3 ms·
I have no problem with "carrying Google's water" in this case. They have as much right to computing freedom as we do. They should totally get to enjoy that free
by matheusmoreira 3y ago
I have no problem with "carrying Google's water" in this case. They have as much right to computing freedom as we do. They should totally get to enjoy that freedom on Apple devices. As should we.
This is completely independent from Google's surveillance capitalism problem. We should deal with that separately by turning personal information into massive liability. Society should make it so it costs them literal truckloads of money to know even a single bit of information about any human being. They should be scrambling to forget all about us the second we're done transacting with them.
> sell a mobile console appliance
Nope. I personally don't believe such things should be allowed to exist at all. Computers should always be real computers at all times. This "appliance" nonsense is everything that is wrong with computing today. Infinite potential, wasted.
- dontlaugh 3y agoCompanies have no rights. Only people do.
- tempodox 3y ago> They have as much right to computing freedom as we do. Except they tirelessly work on taking computing freedom away from you.
- matheusmoreira 3y agoYou sure about that? Google's been one of the better companies when it comes to free and open source work. Their phones are significantly more free than their competition. It's ironic, they sell the easiest phones to install custom operating systems on. They even put in work into open firmware for their chromebook laptops. It's certainly something I've come to appreciate about them, despite their surveillance capitalism.
- fiddlerwoaroof 3y agoI switched away from Android in part because I wanted a phone that was just an appliance that always worked. I enjoyed fiddling with alternative ROMs and such but I eventually realized that, as a tinkerer, the only way to make sure my phone always worked when I needed it was to pick a device I couldn’t root and tinker with. I think the market is big enough for both models and we’re all worse off if the users that want the Apple experience are unable to pick it.
- nervlord 3y ago[dead]
- nerdix 3y agoJust because you can root and tinker with something doesn't mean you have to. Millions of people use Android phones without ever having touched a third party rom (or even have the knowledge that they exist). Additionally, Apple allowing a user to install a browser with a rendering engine other than webkit does not preclude a completely different user from experiencing the "Apple experience". The default experience will be the Apple experience. I really don't understand this common sentiment that more freedom for a user to use a device in the manner in which they want to somehow takes away the freedom of others.
- fiddlerwoaroof 3y agoI know myself well enough to know that I need a phone that prevents me from tinkering if I want a device that works reliably.
- matheusmoreira 3y agoThese days Android is just a worse iOS anyway. All the freedom we used to have was wiped out by hardware remote attestation. If you tinker with anything, your phone will fail attestation and you'll be refused service everywhere. Might as well buy into the better kept garden if that's how it's going to be. I have exactly two reasons to still prefer Android: Termux and GrapheneOS. Who knows what Google's going to break next though? There's already hints that the Linux system calls used by Termux will be sandboxed away someday. If that happens, there's no reason for me to use Android anymore. Stuff like remote attestation should be illegal. They should be required by law to interoperate with you no matter what software you choose to run.
- Terretta 3y ago> I personally don't believe such things should be allowed to exist at all. Computers should always be real computers at all times. This "appliance" nonsense is everything that is wrong with computing today. Infinite potential, wasted. This is great! This is the actual argument, so the clarity is wonderful. If your starting point is to argue that NO manufacturer can be permitted to make a handheld mobile appliance (e.g., to phones what Switch or the PlayStation Portable [PSP] are to consoles) as a market alternative to mobile general computing devices, then, 100% agree that means there's no place for iPhone or iPad. But then this seems weird, because these days everything has a computer in it, digital machinery to go along with mechanical machinery, and it's not clear why we get mad at Apple about "right to tinker" (that's not a real thing even though competitors attack competitors by gaslighting about it) without getting mad at all of these things. It's not clear to me nobody should be allowed to fully integrate software and hardware (which are "just" different amounts of machinery or logic permanence embedded in one user experience), whether they allow "apps" as pluggable cartridges or not. To borrow a non-computing utility tool metaphor: I consider the iPhone like a Leatherman™ tool. The maker works with people like me to decide an ideal mix of tools a Leatherman™ should be, perhaps offer me a few different tool mixes or sizes. I choose a known-good configuration I want, then I don't expect or need to be able to plug random third party accessories to the Leatherman™. I find it anti computing freedom (as well as anti-libertarian and anti-capitalist) to forbid Makers™ from using their computing freedom to offer the marketplace an appliance that can take pictures or make phone calls or plug in apps. The computer form lets you invent new configurations (like a box of Legos turned into a model), then the appliance form lets others use it (like 3D printing the model). That should be OK. So we disagree on the real argument, and that's fair. I have a question though, what does this mean: > Infinite potential, wasted. I find dedicated gaming PCs far more wasteful of time and materials than consoles: wasteful of materials to have a predictable gaming experience, wasteful of time between wanting to be able to play a game and playing them, wasteful of time on an ongoing basis maintaining the ability to play a game. (I say this as a person who made a living building and selling "beige box" computers in college, and who values understanding how to build a computer from parts.) I'd argue that for casual gaming, consoles -- which also use fewer non-renewable materials than a PC sufficiently powered for equivalent game performance -- save far more time and materials "per gaming-hour" than they waste. Yes, some of us have to learn to build tomorrow's consoles, but most just want to play a game. As in my opening remark, I believe our job as engineers is to learn, build, and deliver the "capability" to game, tailored to and fit for purpose. But "infinite potential" is a lot of potential to be wasting -- what potential is unable to be met if allowing Apple to offer an appliance alongside others offering general devices?
- rodgerd 3y ago>Nope. I personally don't believe such things should be allowed to exist at all. "Everyone has to be a linux sysadmin to keep me happy, you aren't allowed things I don't want you to have."
- matheusmoreira 3y agoYes? I do consider computing freedom to be far more important than whatever convenience is gained by allowing them to do this. We should always be able to run our own software at all times with no restrictions. If that turns everyone into a "linux sysadmin" I'm okay with that. Better than a future where our computers come pwned straight off the factory, where we need permission from corporations and governments to write and execute software.
- rodgerd 3y agoYou have the same relationship with 'computer freedom' that Stalin had to the freedom of the proletariat.