for one person or a small group of people to be a few steps ahead of everyone else and able to manipulate the narrative.
- KaiserPro 3y ago> What's the likelihood that pharmaceutical companies paid his accusers due to his anti-pharmaceutical media appearances not very high, its the UK after all. moreover, the evidence of him being a utter shite predates him going off the deepend by quite some way.
- giobox 3y ago> moreover, the evidence of him being a utter shite predates him going off the deepend by quite some way. When I was a lad, we still had this weird concept in the UK's various legal systems of "innocent until proven guilty". The pressure to end his sources of income in the absence of any kind of legitimate justice process, especially from elected officials, is pretty shameful, and I say this as someone who can't stand him either.
- 3y ago
- motohagiography 3y agoRemoving someones ability to defend themselves against serious allegations by cutting them off from their ability to make money to pay for said defense undermines the integrity of the legal system itself. It's a thumb on the scale. These people believe in nothing.
- KaiserPro 3y ago> Removing someones ability to defend themselves against serious allegations by cutting them off from their ability to make money to pay for said defence is not how the uk courts work(ed) thats what legal aid is for. granted in practice now its not the case, but for any crown court there is still legal aid for most cases.
- bensecure 3y ago"thats what legal aid is for" - public defenders are famously underpaid and overworked in most environs. If you rely on them for your defense it will be very poor.
- AYBABTME 3y agoThat's a ridiculous fallback to the actual problem: preemptively cutting someone's livelihood ahead of a battle. An alternative: let's send the defendant to public housing before they head to court. They'll still have a roof over their head!
- georgespencer 3y agoAlmost as ridiculous as trying to argue that anyone in this situation is "preemptively cutting someone's livelihood ahead of a battle". If you read the letter and believe that the government is requesting, or that X and Rumble are agreeing to, the de-monetisation of Brand's content, then we should address a reading comprehension challenge. If you can see that this -- "preemptively cutting someone's livelihood" -- is definitely not happening, then I would encourage you to more precisely convey what you mean, because this attempt almost perfectly expresses the opposite of reality.
- elil17 3y agoIt makes absolutely no sense to demonetize someone's online content for an alleged crime when that crime has nothing to do with the content.
- skymast 3y ago[dead]
- skilled 3y agoRussell is a tank and handling the situation in a very mature manner. He is still doing his show and not talking about the allegations whatsoever. If it goes to court then he will address it as it comes, as he should. This is a pathetic which hunt by the UK, and any platform giving in to nonsense like this is a serious red flag. Is YouTube going to fire its CEO if I make an allegation against him/her? How is me doing that any different than Russell’s current situation? What’s with the weird scapegoating and not respecting “innocent until proven guilty” … This topic/situation really makes my blood boil.
- woah 3y agoRussell is a weird creep but governments should not be going around and asking companies to censor people without a legal basis.
- _ea1k 3y agoThere are weird lines here in general. The court of public opinion plays a major role in where major advertisers are willing to spend their money, regardless of guilt or proof of guilt. But should we treat platform monetization the same way? I hope not, but I can see why there are advocates on that side.
- autoexec 3y ago> Is YouTube going to fire its CEO if I make an allegation against him/her? How is me doing that any different than Russell’s current situation? I really do get what you're saying, but you making an accusation against youtube's CEO would be very different from Russell’s current situation For the comparison to work your accusation would need to be only one of several similar allegations, made by multiple people, with varying degrees of evidence, covering a span of many years. Bonus points if you and the other accusers had a Channel 4 documentary released about your accusations.
- efitz 3y agoI hope they responded with a poo emoji. That was classic.
- jeroenhd 3y agoTwitter's free speech ideals are arbitrary at best. Asking Twitter to take action before this man will eventually be convinced is wrong, but portraying Twitter as some kind of free speech activist when Musk will ban and block as he sees fit when people are mean to him is just wrong. From what I can tell this has very little to do with free speech in the first place, this is more about a company entering a business partnership with a man under investigation for sexual crimes and stalking. They're not asking Twitter to ban him, just to (re)consider their position on doing business with him. Twitter decides per account if they can or can't make money by tweeting, so their decision in this regard do reflect on the company. Brand having proven to be a conspiracy nutjob during COVID should be enough reason for any business not to to business with him, but Musk does seem to attract a certain crowd. I can't say I'm very surprised by Twitter's response other than the fact they responded in the first place; I thought Twitter fired their PR team during the mass exodus when Musk took over.
- foogazi 3y agoCouldn’t the UK block access to his bank accounts via legal mandate if they wanted to ? Why ask private company to do the government’s work ?
- underseacables 3y agoI think a person should only be demonetized if they are convicted of a crime. Accusations alone should not be enough.